Anchoring of turbulent premixed hydrogen/air flames at externally heated walls

Sebastian Klukas, M. Giglmaier, Nikolaus A. Adams, Moritz Sieber, Sebastian Schimek, Christian Oliver Paschereit

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel experimental and numerical study of how to anchor turbulent hydrogen-air flames using heated walls, a technique crucial for stable combustion in devices like jet engines. They developed a new burner design and found that while different chemical models have minor impacts, the flame anchoring is highly sensitive to the heat transfer from the walls, with specific turbulence models and the Eddy Dissipation Concept (EDC) showing good agreement with experimental results.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Achieving stable and controlled flames is essential for continuous combustion devices, from micro-combustors to jet engines and scramjets. Flame anchoring, the process of keeping a flame attached to a specific location, is typically achieved through flow control mechanisms like recirculation, supersonic shocks, or heat transfer. While heat transfer methods have been explored for laminar flames and micro-combustion, their application to larger-scale, turbulent flames with higher Reynolds numbers has been less understood. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating the phenomenon of flame anchoring using externally heated walls in a turbulent hydrogen-air flame scenario, which is relevant for future clean energy applications due to hydrogen's properties.

Methods

The study employs a dual approach: experimental and numerical.

Experimental Setup: A novel burner design was created, featuring a preheater for the air, a nozzle system to control flow, and a unique heating assembly that acts as the flame holder. This assembly heats a specific section of the combustion chamber wall, which is crucial for anchoring the flame. Optical measurements using OH* chemiluminescence were used to visualize and quantify the flame's position and shape.

Numerical Approach: * Governing Equations: The fully compressible Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations were solved using the commercial CFD code Ansys Fluent. * Turbulence Modeling: Several RANS turbulence models were evaluated, including k-ω (standard, BSL, SST) and a Reynolds stress model (RSM). The focus was on models that can be integrated through the viscous sub-layer. * Turbulence-Chemistry Interaction: The Eddy Dissipation Concept (EDC) was used to model the interaction between turbulence and chemical reactions. * Chemical Kinetics: Various hydrogen/air reaction mechanisms were assessed, including detailed and reduced models, with a focus on their performance under heat loss conditions. The Li mechanism was ultimately selected for its balance of accuracy and computational cost. * Heat Transfer: Fourier's heat conduction equation was solved for the burner walls, and a discrete ordinates radiation model was used to account for radiative heat transfer. * Diffusion: Full multicomponent diffusion treatment using the Maxwell-Stefan equation was implemented, recognizing its importance for hydrogen-rich mixtures. * Mesh: A block-structured hexahedral mesh was used, with a focus on resolving the turbulent wall boundary layer (y+ ≈ 1) and the thin reaction zone.

Datasets

The study does not explicitly mention using pre-existing datasets for training. Instead, it relies on:

  • Experimental Data: The primary dataset is generated from the novel burner design itself, using OH* chemiluminescence measurements under various operating conditions (equivalence ratio, bulk Reynolds number, unburnt mixture temperature). This experimental data serves as the benchmark for validating the numerical simulations.
  • Canonical Problems: For evaluating chemical kinetics, a simplified one-dimensional adiabatic freely propagating flame configuration was used, comparing laminar flame speeds against theoretical predictions and experimental data from literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Heated Walls as Effective Anchors: The study confirms that externally heated walls are a viable and effective method for anchoring turbulent flames, even at elevated Reynolds numbers.
  • Heat Transfer is Paramount: The thermal interaction between the flame and the heated wall is the dominant factor in flame anchoring. Elevated wall temperatures enhance flammability limits and lead to more stable anchoring, while lower temperatures shift the anchoring position downstream.
  • EDC Model Sensitivity: While the EDC model is crucial for capturing turbulence-chemistry interactions, its performance is highly dependent on the chosen modeling constants. The study found that universal constants are not sufficient, and adaptation is necessary for accurate predictions.
  • Turbulence Model Nuances: While most tested turbulence models showed reasonable agreement, the k-ω SST model exhibited some discrepancies in predicting the location of maximum OH* concentration and intermediate species distribution compared to experimental data and other models.
  • Chemical Kinetics Under Heat Loss: For hydrogen/air flames, detailed chemical kinetics mechanisms show similar behavior under heat loss conditions, while reduced mechanisms can exhibit significant deviations, highlighting the importance of selecting appropriate kinetics for accurate simulations.

Key Results

  • Flame Anchoring Achieved: The novel burner design successfully anchored turbulent hydrogen/air flames under various operating conditions.
  • Numerical Validation: The numerical setup, particularly with the Li chemical kinetics, k-ω BSL turbulence model, and adapted EDC constants (Cy = 3.0), showed good qualitative agreement with experimental OH* chemiluminescence measurements for flame shape and anchoring behavior.
  • Influence of Operating Conditions:
    • Increasing equivalence ratio and Reynolds number generally led to shorter flame lengths.
  • Lower unburnt mixture temperatures resulted in longer flames, with some deviations between simulation and experiment.
  • Turbulence Model Performance: The k-ω BSL model was selected for its balance of accuracy and computational cost, showing good agreement with experimental data, though minor differences in anchoring position were observed between models.
  • EDC Constant Adaptation: Adapting the EDC constant Cy to 3.0 significantly improved agreement with experimental results.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * EDC Constant Adaptation: The need to adapt EDC constants for different operating conditions suggests that a truly universal EDC model for this specific application might require further refinement. * Deviations at Low Temperatures: For significantly elongated flames due to reduced unburnt mixture temperatures, the simulations showed more pronounced deviations from experimental results, suggesting potential areas for improvement. * Computational Cost: While efforts were made to balance accuracy and cost (e.g., selecting the k-ω BSL model and the Li mechanism), complex simulations involving detailed kinetics and advanced turbulence models remain computationally intensive.

Future Work: * Further EDC Refinement: Continued investigation into optimizing EDC modeling constants or exploring alternative turbulence-chemistry interaction models could lead to even better predictive capabilities. * Broader Operating Range: Extending the study to a wider range of operating conditions, including different fuels or more extreme temperature regimes, would further validate the anchoring concept and numerical approach. * Advanced Turbulence Models: While RANS models were used, exploring Large Eddy Simulation (LES) for specific aspects could provide deeper insights into the turbulent flow structures influencing flame anchoring. * Detailed Heat Transfer Analysis: A more in-depth analysis of the complex heat transfer mechanisms, including radiation and convection at the wall, could refine the understanding of the flame-wall interaction.

Summary updated

Abstract

A joint experimental and numerical investigation of turbulent flame anchoring at externally heated walls is presented. The phenomenon has primarily been studied for laminar flames and micro-combustion while this study focuses on large-scale applications and elevated Reynolds number flows. Therefore, a novel burner design is developed and examined for a diverse set of operating conditions. Hydroxyl radical chemiluminescence measurements are employed to validate the numerical method. The numerical investigation evaluates the performance of various hydrogen/air kinetics, Reynolds-averaged turbulence models and the eddy dissipation concept (EDC) as a turbulence-chemistry interaction model. Simulation results show minor differences between detailed chemical mechanisms but pronounced deviations for a reduced kinetic. The baseline k-ω turbulence model is assessed to most accurately predict flame front position and shape. Universal applicability of EDC modeling constants is contradicted. Conclusively, the flame anchoring concept is considered a promising approach for pilot flames in continuous combustion devices.
BibTeX
@article{klukas2020anchoring,
  author = {Sebastian Klukas and M. Giglmaier and Nikolaus A. Adams and Moritz Sieber and Sebastian Schimek and Christian Oliver Paschereit},
  title = {{Anchoring of turbulent premixed hydrogen/air flames at externally heated walls}},
  journal = {International Journal of Hydrogen Energy},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ijhydene.2020.08.201},
}
Figure