The Potential of Exozodiacal Disks Observations with the WFIRST Coronagraph Instrument

Bertrand Mennesson, Vanessa P. Bailey, Jeremy Kasdin, John T. Trauger, Olivier Absil, Rachel Akeson, L. Armus, Jean-Loup Baudino, Pierre Baudoz, Andrea Bellini, D. P. Bennett, G. Bruce Berriman, A. Boccaletti, S. Calchi Novati, Kenneth G. Carpenter, C. Chen, W. C. Danchi, John H. Debes, Denis Defrère, Steve Ertel, M. A. Frerking, Christopher R. Gelino, J. H. Girard, Tyler D. Groff, S. Kane, G. Hélou, Jason S. Kalirai, Quentin Kral, John Krist, J. Kruk, Y. Hasegawa, A.‐m. Lagrange, Seppo Laine, M. Langlois, Patrick Lowrance, Anne-Lise Maire, Sangeeta Malhotra, Avi M. Mandell, Philip J. Marshall, Michael W. McElwain, Tiffany Meshkat, R. Millan‐Gabet, Leonidas A. Moustakas, B. Nemati, R. Paladini, M. Postman, Laurent Pueyo, Elisa V. Quintana, S. Ramírez, Jason Rhodes, A. J. Eldorado Riggs, M. Rizzo, Daniel Rouan, Rémi Soummer, Karl Stapelfeldt, Christopher C. Stark, Margaret Turnbull, Roeland P. van der Marel, A. Vigan, Marie Ygouf, M. C. Wyatt, Feng Zhao, Neil T. ZimmermanarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The Wide Field Infrared Survey Telescope (WFIRST) Coronagraph Instrument (CGI) will be the first high-performance stellar coronagraph using active wavefront control for deep starlight suppression in space, providing unprecedented levels of contrast, spatial resolution, and sensitivity for astronomical observations in the optical. One science case enabled by the CGI will be taking images and (R~50) spectra of faint interplanetary dust structures present in the habitable zone of nearby sunlike stars (~10 pc) and within the snow-line of more distant ones (~20 pc), down to dust density levels commensurate with that of the solar system zodiacal cloud. Reaching contrast levels below ~10⁻⁷ for the first time, CGI will cross an important threshold in debris disks physics, accessing disks with low enough optical depths that their structure is dominated by transport phenomena than collisions. Hence, CGI results will be crucial for determining how exozodiacal dust grains are produced and transported in low-density disks around mature stars. Additionally, CGI will be able to measure the brightness level and constrain the degree of asymmetry of exozodiacal clouds around individual nearby sunlike stars in the optical, at the ~10x solar zodiacal emission level. This information will be extremely valuable for optimizing the observational strategy of possible future exo-Earth direct imaging missions, especially those planning to operate at optical wavelengths, such as Habitable Exoplanet Observatory (HabEx) and the Large Ultraviolet/Optical/Infrared Surveyor (LUVOIR).

Introduction: The Challenge of Exozodiacal Dust

Searching for "Earth 2.0" involves more than just identifying a small planet; it requires peering through a "glowing fog" known as exozodiacal dust. This dust, composed of small grains from asteroid collisions and comet evaporation, is a double-edged sword. While it provides insights into planetary dynamics, its brightness creates background noise that complicates direct imaging. Bright dust clouds can increase required exposure times or form "clumps" that mimic planets, leading to false positives.

The 'Haystacks' model simulating the modern solar system in true color, illustrating the exozodiacal dust 'fog'.

Currently, our understanding of this dust is limited to the mid-infrared (mid-IR) spectrum or systems with high dust density. We lack high-resolution, visible-light data for sun-like stars at low dust densities—data essential for designing future flagship missions like HabEx or LUVOIR.

Methodology: The WFIRST Coronagraph Instrument (CGI)

The Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope's (formerly WFIRST) CGI is a technology demonstrator designed to achieve starlight suppression (contrast) levels below $10^{-7}$. It employs several advanced technical approaches:

  • Active Wavefront Control: Deformable mirrors cancel out starlight "speckles" to reveal faint dust structures.
  • Specialized Coronagraphs: The Hybrid Lyot (HLC) and Shaped Pupil (SPC) masks block central starlight while allowing the surrounding disk to be imaged.
  • Imaging and Spectroscopy: CGI provides high-resolution images and low-resolution ($R \sim 50$) spectra to characterize dust grain size and composition.
Technical specifications for the CGI filters, including working angles and detection limits.

The authors utilized the "Haystacks" model to simulate how a solar system analog would appear to the CGI, accounting for resonant structures created by planetary gravity.

Key Insights and Results

CGI will be the first instrument to access disks where structure is dominated by transport phenomena (e.g., radiation pressure, Poynting-Robertson drag) rather than collisions. By using the "zodi" (a unit of dust density equivalent to our solar system's) as a metric, CGI aims to detect levels as low as 3–10 zodis—a significant improvement over current ground-based limits of ~30–100 zodis.

Key results include:

  • Unprecedented Contrast: Reaching point source detection limits of $\sim 1.5 \times 10^{-9}$ at small angular separations (0.15" to 0.43").
  • Sensitivity: Maintaining a sensitivity of roughly 3 zodis for sun-like stars within 20 parsecs (pc).
  • Resolution: Achieving spatial resolution of $\sim 50$ milliarcseconds (mas) in the visible spectrum, resolving substructures previously blurred in IR observations.

Conclusion and Future Impact

As a technology demonstration, CGI's findings will be vital for optimizing the "search and characterization" strategies of next-generation telescopes. By identifying "dusty" systems early, missions like HabEx and LUVOIR can avoid wasting valuable observation time on systems where the "fog" is too thick to reliably detect Earth-like planets. CGI fills a critical data gap, providing the visible-light data necessary to understand the behavior of submicron grains that dominate visible scattering.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Wide Field Infrared Survey Telescope (WFIRST) Coronagraph Instrument (CGI) will be the first high-performance stellar coronagraph using active wavefront control for deep starlight suppression in space, providing unprecedented levels of contrast, spatial resolution, and sensitivity for astronomical observations in the optical. One science case enabled by the CGI will be taking images and(R~50)spectra of faint interplanetary dust structures present in the habitable zone of nearby sunlike stars (~10 pc) and within the snow-line of more distant ones(~20pc), down to dust density levels commensurate with that of the solar system zodiacal cloud. Reaching contrast levels below~10-7 for the first time, CGI will cross an important threshold in debris disks physics, accessing disks with low enough optical depths that their structure is dominated by transport phenomena than collisions. Hence, CGI results will be crucial for determining how exozodiacal dust grains are produced and transported in low-density disks around mature stars. Additionally, CGI will be able to measure the brightness level and constrain the degree of asymmetry of exozodiacal clouds around individual nearby sunlike stars in the optical, at the ~10x solar zodiacal emission level. This information will be extremely valuable for optimizing the observational strategy of possible future exo-Earth direct imaging missions, especially those planning to operate at optical wavelengths, such as Habitable Exoplanet Observatory (HabEx) and the Large Ultraviolet/Optical/Infrared Surveyor (LUVOIR).
BibTeX
@misc{mennesson2019potential,
  author = {Bertrand Mennesson and Vanessa P. Bailey and Jeremy Kasdin and John T. Trauger and Olivier Absil and Rachel Akeson and L. Armus and Jean-Loup Baudino and Pierre Baudoz and Andrea Bellini and D. P. Bennett and G. Bruce Berriman and A. Boccaletti and S. Calchi Novati and Kenneth G. Carpenter and C. Chen and W. C. Danchi and John H. Debes and Denis Defrère and Steve Ertel and M. A. Frerking and Christopher R. Gelino and J. H. Girard and Tyler D. Groff and S. Kane and G. Hélou and Jason S. Kalirai and Quentin Kral and John Krist and J. Kruk and Y. Hasegawa and A.‐M. Lagrange and Seppo Laine and M. Langlois and Patrick Lowrance and Anne-Lise Maire and Sangeeta Malhotra and Avi M. Mandell and Philip J. Marshall and Michael W. McElwain and Tiffany Meshkat and R. Millan‐Gabet and Leonidas A. Moustakas and B. Nemati and R. Paladini and M. Postman and Laurent Pueyo and Elisa V. Quintana and S. Ramírez and Jason Rhodes and A. J. Eldorado Riggs and M. Rizzo and Daniel Rouan and Rémi Soummer and Karl Stapelfeldt and Christopher C. Stark and Margaret Turnbull and Roeland P. van der Marel and A. Vigan and Marie Ygouf and M. C. Wyatt and Feng Zhao and Neil T. Zimmerman},
  title = {{The Potential of Exozodiacal Disks Observations with the WFIRST Coronagraph Instrument}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1909.02161},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1909.02161},
}
Figure