Abstract
Non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) has been considered as a study-item in 3GPP for 5G new radio (NR). However, it was decided not to continue with it as a work-item, and to leave it for possible use in beyond 5G. In this paper, we first review the discussions that ended in such decision. Particularly, we present simulation comparisons between the NOMA and multi-user multiple-input-multiple-output (MU-MIMO), where the possible gain of NOMA, compared to MU-MIMO, is negligible. Then, we propose a number of methods to reduce the implementation complexity and delay of both uplink (UL) and downlink (DL) NOMA-based transmission, as different ways to improve its efficiency. Here, particular attention is paid to reducing the receiver complexity, the cost of hybrid automatic repeat request as well as the user pairing complexity. As demonstrated, different smart techniques can be applied to improve the energy efficiency and the end-to-end transmission delay of NOMA-based systems.
Introduction
In the evolution of cellular networks, "Multiple Access" schemes define how users share the available radio spectrum. While traditional methods like OFDMA (used in 4G and 5G) are orthogonal—assigning each user a unique resource block in time or frequency—Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) allows multiple users to share the same resource simultaneously. By using power-domain multiplexing or code-domain spreading, NOMA aims to significantly increase the number of supported devices, a critical requirement for the massive Internet of Things (mIoT) expected in 6G.
Despite its theoretical promise, NOMA was ultimately excluded from 5G New Radio (NR) work items by the 3GPP. This paper explores the technical hurdles that led to this decision and proposes a roadmap of low-complexity innovations designed to make NOMA a viable candidate for the 6G era.
The Performance Gap: NOMA vs. MU-MIMO
The primary reason for NOMA's exclusion from 5G was the "complexity vs. gain" trade-off. During the 3GPP Release 15 study-item, extensive simulations compared NOMA (specifically Welch-bound equality spread multiple access, or WSMA) against Multi-User MIMO (MU-MIMO). The results revealed that in ideal conditions, NOMA provided only a marginal gain of approximately 1.0 to 1.3 dB over existing MU-MIMO techniques.
This small performance boost was deemed insufficient to justify the high computational cost of Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) at the receiver. Furthermore, under non-ideal channel estimation, this gain often vanishes entirely at low Signal-to-Noise Ratios (SNR), making NOMA sensitive to real-world imperfections.
Proposed Low-Complexity Innovations
To overcome these barriers, the authors propose several "smart" strategies to reduce the implementation overhead of NOMA systems:
1. Smart NOMA-HARQ
Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ) is essential for error correction. In a NOMA context, the authors propose a protocol where the Base Station (BS) selectively requests retransmissions. If one user's signal is decoded successfully, it can be used to "clean" the interference for the remaining user in the pair, reducing the total number of required retransmissions and improving energy efficiency.
2. Rate-Based User Pairing
Traditional NOMA requires perfect, real-time channel state information (CSI) for all users to perform optimal pairing, which creates massive signaling overhead. The authors suggest pairing users based on their data rate demands and statistical success probabilities instead. This "rate-based" approach significantly reduces the control signaling required to manage the network.
3. Receiver Adaptation and Fail-Fast Decoding
To save battery life on mobile devices, the authors propose a "fail-fast" decoding approach. If the first user’s signal in a NOMA pair is too corrupted to decode, the receiver immediately stops processing rather than wasting energy on subsequent interference cancellation steps that are likely to fail.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
While NOMA struggled to compete with MU-MIMO in the relatively sparse environments of 5G, its true potential lies in ultra-dense 6G deployments. MU-MIMO tends to "saturate" or hit an error floor when the number of users exceeds the number of antennas. In these overloaded scenarios, NOMA maintains superior performance.
Future research must focus on moving these theoretical low-complexity protocols into hardware implementations and exploring NOMA for "Grant-Free" access. By enabling devices to transmit without waiting for explicit permission from the base station, NOMA can fulfill its promise as the backbone for the next generation of massive connectivity.
Summary updated