Analysis of perception, adaptive design and evaluation of warning signals in different soundscapes

Ks Voigt, Brigitte Schulte‐Fortkamp, Dick Botteldooren, Bert De CoenselGhent 2011

Presented at the DAGA 2011 conference, this research addresses the critical safety and environmental challenges posed by the transition to electric and hybrid vehicles.

DAGA 2011 Conference Logo

Abstract

With the newly emerging hybrid and fully electric vehicle concepts, car manufacturers are not only reducing fuel consumption and carbon dioxide emissions, but are also reducing vehicle noise emissions. This reduction eliminates commonly known vehicle sounds that provide orientation in public soundscapes. Especially at low speeds, the absence of internal combustion engine (ICE) sounds creates a "silent hazard." Aerodynamic noise is increasingly minimized by aeroacoustical design, and tire noise is often only audible in very quiet environments. Even at speeds as low as 30 km/h, collisions can have serious consequences for pedestrians and cyclists.

Introduction: The Silent Hazard

The automotive industry's shift toward hybrid and fully electric powertrains is a significant step toward sustainability. However, it introduces a safety gap in urban environments. Traditional ICE vehicles provide a natural "acoustic signature" that alerts road users to their presence. At speeds below 30 km/h, electric vehicles (EVs) are nearly silent because aerodynamic noise is minimal and tire noise is only audible on specific surfaces in very quiet conditions. This lack of auditory cues increases the risk for vulnerable road users, such as pedestrians and cyclists, who rely on sound for spatial awareness.

The challenge lies in bridging this "acoustical gap" without contributing to urban noise pollution. Simply adding static, loud warning sounds would degrade the quality of life in cities. This research proposes an adaptive approach to signal design that balances safety with environmental acoustics.

Methodology

Researchers from TU Berlin and Ghent University developed a multi-stage framework for designing and evaluating adaptive warning signals:

  1. Evolutionary and Modern Analysis: The team analyzed natural and existing warning sounds to identify characteristics that trigger human attention without being unnecessarily jarring or annoying.
  2. Adaptive Signal Design: The proposed system is dynamic, utilizing two primary inputs:
  3. Vehicle Speed: The signal's pitch or intensity modulates as the vehicle accelerates or decelerates, mimicking the informative nature of traditional engines.
  4. Ambient Soundscape Analysis: The system monitors the surrounding acoustic environment. It ensures the warning signal is audible above the background noise floor but remains as quiet as possible to minimize "dispensable sound."
  5. Subjective Evaluation: The sounds were tested in varied, realistic soundscapes using binaural recordings. Evaluation focused on two metrics: noticeability (detection threshold) and subjective preference (annoyance vs. acceptance).

Key Insights

  • The Acoustical Gap: There is a distinct void between informative vehicle noises (tires, wind) and artificial "buzzers." An effective signal should feel like a natural extension of the vehicle's operation.
  • Context-Aware Safety: Safety sounds should not be "one-size-fits-all." An adaptive car can be more prominent in a bustling city center while remaining nearly silent in a quiet residential area at night.
  • Silence as a Resource: The research treats the urban soundscape as a resource to be protected. The goal is to affect the environment only as much as is strictly required for safety.

Results and Implications

The study successfully identified the parameters—primarily speed and ambient noise—necessary to transform a sound from mere "noise" into a "remarking warning signal." The project resulted in new signal tones designed to enhance transport safety while maintaining aesthetic and environmental standards.

Furthermore, the authors established a validation framework for testing these sounds. This framework provides a roadmap for manufacturers to evaluate Acoustic Vehicle Alerting Systems (AVAS), which have since become a regulatory requirement in many regions.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the research provides a solid foundation for adaptive warning signals, several challenges remain. Future work must refine the adaptive logic to handle increasingly complex urban noise profiles. Additionally, long-term studies are needed to understand the cumulative impact of these sounds on the quality of life for urban residents. Finally, industry-wide standardization is necessary to ensure that pedestrians can easily recognize vehicle signals across different brands and models.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the newly emerging hybrid and fully electric vehicle concepts, car manufacturers are not only reducing fuel consumption and carbon dioxide emissions, but are also reducing vehicle noise emissions, and with this the presence of commonly known vehicle sounds, which provide people some orientation in the public soundscape. Especially when driving at low speeds, vehicle signalization sounds from the absent internal combustion engine are missing. Aerodynamic noise is also removed increasingly by thorough aeroacoustical design, and on plain road surfaces, tires of slowly driving vehicles are only audible in quiet environments. Even at speeds as low as 30 km/h, collisions can already have serious consequences for pedestrians and cyclists.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{voigt2011analysis,
  author = {KS Voigt and Brigitte Schulte‐Fortkamp and Dick Botteldooren and Bert De Coensel},
  title = {{Analysis of perception, adaptive design and evaluation of warning signals in different soundscapes}},
  booktitle = {Ghent},
  year = {2011},
}
Figure