Observation of structural switch in nascent SAM-VI riboswitch during transcription at single-nucleotide and single-molecule resolution

Yanyan Xue, Jun Li, Dian Chen, Xizhu Zhao, Liang Hong, Yu LiuNature Communications 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Growing RNAs fold differently as they are transcribed, which modulates their finally adopted structures. Riboswitches regulate gene expression by structural change, which are sensitive to co-transcriptionally structural biology. Here we develop a strategy to track the structural change of RNAs during transcription at single-nucleotide and single-molecule resolution and use it to monitor individual transcripts of the SAM-VI riboswitch (riboSAM) as transcription proceeds, observing co-existence of five states in riboSAM. We report a bifurcated helix in one newly identified state from NMR and single-molecule FRET (smFRET) results, and its presence directs the translation inhibition in our cellular translation experiments. A model is proposed to illustrate the distinct switch patterns and gene-regulatory outcome of riboSAM when SAM is present or absent. Our strategy enables the precise mapping of RNAs’ conformational landscape during transcription, and may combine with detection methods other than smFRET for structural studies of RNAs in general.

Introduction: The Challenge of Co-transcriptional Folding

RNA molecules do not emerge fully formed; they fold into complex shapes as they are being synthesized by RNA polymerase—a process called co-transcriptional folding. These intermediate shapes often dictate the molecule's final function, especially in "riboswitches," which act as cellular sensors that turn genes on or off based on the presence of specific ligands.

The challenge is that most structural biology tools (like X-ray crystallography or standard NMR) look at the final, "equilibrium" structure. Existing methods to study the folding process itself either lack the resolution to see what happens at a single-nucleotide level or cannot observe individual molecules, masking the diversity of shapes an RNA might take. This paper addresses this "blind spot" in RNA biology by introducing a high-resolution tracking method.

Methods: A Hybrid Approach for Real-Time Observation

The researchers developed a strategy called modified PLOR-smFRET, combining biochemical labeling with single-molecule imaging:

  1. Modified PLOR (Position-specific Labeling of RNA): The team used a "pause-restart" transcription method. By withholding specific building blocks (NTPs), they could stall RNA polymerase at precise locations. This allowed them to insert fluorescent probes (Cy3 and Cy5) at specific sites in the growing RNA chain.
  2. Desthiobiotin Tethering: Standard methods use biotin to stick DNA to beads, but it binds too tightly. The authors used desthiobiotin, which allowed them to gently release the transcription complexes (ECs) so they could be studied in a "liquid phase" more representative of a cell.
The modified PLOR strategy uses a pause-restart mechanism to stall RNAP and site-specifically label nascent RNA.
  1. smFRET (Single-Molecule Förster Resonance Energy Transfer): By measuring the energy transfer between the two fluorescent probes, the researchers could calculate the distance between specific parts of the RNA, effectively "watching" the molecule open and close in real-time.

Key Insights: The Discovery of the "Transit" State

The most surprising find was a fifth structural state, dubbed the "transit" state. It features a "bifurcated helix"—a hybrid structure where the RNA is caught between the "ON" (apo) and "OFF" (holo) configurations. Crucially, the transit state isn't just a brief intermediate; it is functionally active. It can sequester the ribosome-binding site, meaning the riboswitch can start inhibiting translation even before the entire RNA sequence is finished.

Stepwise elongation of the RNA transcript by a single nucleotide allows for high-resolution tracking of structural changes.

Ligand-Triggered Early Switching

In the presence of its target (SAM), the riboswitch performs its structural "flip" two nucleotides earlier than it does without the ligand. This suggests that ligands don't just stabilize a final state; they actively reshape the folding pathway. At any given transcript length, the RNA doesn't exist in just one shape. The researchers observed a co-existence of up to five different states, highlighting how dynamic and "noisy" RNA folding can be.

Key Results

  • Five-State Model: Identified the apo, transit-p, transit, holo-p, and holo states.
  • Single-Nucleotide Sensitivity: Demonstrated that adding just one nucleotide (moving from 81 to 82 nt) can trigger a massive shift in the structural population if the ligand is present.
  • Functional Validation: In cellular assays, a mutant designed to favor the "transit" state reduced protein expression by ~45%, confirming that this intermediate structure is a potent gene regulator.
  • Binding Affinity: Confirmed the SAM-VI riboswitch binds its ligand with high affinity ($K_d \approx 1.03 \mu M$).

Conclusion and Future Directions

While powerful, the method relies on "stalling" the polymerase, which may not perfectly capture the kinetics of a polymerase moving at full speed. However, the authors argue their equilibrated complexes are a good proxy for transient states. This platform could be expanded by combining it with other techniques like chemical probing (SHAPE) or electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) to provide an even more complete picture of RNA dynamics. This strategy could eventually be used to study much larger, more complex RNA machines, like the spliceosome or the ribosome itself.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Growing RNAs fold differently as they are transcribed, which modulates their finally adopted structures. Riboswitches regulate gene expression by structural change, which are sensitive to co-transcriptionally structural biology. Here we develop a strategy to track the structural change of RNAs during transcription at single-nucleotide and single-molecule resolution and use it to monitor individual transcripts of the SAM-VI riboswitch (riboSAM) as transcription proceeds, observing co-existence of five states in riboSAM. We report a bifurcated helix in one newly identified state from NMR and single-molecule FRET (smFRET) results, and its presence directs the translation inhibition in our cellular translation experiments. A model is proposed to illustrate the distinct switch patterns and gene-regulatory outcome of riboSAM when SAM is present or absent. Our strategy enables the precise mapping of RNAs’ conformational landscape during transcription, and may combine with detection methods other than smFRET for structural studies of RNAs in general.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xue2023observation,
  author = {Yanyan Xue and Jun Li and Dian Chen and Xizhu Zhao and Liang Hong and Yu Liu},
  title = {{Observation of structural switch in nascent SAM-VI riboswitch during transcription at single-nucleotide and single-molecule resolution}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-38042-2},
}
Figure