Anomalies of Generalized Symmetries from Solitonic Defects

Lakshya Bhardwaj, Mathew Bullimore, Andrea E. V. Ferrari, Sakura Schäfer‐Nameki

Abstract

We propose the general idea that 't Hooft anomalies of generalized global symmetries can be understood in terms of the properties of solitonic defects, which generically are non-topological defects. The defining property of such defects is that they act as sources for background fields of generalized symmetries. 't Hooft anomalies arise when solitonic defects are charged under these generalized symmetries. We illustrate this idea for several kinds of anomalies in various spacetime dimensions. A systematic exploration is performed in 3d for 0-form, 1-form, and 2-group symmetries, whose 't Hooft anomalies are related to two special types of solitonic defects, namely vortex line defects and monopole operators. This analysis is supplemented with detailed computations of such anomalies in a large class of 3d gauge theories. Central to this computation is the determination of the gauge and 0-form charges of a variety of monopole operators: these involve standard gauge monopole operators, but also fractional gauge monopole operators, as well as monopole operators for 0-form symmetries. The charges of these monopole operators mainly receive contributions from Chern-Simons terms and fermions in the matter content. Along the way, we interpret the vanishing of the global gauge and ABJ anomalies, which are anomalies not captured by local anomaly polynomials, as the requirement that gauge monopole operators and mixed monopole operators for 0-form and gauge symmetries have non-fractional integer charges.

Introduction

In modern theoretical physics, generalized global symmetries—which act on extended objects like lines and surfaces—are essential for understanding the phases of matter. A crucial property of these symmetries is the 't Hooft anomaly, an obstruction to "gauging" the symmetry. Traditionally, calculating these anomalies involves defining the theory on a compact spacetime manifold and checking the invariance of the partition function under background gauge transformations. This approach often requires complex topological considerations and is difficult to apply to lattice systems where compact manifolds are not naturally defined.

This paper introduces a more physical and intuitive framework: calculating 't Hooft anomalies by studying the properties of solitonic defects. By treating these defects as sources for background fields, the authors show that anomalies are simply the manifestation of these defects carrying charges under generalized global symmetries.

The Solitonic Defect Framework

The core methodology distinguishes between topological defects (which generate symmetries) and solitonic defects. Solitonic defects are generically non-topological and act as sources for the background fields of those symmetries.

Figure 1: A solitonic defect $L$ acting as a source for a background field, represented by its intersection with a transverse disk $D_{d-1}$.

The authors prove that a mixed 't Hooft anomaly between symmetry A and symmetry B exists if and only if a solitonic defect sourcing symmetry A carries a non-trivial charge under symmetry B. This shifts the problem from abstract mathematical obstructions to the physical quantum numbers of defects.

Systematic Analysis in 3D Gauge Theories

In 3D gauge theories, the primary actors are vortex line defects (which source 0-form and 1-form symmetry backgrounds) and monopole operators (point-like defects). The paper provides a rigorous "recipe" to calculate the charges of these operators, which receive contributions from two main sources:

  1. Chern-Simons terms: Topological interactions that contribute directly to the defect's charge.
  2. Fermions: The zero-modes of fermions in the matter content in the presence of the defect.

This framework also extends to 2-group symmetries, where 0-form and 1-form symmetries mix non-trivially. This mixing is encoded in the equivalence classes of line defects and the appearance of "fractional gauge monopole operators" at the ends of topological lines.

Key Insights and Results

  • Anomalies as Physical Charges: An anomaly is not just an abstract obstruction; it is a statement about the quantum numbers of defects. If a vortex line is "charged," the theory has an anomaly.
  • Global Perspective: The paper highlights that global gauge and ABJ anomalies, which are not captured by standard anomaly polynomials, are equivalent to the requirement that certain monopole operators must have integer (non-fractional) charges.
  • Lattice-Friendly Framework: Because this method relies on local defect properties rather than global spacetime topology, it is significantly easier to apply to condensed matter systems and lattice gauge theories.
  • Validation: The framework is successfully tested against well-known models, including QED with fermions, $\mathcal{N}=4$ SQED, and the $T[SU(2)]$ theory, recovering known mixed 0-form anomalies.

Conclusion

By mapping 't Hooft anomalies to the charges of solitonic defects, the authors provide a powerful tool for analyzing generalized symmetries. While the detailed computations focus on 3D, the logic provides a roadmap for higher dimensions—using Wilson-'t Hooft lines in 4D or instanton-particle lines in 5D—and paves the way for studying strongly coupled, non-Lagrangian theories.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose the general idea that 't Hooft anomalies of generalized global symmetries can be understood in terms of the properties of solitonic defects, which generically are non-topological defects. The defining property of such defects is that they act as sources for background fields of generalized symmetries. 't Hooft anomalies arise when solitonic defects are charged under these generalized symmetries. We illustrate this idea for several kinds of anomalies in various spacetime dimensions. A systematic exploration is performed in 3d for 0-form, 1-form, and 2-group symmetries, whose 't Hooft anomalies are related to two special types of solitonic defects, namely vortex line defects and monopole operators. This analysis is supplemented with detailed computations of such anomalies in a large class of 3d gauge theories. Central to this computation is the determination of the gauge and 0-form charges of a variety of monopole operators: these involve standard gauge monopole operators, but also fractional gauge monopole operators, as well as monopole operators for 0-form symmetries. The charges of these monopole operators mainly receive contributions from Chern-Simons terms and fermions in the matter content. Along the way, we interpret the vanishing of the global gauge and ABJ anomalies, which are anomalies not captured by local anomaly polynomials, as the requirement that gauge monopole operators and mixed monopole operators for 0-form and gauge symmetries have non-fractional integer charges.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bhardwaj2024anomalies,
  author = {Lakshya Bhardwaj and Mathew Bullimore and Andrea E. V. Ferrari and Sakura Schäfer‐Nameki},
  title = {{Anomalies of Generalized Symmetries from Solitonic Defects}},
  booktitle = {SciPost},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21468/scipostphys.16.3.087},
}
Figure