Analysis of factors which will determine the future continuation of business of dairy farms and the estimation of the numbers of dairy farms and cattle through a questionnaire in Chiba prefecture.

Kazuhiro Kengaku, Atsushi Yamashita, Tsunenobu Mitsuhashi, Hidemichi KomotoJAPAN 1987 · DOI

Abstract

The number of dairy farms in Chiba prefecture is decreasing due to urbanization, lack of successors, and other structural problems. To understand the factors determining the prospective continuation of these businesses, a questionnaire-based study was conducted. Farms intending to continue for 20 years or longer are typically operated by young farmers with a strong desire to expand. Those planning for 10 to 20 years are middle-scale operations run by couples focused on maintenance. Farms expecting to fold within 10 years are small-scale, run by older farmers whose successors have moved to other occupations. Consequently, the number of dairy farms and cattle in Chiba is estimated to decrease to 2/3 and 5/6 of current levels, respectively, within a decade.

Introduction

This 1987 study, originally published in the Journal of Veterinary Informatics, applies advanced statistical quantification methods to survey data from over 1,400 dairy farms in Chiba Prefecture, Japan. By analyzing factors such as manager age and successor availability, the researchers categorized farms by their expected longevity and forecasted a significant contraction of the regional dairy industry.

Methods

The researchers employed Hayashi’s Quantification Theory, a suite of multivariate analysis techniques designed for categorical data:

  1. Quantification Theory Type III: Used for exploratory data analysis to visualize how different farm characteristics (e.g., "small scale" and "elderly manager") cluster together in a multi-dimensional space.
  2. Quantification Theory Type II: Used for discriminant analysis to classify farms into three groups based on their intended continuation period: >20 years, 10–20 years, and <10 years.

Datasets and Survey Overview

The study utilized a primary dataset from a survey conducted between 1982 and 1983, covering 1,481 dairy farms (a 34% random sample of Chiba's dairy households). The analysis tracked 10 explanatory variables, including labor force size, manager age, successor status, and herd size.

Distribution of survey responses across operational and demographic categories.

Key Insights: Industry Stratification

The analysis revealed a clear "demographic cliff." The most influential factors for survival were manager age and the presence of a successor. The industry was found to be stratified into three distinct tiers:

  • The Growth Tier (>20 years): Managed by young farmers (20s–30s) with 3+ workers and 21+ cows. These farms showed a strong desire to modernize and expand.
  • The Maintenance Tier (10–20 years): Middle-scale farms run by husband-and-wife teams aiming to maintain the status quo.
  • The Exit Tier (<10 years): Small-scale operations run by elderly managers (60s+) with no successors. In many cases, potential successors had already moved into urban occupations.
Clustering of farm characteristics using Hayashi’s Quantification Theory Type III, showing the relationship between operational scale and demographic factors.

Key Results and Forecast

The discriminant model (Type II) proved highly effective at identifying the extremes, correctly classifying 78.4% of farms in the "Growth Tier" and 73.2% in the "Exit Tier." Predicting the "Maintenance Tier" was more challenging (46% accuracy), suggesting these middle-scale farms are in a volatile transition state.

Based on these findings, the authors estimated that by the mid-1990s, the number of dairy farms in Chiba would drop to approximately 3,000 (2/3 of the 1982 level), and the total cattle population would shrink to roughly 75,000 head (5/6 of the 1982 level).

Conclusion and Policy Implications

The study suggests that urbanization impacts farming not just through land use, but by providing alternative career paths that draw away potential successors. The authors conclude that policy interventions should focus on making dairy farming an attractive, "charming" occupation for the younger generation to ensure business succession, rather than merely providing financial subsidies to an aging workforce.

Summary updated

Abstract

The number of dairy farms in Chiba prefecture are decreasing because of urbanization, lack of successors and other problems. To understand the factors which determine the prospective continuation of each dairy farm, we carried out a questionnaire-based study.Dairy farms which answered to continue 20-years or longer are operated principally by young farmers. They had a strong desire to increase the number of dairy catlle and to expand the upgrade and scale of management.Those which answered to continue 10 to 20 years are typical middle-scale dairy farms operated by a husband and wife team. They preferred maintenance on the present conditional scale.Those which answered to continue less than 10 years are small-scale dairy farms operated only by older farmers. Because their sons, who were expected to succeed to their business, have already become engaged in other occupations. It seems difficult that business would be prolonged even if conditions were to improve. As a consequence, the numbers of dairy farms and dairy cattle in Chiba prefecture are estimated to decrease to 2/3 or 5/6 of the present number, respectively, within the next ten years.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kengaku1987analysis,
  author = {Kazuhiro KENGAKU and Atsushi Yamashita and Tsunenobu MITSUHASHI and Hidemichi KOMOTO},
  title = {{Analysis of factors which will determine the future continuation of business of dairy farms and the estimation of the numbers of dairy farms and cattle through a questionnaire in Chiba prefecture.}},
  booktitle = {JAPAN},
  year = {1987},
  doi = {10.2743/jve1986.1987.19\_1},
}
Figure