Anomalies of generalized symmetries from solitonic defects

Lakshya Bhardwaj, Mathew Bullimore, Andrea E. V. Ferrari, Sakura Schäfer‐Nameki

Abstract

We propose the general idea that ’t Hooft anomalies of generalized global symmetries can be understood in terms of the properties of solitonic defects, which generically are non-topological defects. The defining property of such defects is that they act as sources for background fields of generalized symmetries. ’t Hooft anomalies arise when solitonic defects are charged under these generalized symmetries. We illustrate this idea for several kinds of anomalies in various spacetime dimensions. A systematic exploration is performed in 3d for 0-form, 1-form, and 2-group symmetries, whose ’t Hooft anomalies are related to two special types of solitonic defects, namely vortex line defects and monopole operators. This analysis is supplemented with detailed computations of such anomalies in a large class of 3d gauge theories. Central to this computation is the determination of the gauge and 0-form charges of a variety of monopole operators: these involve standard gauge monopole operators, but also fractional gauge monopole operators, as well as monopole operators for 0-form symmetries. The charges of these monopole operators mainly receive contributions from Chern-Simons terms and fermions in the matter content. Along the way, we interpret the vanishing of the global gauge and ABJ anomalies, which are anomalies not captured by local anomaly polynomials, as the requirement that gauge monopole operators and mixed monopole operators for 0-form and gauge symmetries have non-fractional integer charges.

Introduction

In theoretical physics, 't Hooft anomalies are indispensable tools for studying the non-perturbative behavior of quantum field theories (QFTs). Traditionally, these anomalies are characterized by the non-invariance of a theory's partition function when defined on a compact spacetime manifold under background gauge transformations.

However, this "global" approach has drawbacks: it is mathematically subtle, often difficult to apply to lattice systems (common in condensed matter physics), and can feel disconnected from the local physics of the theory. As our understanding of "generalized symmetries"—which can act on lines or surfaces instead of just points—has expanded, there is a pressing need for a more direct way to compute their anomalies. This paper proposes replacing abstract global consistency checks with the local, physical properties of defects.

Methodology: Solitonic Defects as Sources

The authors propose that 't Hooft anomalies arise precisely when solitonic defects—non-topological objects that act as "sources" for background fields—are themselves charged under those symmetries.

A solitonic defect $L$ acting as a source for background fields, illustrated with a transverse disk $D_{d-1}$.

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Defining Solitonic Defects: They identify specific defects, such as vortex lines (codimension-2) and monopole operators (codimension-3), that induce non-trivial background configurations for 0-form, 1-form, and 2-group symmetries.
  • Charge Computation: For 3D gauge theories, they provide a systematic "recipe" to calculate the charges of these monopole operators. These charges receive contributions from two main sources: tree-level Chern-Simons terms and the quantum effects of fermionic matter.
  • Symmetry Mapping: They show how the mixing of different symmetry types (like 0-form and 1-form symmetries merging into a "2-group") is reflected in the way these defects transform.
  • Gauging Analysis: The paper tracks the "fate" of these defects when a symmetry is gauged, showing how they transition from being solitonic to non-solitonic (or vice versa).

Key Insights and Ideas

The relationship between anomalies and defects is a two-way street. If the anomaly is known, one can predict the defect charges; conversely, if the defect charges can be calculated (often easier in a specific Lagrangian), the anomaly is found. This approach allows researchers to study anomalies in systems where a compact spacetime manifold cannot be naturally defined, such as condensed matter lattice models.

In 3D, the "global" gauge and ABJ anomalies—which are invisible to standard local anomaly polynomials—are reinterpreted as the requirement that certain monopole operators must have integer (non-fractional) charges. Furthermore, the abstract concept of a 2-group symmetry is made concrete: it occurs when a defect sourcing a 0-form symmetry is forced to sit at the end of a 1-form symmetry line.

Results

The paper provides a comprehensive framework for computing 1-form, 0-form, and 2-group anomalies in a wide class of 3D gauge theories. The authors apply their method to several benchmark theories, including:

  • QED with fermions: Showing how Chern-Simons levels must be quantized to avoid anomalies.
  • $\mathcal{N}=4$ SQED: Demonstrating the interplay between flavor and topological symmetries.
  • Dualities: Recovering known anomalies for the $T[SU(2)]$ theory through its UV gauge theory description.

While focused on 3D, the authors successfully demonstrate that the logic holds in higher dimensions, using Wilson-'t Hooft lines in 4D and fractional instanton lines in 5D.

Conclusion and Future Work

While the general principle is universal, the specific defect types change in higher dimensions, and the bulk of the detailed computational "recipe" is specialized for three dimensions. A significant open challenge is extending this solitonic defect perspective to non-invertible (categorical) symmetries. Additionally, while the authors suggest this method is useful for non-Lagrangian theories, most examples provided are Lagrangian; future work will specifically apply these results to strongly-coupled 3D $\mathcal{N}=4$ superconformal field theories (SCFTs).

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose the general idea that ’t Hooft anomalies of generalized global symmetries can be understood in terms of the properties of solitonic defects, which generically are non-topological defects. The defining property of such defects is that they act as sources for background fields of generalized symmetries. ’t Hooft anomalies arise when solitonic defects are charged under these generalized symmetries. We illustrate this idea for several kinds of anomalies in various spacetime dimensions. A systematic exploration is performed in 3d for 0-form, 1-form, and 2-group symmetries, whose ’t Hooft anomalies are related to two special types of solitonic defects, namely vortex line defects and monopole operators. This analysis is supplemented with detailed computations of such anomalies in a large class of 3d gauge theories. Central to this computation is the determination of the gauge and 0-form charges of a variety of monopole operators: these involve standard gauge monopole operators, but also fractional gauge monopole operators, as well as monopole operators for 0-form symmetries. The charges of these monopole operators mainly receive contributions from Chern-Simons terms and fermions in the matter content. Along the way, we interpret the vanishing of the global gauge and ABJ anomalies, which are anomalies not captured by local anomaly polynomials, as the requirement that gauge monopole operators and mixed monopole operators for 0-form and gauge symmetries have non-fractional integer charges.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bhardwaj2024anomalies,
  author = {Lakshya Bhardwaj and Mathew Bullimore and Andrea E. V. Ferrari and Sakura Schäfer‐Nameki},
  title = {{Anomalies of generalized symmetries from solitonic defects}},
  booktitle = {SciPost},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21468/scipostphys.16.3.087},
}
Figure