Advancing European high-contrast imaging R&D towards the Habitable Worlds Observatory

Iva Laginja, Óscar Carrión-González, Romain Laugier, Elisabeth C. Matthews, Lucie Leboulleux, Axel Potier, Alexis K.h. Lau, Olivier Absil, Pierre Baudoz, Beth Biller, A. Boccaletti, Wolfgang Brandner, Alexis Carlotti, G. Chauvin, Élodie Choquet, David Doelman, Kjetil Dohlen, Marc Ferrari, Sasha Hinkley, Elsa Huby, Mikael Karlsson, O. Krause, Jonas Kühn, Jean-Michel Le Duigou, Johan Mazoyer, D. Mesa, M. Min, David Mouillet, Laurent M. Mugnier, Gilles Orban de Xivry, Frans Snik, Daniele Vassallo, A. Vigan, Pieter de VisserAstrophysics 2025 · DOI

Abstract

The Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO) represents a generational leap in astrophysics, aiming to directly image and characterize Earth-like exoplanets. To achieve this, NASA is prioritizing early technology development and international collaboration. This paper synthesizes the outcomes of the "R&D for Space-Based HCI in Europe" workshop (March 2024), outlining a strategic roadmap for European contributions. We highlight Europe's expertise in high-contrast imaging (HCI), the critical need for investment in wavefront control and starlight suppression technologies, and the importance of aligning European funding mechanisms with the HWO timeline.

Introduction

The search for "Earth 2.0"—a rocky, habitable planet orbiting a Sun-like star—is a primary driver of modern astronomy. Detecting such a planet requires resolving an object ten billion times fainter than its host star ($10^{-10}$ contrast). NASA’s Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO) is designed to meet this challenge. However, the technical requirements exceed current capabilities, necessitating a coordinated global effort. European researchers, building on decades of success in ground-based HCI, are positioning themselves to provide critical technology and expertise.

The Challenge of High-Contrast Imaging

Achieving $10^{-10}$ contrast is analogous to spotting a firefly next to a lighthouse from thousands of miles away. Current space telescopes, including the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), are not optimized for this level of precision. The "readiness gap" involves developing ultra-stable deformable mirrors, advanced coronagraphs, and low-noise detectors. Furthermore, a systemic funding hurdle exists in Europe: national agencies often await a formal commitment from the European Space Agency (ESA) before investing in R&D, while ESA seeks evidence of national interest before making such commitments.

Strategic Methodology and Review

The March 2024 workshop at Paris Observatory evaluated the European HCI landscape through several lenses:

  • Technology Gap Analysis: Identifying shortfalls in broadband mirror coatings, sub-Kelvin cooling, and high-throughput integral field spectrographs required to reach the $10^{-10}$ threshold.
  • Facility Assessment: Reviewing testbeds like the Très Haute Dynamique 2 (THD2) at Paris Observatory, currently Europe's premier facility for space-equivalent contrast levels in air.
  • Synergy Mapping: Leveraging R&D from ground-based projects, such as the Extremely Large Telescope's (ELT) Planetary Camera and Spectrograph (PCS), and complementary mission concepts like the mid-IR interferometer LIFE.

Key Technological Priorities

Europe is uniquely positioned to lead in several high-priority areas essential for HWO's success:

  1. Deformable Mirrors (DMs): Developing high-actuator-count mirrors with unprecedented stability to correct wavefront errors in real-time.
  2. Coronagraphic Masks: Refining designs such as Vector Vortex and Apodized Pupil Lyot Coronagraphs to suppress starlight more effectively.
  3. Low-Order Wavefront Sensing: Implementing systems to maintain telescope stability against minute thermal and mechanical vibrations.
  4. In-Air vs. Vacuum Testing: While vacuum testbeds are essential for final flight validation, in-air testbeds like THD2 allow for rapid, cost-effective prototyping of wavefront control algorithms up to $10^{-9}$ contrast.

Conclusion and Call to Action

NASA’s HWO timeline is aggressive, with Phase A targeted for the early 2030s. For Europe to be a core partner, immediate alignment is required. Workshop participants called for an "open affirmation" from ESA to signal to national agencies that a European contribution is anticipated. This would unlock necessary funding and ensure that European innovation plays a pivotal role in the quest to characterize temperate exoplanets and search for life beyond our solar system.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO) will enable a transformative leap in the direct imaging and characterization of Earth-like exoplanets. For this, NASA is focusing on early investment in technology development prior to mission definition and actively seeking international partnerships earlier than for previous missions. The “R&D for Space-Based HCI in Europe” workshop, held in March 2024 at Paris Observatory, convened leading experts in high-contrast imaging (HCI) to discuss European expertise and explore potential strategies for European contributions to HWO. This paper synthesizes the discussions and outcomes of the workshop, highlighting Europe’s critical contributions to past and current HCI efforts, the synergies between ground- and space-based technologies, and the importance of laboratory testbeds and collaborative funding mechanisms. Key conclusions include the need for Europe to invest in technology development for areas such as deformable mirrors and advanced detectors, and establish or enhance laboratory facilities for system-level testing. Putting emphasis on the urgency of aligning with the timeline of HWO, the participants called on an open affirmation by the European Space Agency (ESA) that a European contribution to HWO is clearly anticipated, to signal national agencies and unlock funding opportunities at the national level. Based on the expertise demonstrated through R&D, Europe is poised to play a pivotal role in advancing global HCI capabilities, contributing to the characterization of temperate exoplanets and fostering innovation across domains.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{laginja2025advancing,
  author = {Iva Laginja and Óscar Carrión-González and Romain Laugier and Elisabeth C. Matthews and Lucie Leboulleux and Axel Potier and Alexis K.H. Lau and Olivier Absil and Pierre Baudoz and Beth Biller and A. Boccaletti and Wolfgang Brandner and Alexis Carlotti and G. Chauvin and Élodie Choquet and David Doelman and Kjetil Dohlen and Marc Ferrari and Sasha Hinkley and Elsa Huby and Mikael Karlsson and O. Krause and Jonas Kühn and Jean-Michel Le Duigou and Johan Mazoyer and D. Mesa and M. Min and David Mouillet and Laurent M. Mugnier and Gilles Orban de Xivry and Frans Snik and Daniele Vassallo and A. Vigan and Pieter de Visser},
  title = {{Advancing European high-contrast imaging R\&D towards the Habitable Worlds Observatory}},
  booktitle = {Astrophysics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1007/s10509-025-04417-8},
}
Figure