Absence of selection for quantum coherence in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex: a combined evolutionary and excitonic study

Stéphanie Valleau, Romain A. Studer, Florian Häse, Christoph Kreisbeck, Rafael G. Saer, Robert E. Blankenship, Eugene I. Shakhnovich, Alán Aspuru‐Guzik

Abstract We present a study on the evolution of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson bacterial photosynthetic pigment-protein complex. This protein complex functions as an antenna. It transports absorbed photons - excitons - to a reaction center where photosynthetic reactions initiate. The efficiency of exciton transport is therefore fundamental for the photosynthetic bacterium's survival. We have reconstructed an ancestor of the complex to establish whether coherence in the exciton transport was selected for or optimized over time. We have also investigated on the role of optimizing free energy variation upon folding in evolution. We studied whether mutations which connect the ancestor to current day species were stabilizing or destabilizing from a thermodynamic view point. From this study, we established that most of these mutations were thermodynamically neutral. Furthermore, we did not see a large change in exciton transport efficiency or coherence and thus our results predict that exciton coherence was not specifically selected for.

Introduction

In the mid-2000s, the field of "quantum biology" gained significant attention when experiments suggested that the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex—a light-harvesting protein in green sulfur bacteria—uses quantum coherence to transport energy with near-perfect efficiency. This sparked a debate: did evolution specifically "tune" these proteins to exploit quantum mechanics, or is coherence an incidental byproduct of the pigment arrangement? By combining evolutionary biology with theoretical physics, this study investigates whether the efficiency or coherence of energy transport improved as bacteria evolved from their ancient ancestors to modern species like Chlorobaculum tepidum.

Reconstructing the Proterozoic Ancestor

The researchers employed ancestral sequence reconstruction to "rewind" 1.6 billion years of evolution. Using Bayesian inference on modern fmoA gene sequences, they identified the most likely amino acid sequence of the FMO ancestor from the Proterozoic era. This sequence was then folded into a 3D structure using homology modeling.

Comparison of the reconstructed ancestral FMO complex with the modern C. tepidum structure, showing high conservation of pigment positions and protein backbone.

As shown in the structural comparison, the ancestral FMO complex was remarkably similar to modern versions. The positions of the eight bacteriochlorophyll-a (BChl-a) pigments (Panel A) and the overall protein backbone (Panel B) are highly conserved. This suggests that the ancestral complex was already an incredibly efficient energy transporter, and evolution did not need to "invent" better transport mechanisms over the subsequent eons.

Evolutionary Stability and Thermodynamic Neutrality

To understand the forces driving FMO evolution, the team analyzed the thermodynamic impact of mutations. While a general analysis of all possible single-point mutations in C. tepidum shows that 65% are destabilizing, the mutations that actually occurred during evolution tell a different story.

Phylogenetic tree of the FMO complex across green sulfur bacteria, with pie charts indicating the thermodynamic impact of mutations along evolutionary branches.

The phylogenetic analysis reveals that most mutations fixed over the last billion years were thermodynamically neutral (represented by the grey segments in the pie charts). Evolution appears to have "drifted" through sequence space without significantly compromising the protein's stability. This neutrality suggests that there was no strong selection pressure to further optimize the internal physics of the complex, likely because it was already highly functional in the ancestor.

Quantum Coherence: A Physical Byproduct

The study used the Hierarchy Equation of Motion (HEOM) to simulate excitonic dynamics and compute 2D-photon echo spectra. These spectra reveal "quantum beats"—the signature of quantum coherence. Strikingly, the oscillations were nearly identical between the 1.6-billion-year-old ancestor and modern bacteria.

If quantum coherence were a trait under heavy selection pressure, one would expect it to optimize or "sharpen" over time. Since it remained stable, the authors conclude that coherence is likely a physical consequence of the close pigment arrangement required for transport, rather than a specifically selected biological feature. Mutations were more likely selected to improve external factors, such as how the FMO complex binds to the baseplate and reaction center, rather than to fine-tune quantum phases.

Conclusion

This multi-disciplinary study suggests that nature did not specifically select for "quantumness" in the FMO complex. Instead, the high efficiency of energy transport was an early achievement of evolution, and subsequent changes primarily maintained structural stability and functional integration. These findings provide a grounded evolutionary perspective on the role of quantum effects in biological systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a study on the evolution of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson bacterial photosynthetic pigment-protein complex. This protein complex functions as an antenna. It transports absorbed photons - excitons - to a reaction center where photosynthetic reactions initiate. The efficiency of exciton transport is therefore fundamental for the photosynthetic bacterium's survival. We have reconstructed an ancestor of the complex to establish whether coherence in the exciton transport was selected for or optimized over time. We have also investigated on the role of optimizing free energy variation upon folding in evolution. We studied whether mutations which connect the ancestor to current day species were stabilizing or destabilizing from a thermodynamic view point. From this study, we established that most of these mutations were thermodynamically neutral. Furthermore, we did not see a large change in exciton transport efficiency or coherence and thus our results predict that exciton coherence was not specifically selected for.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{valleau2017absence,
  author = {Stéphanie Valleau and Romain A. Studer and Florian Häse and Christoph Kreisbeck and Rafael G. Saer and Robert E. Blankenship and Eugene I. Shakhnovich and Alán Aspuru‐Guzik},
  title = {{Absence of selection for quantum coherence in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex: a combined evolutionary and excitonic study}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1021/acscentsci.7b00269},
}
Figure