A Survey of NOMA: Current Status and Open Research Challenges

Behrooz Makki, Krishna Chitti, Ali Behravan, Mohamed‐Slim Alouini

Abstract

Non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) has been considered as a study-item in 3GPP for 5G new radio (NR). However, it was decided not to continue with it as a work-item, and to leave it for possible use in beyond 5G. In this paper, we first review the discussions that ended in such decision. Particularly, we present simulation comparisons between the Welch-bound equality spread multiple access (WSMA)-based NOMA and multi-user multiple-input-multiple-output (MU-MIMO), where the possible gain of WSMA-based NOMA, compared to MU-MIMO, is negligible. Then, we summarize the 3GPP discussions on NOMA, and propose a number of methods to reduce the implementation complexity and delay of both uplink (UL) and downlink (DL) NOMA-based transmission, as different ways to improve its efficiency. Here, particular attention is paid to reducing the receiver complexity, the cost of hybrid automatic repeat request as well as the user pairing complexity. As demonstrated, different smart techniques can be applied to improve the energy efficiency and the end-to-end transmission delay of NOMA-based systems.

Introduction: The NOMA vs. MU-MIMO Deadlock

The evolution of cellular networks is a constant battle for spectral efficiency—maximizing the number of users served within a limited frequency band. While Orthogonal Multiple Access (OMA) assigns unique time or frequency slots to each user, Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) allows multiple users to share the same resources simultaneously. By employing sophisticated interference cancellation at the receiver, NOMA aims to surpass the capacity limits of traditional OMA.

Despite its promise, 3GPP Release 15 ultimately sidelined NOMA as a "work-item" for 5G New Radio (NR). The primary reason was a "diminishing returns" problem: when compared to advanced Multi-User MIMO (MU-MIMO), which utilizes spatial separation, NOMA's marginal throughput gains did not justify the significant increases in receiver complexity, power consumption, and signaling overhead. This paper explores the technical hurdles behind this decision and proposes architectural improvements to make NOMA a viable candidate for 6G.

Proposed Methodology: Enhancing WSMA-NOMA

The authors focus on Welch-bound equality Spread Multiple Access (WSMA), a specific NOMA variant that utilizes non-orthogonal short spreading sequences to distinguish overlapping users. To address the complexity and delay issues identified by 3GPP, three primary architectural shifts are proposed:

  1. Smart NOMA-HARQ: This retransmission protocol optimizes the recovery of failed packets. If a transmission fails, the Base Station (BS) can request one user to pause while another retransmits. This allows the BS to use Maximum Ratio Combining (MRC) to enhance the first signal before applying Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) to the second, effectively reducing the total number of retransmissions required.
  2. Rate-Based User Pairing: Traditional NOMA often requires perfect, instantaneous Channel State Information (CSI), creating a massive signaling bottleneck. The authors propose pairing users based on their data rate requirements and statistical success probabilities, significantly reducing signaling overhead.
  3. Adaptive Receiver Logic: Standard SIC is often an "all or nothing" process. The proposed logic allows the receiver to "early-exit" if the primary user's signal is deemed unrecoverable, saving energy and reducing the end-to-end (E2E) delay that often plagues NOMA systems.
Transmitter block diagram for a WSMA-based NOMA system, showing the progression from input bits to output symbols through spreading and modulation.

Simulation and Performance Analysis

The study utilizes link-level and system-level simulations based on 3GPP-standardized models to evaluate performance. The scenarios focus on Massive Machine Type Communications (mMTC) using Tapped Delay Line (TDL) channel models.

Key Insights

  • The Reality of Channel Estimation: In ideal conditions, NOMA provides a ~1 dB gain over MU-MIMO. However, this gain virtually disappears when non-ideal channel estimation is factored in—a critical finding that influenced 3GPP's decision.
  • The Overloading Advantage: NOMA's true strength lies in "overloaded" scenarios where the number of users exceeds available orthogonal resources. In low-density scenarios, OMA remains more efficient.
  • Virtual Diversity: By dynamically re-pairing users during Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ) rounds, the system can achieve "virtual diversity," improving decoding success without increasing transmit power.

Results and Discussion

Simulations involving 6 to 12 users demonstrated that WSMA-NOMA can achieve a 1 to 1.3 dB SNR gain over MU-MIMO at a $10^{-2}$ Block Error Rate (BLER), assuming perfect channel estimation. While MU-MIMO performance tends to saturate quickly in high-load, interference-limited scenarios, NOMA maintains a lower error floor, allowing for higher user density at the cost of increased SNR requirements.

Furthermore, the proposed Smart-HARQ and adaptive receiver methods showed significant improvements in energy efficiency and reductions in E2E packet delay compared to conventional NOMA implementations.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While NOMA faced setbacks in 5G standardization, its potential for 6G remains significant, particularly in ultra-dense networks like smart factories or massive IoT deployments where spatial degrees of freedom are exhausted. Future work must address the signaling overhead for mobile handsets in the downlink and provide hardware-level benchmarks (e.g., FPGA/ASIC) to validate the proposed algorithmic complexity reductions for industry adoption.

Summary updated

Abstract

Non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) has been considered as a study-item in 3GPP for 5G new radio (NR). However, it was decided not to continue with it as a work-item, and to leave it for possible use in beyond 5G. In this paper, we first review the discussions that ended in such decision. Particularly, we present simulation comparisons between the Welch-bound equality spread multiple access (WSMA)-based NOMA and multi-user multiple-input-multiple-output (MU-MIMO), where the possible gain of WSMA-based NOMA, compared to MU-MIMO, is negligible. Then, we summarize the 3GPP discussions on NOMA, and propose a number of methods to reduce the implementation complexity and delay of both uplink (UL) and downlink (DL) NOMA-based transmission, as different ways to improve its efficiency. Here, particular attention is paid to reducing the receiver complexity, the cost of hybrid automatic repeat request as well as the user pairing complexity. As demonstrated, different smart techniques can be applied to improve the energy efficiency and the end-to-end transmission delay of NOMA-based systems.
BibTeX
@article{makki2020survey,
  author = {Behrooz Makki and Krishna Chitti and Ali Behravan and Mohamed‐Slim Alouini},
  title = {{A Survey of NOMA: Current Status and Open Research Challenges}},
  journal = {IEEE Open J. Commun. Soc.},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=YOIvv2_t3eL3},
}
Figure