A systematic search for RNA structural switches across the human transcriptome

Matvei Khoroshkin, Daniel Asarnow, Albertas Navickas, Aidan Winters, Johnny Yu, Simon K. Zhou, Shaopu Zhou, Christina Palka, Lisa Fish, K. Mark Ansel, Yifan Cheng, Luke A. Gilbert, Hani GoodarzibioRxiv 2023 · DOI

Abstract

RNA structural switches are key regulators of gene expression in bacteria, yet their characterization in Metazoa remains limited. Here we present SwitchSeeker, a comprehensive computational and experimental approach for systematic identification of functional RNA structural switches. We applied SwitchSeeker to the human transcriptome and identified 245 putative RNA switches. To validate our approach, we characterized a previously unknown RNA switch in the 3’UTR of the RORC transcript. In vivo DMS-MaPseq, coupled with cryogenic electron microscopy, confirmed its existence as two alternative structural conformations. Furthermore, we used genome-scale CRISPR screens to identify trans factors that regulate gene expression through this RNA structural switch. We found that nonsense-mediated mRNA decay acts on this element in a conformation-specific manner. SwitchSeeker provides an unbiased, experimentally-driven method for discovering RNA structural switches that shape the eukaryotic gene expression landscape.

Introduction

In molecular biology, the genetic code is often viewed as a linear sequence of nucleotides. However, RNA molecules are dynamic entities that fold into complex three-dimensional architectures. In bacteria, "riboswitches"—RNA elements that toggle between distinct conformations to regulate gene expression—are well-documented. In contrast, identifying such switches in the human transcriptome has proven exceptionally difficult.

Most existing computational tools rely on homology to known bacterial sequences, an approach that fails in eukaryotes where switches likely evolved independently. Furthermore, proving that an RNA molecule actually "switches" between states within a living cell, and that this change has a functional consequence, presents a significant technical hurdle. This study introduces SwitchSeeker, an integrated framework designed to systematically discover and validate functional RNA structural switches in humans.

The SwitchSeeker Framework

SwitchSeeker utilizes a three-pronged approach to bridge the gap between computational prediction and biological function:

  1. SwitchFinder (Computational Prediction): Unlike previous algorithms that search for specific sequences, SwitchFinder analyzes the "energy landscape" of RNA. It identifies "bistable" candidates—sequences capable of adopting two different, nearly equal-energy folding patterns separated by a low kinetic barrier.
  2. In Vivo Screening: The researchers employed DMS-MaPseq, a chemical probing technique, to observe RNA folding within living cells. Simultaneously, they used Massively Parallel Reporter Assays (MPRA) to measure how thousands of candidate switches influenced the expression of a fluorescent reporter gene.
  3. Mechanistic and Structural Validation: For high-priority candidates, the team utilized cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) to directly visualize alternative 3D conformations and CRISPR interference (CRISPRi) screens to identify the cellular machinery interacting with these switches.

Discovery of the RORC Switch

Applying SwitchSeeker to the 3’ Untranslated Regions (3’UTRs) of the human transcriptome, the authors identified 245 high-confidence functional switches. A primary focus of the study was a novel switch discovered in the RORC gene, which is critical for T-cell differentiation.

In Jurkat T-cells, the RORC switch exists in a natural equilibrium, with approximately 27% of molecules in Conformation 1 and 73% in Conformation 2. Using cryo-EM, the researchers achieved a rare feat: directly visualizing these two distinct 3D shapes for a small RNA element. Functional assays revealed that locking the RNA into Conformation 2 significantly decreased gene expression, while Conformation 1 promoted it.

Mechanism: NMD as a Regulatory Dial

Through genome-wide CRISPRi screens, the study uncovered the mechanism behind the RORC switch's regulatory power. They found that Conformation 2 specifically recruits the SURF complex, a core component of the Nonsense-Mediated Decay (NMD) machinery. While NMD is typically viewed as a quality-control system that destroys faulty mRNA, this switch repurposes NMD as a "regulatory dial." By toggling between shapes, the cell can selectively target RORC mRNA for degradation, thereby tuning protein levels.

Crucially, "mutation-rescue" experiments demonstrated that this regulation is driven by the RNA's shape, not its specific sequence. When the nucleotide sequence was altered but the structural fold was preserved, the switch remained functional. This underscores the importance of secondary and tertiary structure in eukaryotic gene regulation.

Therapeutic Implications and Future Directions

The discovery of these switches opens new avenues for precision medicine. The authors demonstrated that Antisense Oligonucleotides (ASOs) could be used to physically block one conformation, forcing the RNA into the alternative state and successfully "flipping the switch" to increase gene expression. This suggests that RNA switches could serve as viable drug targets for modulating protein levels without altering the underlying genome.

Despite these advances, several questions remain. This study focused exclusively on 3’UTRs, leaving potential switches in 5’UTRs and introns unexplored. Additionally, the current framework identifies switches that are bistable under steady-state conditions; "latent" switches that only trigger in response to specific environmental stressors (such as heat shock or drug treatment) may still be undiscovered. Identifying the natural ligands or physiological signals that trigger these switches remains the next major frontier in RNA biology.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT RNA structural switches are key regulators of gene expression in bacteria, yet their characterization in Metazoa remains limited. Here we present SwitchSeeker, a comprehensive computational and experimental approach for systematic identification of functional RNA structural switches. We applied SwitchSeeker to the human transcriptome and identified 245 putative RNA switches. To validate our approach, we characterized a previously unknown RNA switch in the 3’UTR of the RORC transcript. In vivo DMS-MaPseq, coupled with cryogenic electron microscopy, confirmed its existence as two alternative structural conformations. Furthermore, we used genome-scale CRISPR screens to identify trans factors that regulate gene expression through this RNA structural switch. We found that nonsense-mediated mRNA decay acts on this element in a conformation-specific manner. SwitchSeeker provides an unbiased, experimentally-driven method for discovering RNA structural switches that shape the eukaryotic gene expression landscape.
BibTeX
@misc{khoroshkin2023systematic,
  author = {Matvei Khoroshkin and Daniel Asarnow and Albertas Navickas and Aidan Winters and Johnny Yu and Simon K. Zhou and Shaopu Zhou and Christina Palka and Lisa Fish and K. Mark Ansel and Yifan Cheng and Luke A. Gilbert and Hani Goodarzi},
  title = {{A systematic search for RNA structural switches across the human transcriptome}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.03.11.532161},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure