An Implantable Piezofilm Middle Ear Microphone: Performance in Human Cadaveric Temporal Bones

John Z. Zhang, Lukas Graf, Annesya Banerjee, Aaron Yeiser, Christopher I. McHugh, Ioannis Kymissis, Jeffrey H. Lang, Elizabeth S. Olson, Hideko Heidi Nakajima

TL;DR

Researchers have developed the "DrumMic," a piezoelectric membrane microphone designed to be implanted in the middle ear to sense vibrations at the tip of the malleus (the umbo). Tested in human cadaveric temporal bones, the device demonstrates robust, linear performance across speech frequencies, bringing us a significant step closer to totally implantable cochlear implants that preserve the natural acoustic benefits of the outer ear.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While cochlear implants (CIs) have revolutionized hearing for over a million people, they still rely on external hardware—specifically microphones worn behind the ear. This setup has several drawbacks: it’s aesthetically conspicuous, susceptible to wind noise, unusable in water or during sleep, and, perhaps most importantly, it bypasses the natural "pinna effect." The outer ear (pinna) and ear canal naturally filter and amplify sound, providing crucial cues for localization and speech clarity in noise.

The "holy grail" of CI research is a totally implantable system. However, the bottleneck has always been the microphone. Subcutaneous microphones (placed under the skin) suffer from poor signal-to-noise ratios because the skin attenuates high-frequency sounds while picking up internal body noise. This paper explores a middle-ear approach, aiming to create a sensor that is sensitive, low-noise, and easy to integrate with existing surgical procedures.

Methods

The authors introduced a "DrumMic" concept based on a piezoelectric polymer called polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF).

  • Design: The microphone consists of a thin PVDF membrane stretched over a 3mm brass ring. One side of the membrane presses against the umbo (the tip of the malleus bone attached to the eardrum), while the other side sits on the cochlear promontory.
  • Mechanism: As sound vibrates the eardrum and the ossicular chain, the umbo moves, stretching the PVDF membrane. This mechanical strain generates an electrical charge, which is then processed by a custom low-noise charge amplifier.
  • Experimental Setup: The team tested five different DrumMics across four human cadaveric temporal bones. They used Laser Doppler Vibrometry (LDV) to measure the actual velocity of the umbo and compared it to the electrical output of the DrumMic.
  • Adjustability: To ensure good mechanical contact, they used tiny plastic shims (0.65 mm thick) to "tension" the microphone between the bone and the umbo.

Datasets

This study did not use a traditional computational dataset. Instead, it generated primary experimental data from:

  • Five custom-fabricated DrumMics.
  • Four human cadaveric temporal bones (harvested from four male donors, mean age 71.5, with no history of ear pathology).
  • Comparative benchmarks: Performance was compared against the Knowles EK-23103, a standard high-end microphone used in commercial hearing aids.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Umbo as a Signal Source: The researchers chose the umbo because it exhibits the largest, most predictable one-dimensional motion in the middle ear, making it an ideal "mechanical" output for sound.
  • The "Canceling" Effect: A fascinating finding was that the DrumMic's sensitivity to ear canal pressure remained consistent even when the anatomy varied. While a tighter fit (more shims) increases the tension and sensitivity of the PVDF film, it also stiffens the ear's mechanics, reducing the umbo's motion. These two factors effectively cancel each other out, resulting in a device that is remarkably robust to surgical placement variations.
  • Leveraging Natural Anatomy: By placing the mic behind the eardrum, the system benefits from the natural 10–20 dB pressure gain provided by the ear canal and pinna, which helps offset the intrinsic noise of the sensor.

Key Results

  • Linearity: The DrumMic behaved linearly across a massive dynamic range, from 46 dB SPL to at least 100 dB SPL.
  • Bandwidth: The device maintained a strong signal-to-noise ratio up to 8 kHz, covering the essential frequencies for human speech.
  • Sensitivity: The output was tightly clustered around 25 fC/Pa (femtocoulombs per Pascal) across different ears and devices.
  • Noise Floor: The measured Equivalent Input Noise (EIN) was 54 dB SPL. However, when accounting for the natural gain of the outer ear, the effective EIN was estimated at 46 dB SPL. While this is higher than the ~34 dB SPL of top-tier external hearing aid mics, it is a significant improvement over many previous implantable concepts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Environmental Protection: The middle ear is a moist environment. The current prototype was only lightly coated in silicone; a final version will require sophisticated hermetic sealing and medical-grade biocompatibility.
  • Anatomical Interference: The base of the current design sits near Jacobson’s nerve. Future iterations must ensure the device does not cause trauma to this or other middle-ear structures.
  • Noise Reduction: While 46 dB SPL is promising, further optimization of the charge amplifier and electrical shielding is needed to match the performance of external microphones.
  • Long-term Stability: The study used cadaveric bones; future work must address how the mechanical coupling holds up over years of vibration and pressure changes in a living patient.

Summary updated

Abstract

Purpose: One of the major reasons that totally implantable cochlear microphones are not readily available is the lack of good implantable microphones. An implantable microphone has the potential to provide a range of benefits over external microphones for cochlear implant users including the filtering ability of the outer ear, cosmetics, and usability in all situations. This paper presents results from experiments in human cadaveric ears of a piezofilm microphone concept under development as a possible component of a future implantable microphone system for use with cochlear implants. This microphone is referred to here as a drum microphone (DrumMic) that senses the robust and predictable motion of the umbo, the tip of the malleus. Methods: The performance was measured of five DrumMics inserted in four different human cadaveric temporal bones. Sensitivity, linearity, bandwidth, and equivalent input noise were measured during these experiments using a sound stimulus and measurement setup. Results: The sensitivity of the DrumMics was found to be tightly clustered across different microphones and ears despite differences in umbo and middle ear anatomy. The DrumMics were shown to behave linearly across a large dynamic range (46 dB SPL to 100 dB SPL) across a wide bandwidth (100 Hz to 8 kHz). The equivalent input noise (0.1-10 kHz) of the DrumMic and amplifier referenced to the ear canal was measured to be 54 dB SPL and estimated to be 46 dB SPL after accounting for the pressure gain of the outer ear. Conclusion: The results demonstrate that the DrumMic behaves robustly across ears and fabrication. The equivalent input noise performance was shown to approach that of commercial hearing aid microphones. To advance this demonstration of the DrumMic concept to a future prototype implantable in humans, work on encapsulation, biocompatibility, connectorization will be required.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2024implantable,
  author = {John Z. Zhang and Lukas Graf and Annesya Banerjee and Aaron Yeiser and Christopher I. McHugh and Ioannis Kymissis and Jeffrey H. Lang and Elizabeth S. Olson and Hideko Heidi Nakajima},
  title = {{An Implantable Piezofilm Middle Ear Microphone: Performance in Human Cadaveric Temporal Bones}},
  journal = {Journal of the Association for Research in Otolaryngology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s10162-024-00927-4},
}
Figure