A Survey of PPG's Application in Authentication

Lin Li, Chao Chen, Lei Pan, Leo Yu Zhang, Zhifeng Wang, Jun Zhang, Yang Xiang

Abstract

Biometric authentication has prospered due to its convenience and inherent security. However, early generations of biometric mechanisms often suffer from spoofing attacks. Recently, unobservable physiological signals—such as Electroencephalogram (EEG), Photoplethysmogram (PPG), and Electrocardiogram (ECG)—have emerged as potential remedies. Specifically, PPG measures blood flow changes via optical methods. While clinically used for monitoring oxygen saturation and heart rate, PPG signals contain rich individual cardiac information suitable for cybersecurity. This survey explores the unique advantages of PPG—simple acquisition, difficulty to steal, and inherent liveness detection—while systematizing the current research landscape into a unified framework and identifying future directions.

Introduction: The Vulnerability of Traditional Biometrics

Traditional biometrics like fingerprints and facial recognition face a significant "publicity" challenge: they are easily observable and replicable. Fingerprints are left on physical surfaces, and faces are captured by ubiquitous cameras, making them vulnerable to presentation attacks using 3D masks or lifted prints.

Physiological signals offer a more robust alternative. PPG, the signal used by smartwatches to track heart rate, is generated internally and responds directly to the human heartbeat. This makes it exceptionally difficult to "steal" from a distance and provides built-in liveness detection. Despite its potential, PPG research has remained fragmented. This paper proposes a standard framework to unify the field and bridge the gap toward mainstream adoption.

The Four-Layered PPG Authentication Framework

To categorize the existing body of research, we propose a four-layered architecture that tracks the signal from the sensor to the final authentication decision.

1. Signal Acquisition Layer

This layer distinguishes between contact-based methods (e.g., pulse oximeters and wearables) and remote methods (rPPG). While contact methods provide high-fidelity data, rPPG uses standard cameras to detect subtle skin color changes from a distance, offering a "frictionless" user experience.

Overview of the Signal Acquisition Layer, contrasting contact-based and remote PPG methods.

2. Signal Conditioning Layer

The primary challenge in PPG processing is noise, particularly Motion Artifacts (MA) and baseline wander caused by respiration. Researchers employ various denoising techniques, including Kalman filters and Empirical Mode Decomposition, to isolate the clean cardiac signal.

3. PPG Representation Layer

Raw waveforms must be converted into a "digital signature." This involves extracting fiducial points (such as systolic peaks or the dicrotic notch) or applying mathematical transforms (Fourier or Wavelet) to analyze the signal's frequency components.

4. Security Authentication Layer

The final layer involves the decision-making engine. Approaches range from traditional similarity metrics, such as Euclidean distance and bit-wise comparisons, to modern deep learning architectures like CNNs and LSTMs that capture complex temporal patterns.

Common metrics and methods used in the Security Authentication Layer to compare PPG signatures.

Dataset Analysis

A meta-analysis of over 20 public datasets reveals a diverse landscape. Key resources include PPG-DaLiA, which captures signals during daily activities, and MIMIC-III, a massive clinical dataset. However, a critical gap remains: few datasets are designed for long-term authentication, which is necessary to test how a user's signature holds up over weeks or months.

Key Insights and Performance

  • The Liveness Advantage: It is nearly impossible to simulate the complex hemodynamic response of a living human using a static mask or screen, making PPG highly resistant to DeepFakes.
  • The rPPG Paradox: While remote PPG is convenient, it introduces the risk of "long-distance" biometric theft via high-definition video.
  • Accuracy: Many studies report Equal Error Rates (EER) below 5%, with deep learning models achieving near-perfect identification in controlled, single-session environments.

Challenges and Future Work

The most significant hurdle is the conflict between permanence and physiology. A PPG signal changes based on stress, exercise, or temperature. Future research must focus on "cross-session" authentication—identifying a user despite these physiological shifts. Additionally, as we move toward AI-driven models, we must defend against adversarial attacks and optimize algorithms for the resource-constrained hardware of wearable devices.

Summary updated

Abstract

Biometric authentication prospered because of its convenient use and security. Early generations of biometric mechanisms suffer from spoofing attacks. Recently, unobservable physiological signals (e.g., Electroencephalogram, Photoplethysmogram, Electrocardiogram) as biometrics offer a potential remedy to this problem. In particular, Photoplethysmogram (PPG) measures the change in blood flow of the human body by an optical method. Clinically, researchers commonly use PPG signals to obtain patients' blood oxygen saturation, heart rate, and other information to assist in diagnosing heart-related diseases. Since PPG signals contain a wealth of individual cardiac information, researchers have begun to explore their potential in cyber security applications. The unique advantages (simple acquisition, difficult to steal, and live detection) of the PPG signal allow it to improve the security and usability of the authentication in various aspects. However, the research on PPG-based authentication is still in its infancy. The lack of systematization hinders new research in this field. We conduct a comprehensive study of PPG-based authentication and discuss these applications' limitations before pointing out future research directions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023survey,
  author = {Lin Li and Chao Chen and Lei Pan and Leo Yu Zhang and Zhifeng Wang and Jun Zhang and Yang Xiang},
  title = {{A Survey of PPG's Application in Authentication}},
  booktitle = {Comput. Secur},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=RmtCFqxUWh},
}
Figure