Amplitude Analysis of the Decays $\\eta^\\prime \\rightarrow \\pi^+\\pi^-\\pi^0$ and $\\eta^\\prime \\rightarrow \\pi^0\\pi^0\\pi^0$
Medina Ablikim, Xiaonan Li, Selim Çetin, Dapeng Jin, W. Shan, Kun Zhang, A. Kupść, Y. Hu, Xiaoling Li, Kanglin He, Haiyun Chen, Xingtao Huang, М. Н. Ачасов, Wolfgang Kuehn K uhn, Mauro Savrié Savri 'e, Yong Ding, Ling Zhao, Jingzhi Bai, Zhi-Gang Wang, H. Liu, A. Dbeyssi, Zhonghua Qin, G. Rong, Y. P. Guo, Guangrui Liao, Xiongfei Wang, Jueping Liu, L. Xia, Fengcai Ma, Shenjian Chen, B. Zheng, Chenglin Luo, B. Kloss, J. Dong, F. Bianchi, K. J. Zhu, Landiao Liu, Shubin Liu, Y. Guan, Minghan Ye, M. Ripka, Wang Peiliang, A. G. Denig, Z. Gao, E. H. Thorndike, Fang Liu, Y. Lu, Xiaoshan Jiang, Jian Min, F. F. An, Beijiang Liu, L. Y. Dong, Wenxuan Gong, I. Boyko, Y. K. Sun, Z. L. Hou, Shi Chen, E. Boger, Zepu Mao, Y. F. Wang, Shiquan Zhang, Haibo Li, M. Maggiora, H Cheng, Xiqing Hao, Jin Li, F. A. Harris, Xingyu Jiang, A. Yuncu, Dong Liu, Y. Gao, S. J. Zhu, Q. Gao, Hao Xiao, Pengfei Duan, Ziping Zhang, Qun OuYang Ouyang, Y. Ban, Dahua Zhang, S. S. Sun, X. Y. Shen, Hongyu Zhang, Fengyun Li, Matthias Ullrich, Luwen Jiang, Xiaoshuai Qin, Ming Qi, Jin Zhang, Christoph Florian Redmer, X. Zhang, A. Q. Guo, Jie Liu, G. F. Cao, Klaus Peters, B. Zhong, I. B. Nikolaev, Xurong Chen, L. Zhou, M. M. Ma
Based on a sample of $1.31\times10^9$ $J/\psi$ events collected with the BESIII detector, an amplitude analysis of the isospin violating decays $\eta^\prime\rightarrow\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0$ and $\eta^\prime\rightarrow\pi^0\pi^0\pi^0$ is performed. Significant $P$-wave contribution from $\eta^\prime\rightarrow\rho^{\pm}\pi^{\mp}$ is observed for the first time in $\eta^\prime\rightarrow\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0$. The branching fraction is determined to be ${\mathcal B}(\eta^\prime\rightarrow\rho^{\pm}\pi^{\mp})=(7.44\pm0.60\pm1.26\pm1.84)\times 10^{-4}$, where the first uncertainty is statistical, the second systematic and the third model dependent. In addition to the non-resonant $S$-wave component, a contribution from the $\sigma$ meson is also essential. The branching fractions of the $S$-wave components are determined as ${\mathcal B}(\eta^\prime\rightarrow\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0)_S=(37.63\pm0.77\pm2.22\pm4.48)\times 10^{-4}$ and ${\mathcal B}(\eta^\prime\rightarrow\pi^0\pi^0\pi^0)=(35.22\pm0.82\pm2.60)\times 10^{-4}$, respectively. The latter one is consistent with previous BESIII measurements.
Introduction
In the Standard Model of particle physics, the mass difference between "up" ($u$) and "down" ($d$) quarks is a fundamental parameter. However, because quarks are confined within hadrons, this difference cannot be measured directly. Isospin-violating decays, such as the $\eta^\prime$ meson decaying into three pions ($\pi\pi\pi$), provide a unique laboratory to probe this difference. Isospin symmetry treats $u$ and $d$ quarks as interchangeable; if they were identical in mass, these decays would be highly suppressed. The observation and precise measurement of these decays allow physicists to constrain the $d-u$ mass difference.
While previous experiments have observed these rare decays, the lack of sufficiently large data samples prevented a comprehensive amplitude analysis—a technique required to map internal dynamics and identify intermediate resonant states.
Experimental Procedure
This study utilizes a massive sample of $1.31 \times 10^9$ $J/\psi$ events collected by the BESIII detector at the Beijing Electron Positron Collider (BEPCII). The $\eta^\prime$ mesons are produced via the radiative decay $J/\psi \rightarrow \gamma \eta^\prime$, providing a clean signal source.
The analysis employed several advanced technical methods:
Dalitz Plot Analysis: Mapping the energy distribution of the three pions to identify intermediate states.
Isobar Model: Modeling the decay as a coherent sum of different channels, including $P$-wave ($\rho^\pm \pi^\mp$) and $S$-wave (non-resonant and $\sigma$ meson) components.
Kinematic Fitting: Multi-constraint fits (up to 8C) were used to ensure energy-momentum conservation and suppress background noise.
Unbinned Maximum Likelihood Fit: This statistical method allowed for the simultaneous extraction of the relative strengths (branching fractions) and phases of each decay component.
Results and Discussion
The amplitude analysis revealed several key insights into $\eta^\prime$ decay dynamics. Most notably, the study reports the first significant experimental observation of a $P$-wave contribution from $\eta^\prime \rightarrow \rho^\pm \pi^\mp$ in the charged channel. This confirms long-standing theoretical predictions that were previously unverified by experiment.
Furthermore, the analysis demonstrates that the $S$-wave component is not a simple flat distribution but requires the inclusion of the broad $\sigma$ meson resonance to accurately describe the data.
Projections of the invariant mass distributions for $\eta^\prime \rightarrow \pi^+\pi^-\pi^0$ showing the fit results and individual resonant components.
The measured branching fractions for the various decay modes are summarized in the table below. The results for the neutral decay $\eta^\prime \rightarrow 3\pi^0$ confirm previous BESIII measurements, resolving discrepancies with older experimental data from other facilities.
Summary of yields, efficiencies ($\epsilon$), and branching fractions ($\mathcal{B}$) for the analyzed $\eta^\prime$ decay modes.
This high-precision amplitude analysis provides critical experimental input for refining light quark mass ratios. While the $P$-wave contribution has been established, significant model-dependent uncertainties remain. Future work utilizing more sophisticated dispersive approaches may further reduce these uncertainties by better accounting for final-state interactions between the pions, which is crucial for an even more precise determination of quark masses.
Summary updated
Abstract
Based on a sample of $1.31\\times10^9$ $J/\\psi$ events collected with the BESIII detector, an amplitude analysis of the isospin violating decays $\\eta^\\prime\\rightarrow\\pi^+\\pi^-\\pi^0$ and $\\eta^\\prime\\rightarrow\\pi^0\\pi^0\\pi^0$ is performed. Significant $P$-wave contribution from $\\eta^\\prime\\rightarrow\\rho^{\\pm}\\pi^{\\mp}$ is observed for the first time in $\\eta^\\prime\\rightarrow\\pi^+\\pi^-\\pi^0$. The branching fraction is determined to be ${\\mathcal B}(\\eta^\\prime\\rightarrow\\rho^{\\pm}\\pi^{\\mp})=(7.44\\pm0.60\\pm1.26\\pm1.84)\\times 10^{-4}$, where the first uncertainty is statistical, the second systematic and the third model dependent. In addition to the non-resonant $S$-wave component, a contribution from the $\\sigma$ meson is also essential. The branching fractions of the $S$-wave components are determined as ${\\mathcal B}(\\eta^\\prime\\rightarrow\\pi^+\\pi^-\\pi^0)_S=(37.63\\pm0.77\\pm2.22\\pm4.48)\\times 10^{-4}$ and ${\\mathcal B}(\\eta^\\prime\\rightarrow\\pi^0\\pi^0\\pi^0)=(35.22\\pm0.82\\pm2.60)\\times 10^{-4}$, respectively. The latter one is consistent with previous BESIII measurements.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ablikim2017amplitude,
author = {Medina Ablikim and Xiaonan Li and Selim Çetin and Dapeng Jin and W. Shan and Kun Zhang and A. Kupść and Y. Hu and Xiaoling Li and Kanglin He and Haiyun Chen and Xingtao Huang and М. Н. Ачасов and Wolfgang Kuehn K uhn and Mauro Savrié Savri 'e and Yong Ding and Ling Zhao and Jingzhi Bai and Zhi-Gang Wang and H. Liu and A. Dbeyssi and Zhonghua Qin and G. Rong and Y. P. Guo and Guangrui Liao and Xiongfei Wang and Jueping Liu and L. Xia and Fengcai Ma and Shenjian Chen and B. Zheng and Chenglin Luo and B. Kloss and J. Dong and F. Bianchi and K. J. Zhu and Landiao Liu and Shubin Liu and Y. Guan and Minghan Ye and M. Ripka and Wang Peiliang and A. G. Denig and Z. Gao and E. H. Thorndike and Fang Liu and Y. Lu and Xiaoshan Jiang and Jian Min and F. F. An and Beijiang Liu and L. Y. Dong and Wenxuan Gong and I. Boyko and Y. K. Sun and Z. L. Hou and Shi Chen and E. Boger and Zepu Mao and Y. F. Wang and Shiquan Zhang and Haibo Li and M. Maggiora and H Cheng and Xiqing Hao and Jin Li and F. A. Harris and Xingyu Jiang and A. Yuncu and Dong Liu and Y. Gao and S. J. Zhu and Q. Gao and Hao Xiao and Pengfei Duan and Ziping Zhang and Qun OuYang Ouyang and Y. Ban and Dahua Zhang and S. S. Sun and X. Y. Shen and Hongyu Zhang and Fengyun Li and Matthias Ullrich and Luwen Jiang and Xiaoshuai Qin and Ming Qi and Jin Zhang and Christoph Florian Redmer and X. Zhang and A. Q. Guo and Jie Liu and G. F. Cao and Klaus Peters and B. Zhong and I. B. Nikolaev and Huihui Liu and Xurong Chen and L. Zhou and M. M. Ma},
title = {{Amplitude Analysis of the Decays $\textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}eta^\textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}prime \textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}rightarrow \textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}pi^+\textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}pi^-\textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}pi^0$ and $\textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}eta^\textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}prime \textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}rightarrow \textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}pi^0\textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}pi^0\textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}pi^0$}},
booktitle = {Physical},
year = {2017},
doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.118.012001},
}