The ESO's Extremely Large Telescope Working Groups

P. Padovani, Michele Cirasuolo, R. F. J. van der Burg, F. Cantalloube, E. M. George, M. Kasper, Kieran Leschinski, C. J. A. P. Martins, J. Milli, Sabine Möhler, Mark Neeser, Benoît Neichel, Ángel Otarola, Rubén Sánchez-Janssen, Benoît Serra, A. Smette, E. Valenti, Christophe Vérinaud, J. Vernet, Olivier Absil, Guido Agapito, Morten Andersen, Carmelo Arcidiacono, Matej Arko, Pierre Baudoz, Olivier Beltramo-Martin, Enrico Biancalani, Thomas Bierwirth, L. Burtscher, Giulia Carlà, Julio A. Castro-Almazán, Anne-Laure Cheffot, L. Coccato, Carlos Correia, Romain Fétick, G. Fiorentino, Thierry Fusco, B. García‐Lorenzo, N. P. Gentile Fusillo, O. González López, A. Grazian, Marco Gullieuszik, O. Hainaut, V. D. Ivanov, Melanie Kaasinen, Darshan Kaddad, T. Kamiński, Wolfgang Kausch, F. Kerber, S. Kimeswenger, Rosita Kokotanekova, Arseniy I. Kuznetsov, Alexis K.h. Lau, Miska Le Louarn, Frédéric Lemmel, J. Liske, G. Lo Curto, David Lucsanyi, Lars Lundin, Stefan Noll, Sylvain Oberti, James Osborn, Elena Masciadri, Dinko Milaković, M. T. Murphy, Fernando Pedichini, M. Pereira-Santaella, Roberto Piazzesi, Javier Piqueras López, Cédric Plantet, Thibaut Prod’homme, N. Przybilla, M. Puech, Derryck T. Reid, A. Reiners, Rutger Rijnenberg, M. Rodrigues, Fabio Rossi, Laurence Routledge, Hans Smit, Mathias Tecza, Niranjan Thatte, R. van Boekel, A. Verma, A. ViganarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Since 2005 ESO has been working with its community and industry to develop an extremely large optical/infrared telescope. ESO's Extremely Large Telescope, or ELT for short, is a revolutionary ground-based telescope that will have a 39-metre main mirror and will be the largest visible and infrared light telescope in the world. To address specific topics that are needed for the science operations and calibrations of the telescope, thirteen specific working groups were created to coordinate the effort between ESO, the instrument consortia, and the wider community. We describe here the goals of these working groups as well as their achievements so far.

Introduction

The European Southern Observatory (ESO) is currently developing the Extremely Large Telescope (ELT), a 39-meter optical/infrared observatory slated for first light in 2028. As the largest ground-based telescope of its kind, the ELT presents unprecedented challenges in both engineering and operations. Traditional calibration methods, which often rely on empirical observations of standard stars, are projected to be too time-consuming for an instrument of this scale. To ensure peak scientific efficiency, ESO established 13 specialized working groups (WGs) to coordinate development between the observatory, instrument consortia, and the broader astronomical community.

A Modular Collaborative Framework

The operational strategy for the ELT relies on a modular, interconnected system of tools and standards. These WGs address critical areas such as atmospheric modeling, adaptive optics (AO) performance, and detector characterization. A central theme of this effort is the creation of a "feedback loop" where data from one domain—such as real-time "Astro-weather" monitoring—directly informs other processes like PSF reconstruction and telluric correction.

System diagram showing the interconnectedness of ELT calibration and simulation tools.

Technical Methodologies and Innovations

To minimize the overhead of calibration, the WGs are shifting toward synthetic modeling. Tools like Molecfit are used to generate synthetic atmospheric absorption spectra, potentially reclaiming up to 10% of observing time previously lost to telluric star observations. For AO characterization, the TIPTOP algorithm provides rapid PSF predictions, enabling researchers to model instrument performance under varying atmospheric conditions in seconds.

Furthermore, the groups utilize advanced computational techniques, including Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs), to identify problematic binary stars in guide-star catalogues (e.g., Gaia EDR3) that might otherwise degrade wavefront sensing. Detector simulations are standardized through the PyXel framework, allowing for precise modeling of complex effects like persistence and non-linearity in HgCdTe sensors.

Key Results and Operational Impact

The collaborative effort has already yielded significant tools and datasets. The ELVIS (ELT Virtual Instrument Simulator) now serves as a backbone for first-order observation simulations. In terms of detector science, the Persistence WG has developed automated mapping techniques to correct remnant signals, which is vital for high-contrast imaging.

Comparison between real data and TIPTOP simulation, showing the accuracy of the PSF reconstruction.

The TIPTOP tool, illustrated above, demonstrates high fidelity in matching real-world data, providing a robust framework for proposal preparation and queue scheduling. Additionally, new candidate spectro-photometric standard stars have been identified and vetted using VLT/X-shooter data to provide noise-free references for the ELT’s high sensitivity.

Future Challenges and Limitations

Despite these advancements, several hurdles remain. Our understanding of the near-IR sky continuum emission is still limited, and calibrating non-common path aberrations within the instruments themselves remains a priority. Additionally, the sheer volume of AO telemetry data—estimated at 10 TB per night—requires ongoing refinement of compression and archiving strategies. For high-precision fundamental physics, the team anticipates that Laser Frequency Combs (LFCs) will eventually be required to surpass the limitations of current laboratory atomic transition measurements.

By integrating software development with hardware design through these 13 working groups, ESO is ensuring that the ELT will be ready to deliver transformative science from day one.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since 2005 ESO has been working with its community and industry to develop an extremely large optical/infrared telescope. ESO's Extremely Large Telescope, or ELT for short, is a revolutionary ground-based telescope that will have a 39-metre main mirror and will be the largest visible and infrared light telescope in the world. To address specific topics that are needed for the science operations and calibrations of the telescope, thirteen specific working groups were created to coordinate the effort between ESO, the instrument consortia, and the wider community. We describe here the goals of these working groups as well as their achievements so far.
BibTeX
@misc{padovani2022eso,
  author = {P. Padovani and Michele Cirasuolo and R. F. J. van der Burg and F. Cantalloube and E. M. George and M. Kasper and Kieran Leschinski and C. J. A. P. Martins and J. Milli and Sabine Möhler and Mark Neeser and Benoît Neichel and Ángel Otarola and Rubén Sánchez-Janssen and Benoît Serra and A. Smette and E. Valenti and Christophe Vérinaud and J. Vernet and Olivier Absil and Guido Agapito and Morten Andersen and Carmelo Arcidiacono and Matej Arko and Pierre Baudoz and Olivier Beltramo-Martin and Enrico Biancalani and Thomas Bierwirth and L. Burtscher and Giulia Carlà and Julio A. Castro-Almazán and Anne-Laure Cheffot and L. Coccato and Carlos Correia and Romain Fétick and G. Fiorentino and Thierry Fusco and B. García‐Lorenzo and N. P. Gentile Fusillo and O. González López and A. Grazian and Marco Gullieuszik and O. Hainaut and V. D. Ivanov and Melanie Kaasinen and Darshan Kaddad and T. Kamiński and Wolfgang Kausch and F. Kerber and S. Kimeswenger and Rosita Kokotanekova and Arseniy I. Kuznetsov and Alexis K.H. Lau and Miska Le Louarn and Frédéric Lemmel and J. Liske and G. Lo Curto and David Lucsanyi and Lars Lundin and Stefan Noll and Sylvain Oberti and James Osborn and Elena Masciadri and Dinko Milaković and M. T. Murphy and Fernando Pedichini and M. Pereira-Santaella and Roberto Piazzesi and Javier Piqueras López and Cédric Plantet and Thibaut Prod’homme and N. Przybilla and M. Puech and Derryck T. Reid and A. Reiners and Rutger Rijnenberg and M. Rodrigues and Fabio Rossi and Laurence Routledge and Hans Smit and Mathias Tecza and Niranjan Thatte and R. van Boekel and A. Verma and A. Vigan},
  title = {{The ESO's Extremely Large Telescope Working Groups}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2302.14375},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14375},
}
Figure