A Study on the Influence of Motor Imagery Training at Different Speeds on the Maximum Strength of Elbow Flexion

Chen Feng, Huang Zhi-jianLeisure 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to explore the difference of the influence of motor imagery with different speeds on the maximum power of the exercisers, to find the image mode suitable for improving the performance of maximum power, and to explore the possible functional differences between motor imagery with different speeds. A mixed study design of 4 groups × 2 tests was adopted. 79 subjects were randomly divided into a slow group (n=19), real speed group (n=19), fast group (n=22), and a control group (n=19). The experiment consisted of three parts: pre-test of elbow flexion strength, imagery training, and post-test of elbow flexion strength. Results showed that strength performance in the real speed and fast groups increased significantly after intervention ($p < 0.01$), while no significant difference was found in the slow speed or control groups. Comparing changes in maximum strength across groups revealed significant differences ($p < 0.01$). Specifically, strength growth in the fast group ($p < 0.01$) and real speed group ($p = 0.01$) was significantly greater than in the control group. Conclusion: (1) Real speed and fast motor imagery training promote strength performance; (2) Different imagery speeds lead to different functional understandings of imagery content.

Introduction

Motor Imagery (MI)—the mental simulation of physical action without overt movement—is a well-established tool in sports psychology for enhancing motor skills and muscle strength. However, the optimal parameters for MI, particularly the speed of mental rehearsal, remain a subject of debate. While some suggest slow-motion visualization for technical precision, others argue for real-time simulation to maintain functional equivalence. This study investigates how varying imagery speeds affect 1-Repetition Maximum (1RM) strength in elbow flexion, aiming to identify the most effective visualization speed for strength gains.

Methodology

The study involved 79 male university students with prior resistance training experience. To ensure the validity of the mental training, participants were screened using the Movement Imagery Questionnaire-Revised (MIQ-R) to establish high baseline kinesthetic and visual imagery abilities.

Subjects were randomly assigned to one of four experimental conditions:

  1. Slow Speed Group (SMG): Visualized the movement at a pace slower than real life.
  2. Real Speed Group (RTG): Visualized the movement at a natural, real-time pace.
  3. Fast Speed Group (FMG): Visualized the movement at a pace faster than real life.
  4. Control Group (CTL): Watched unrelated videos.

The intervention followed the PETTLEP model, a gold-standard framework that ensures mental practice is functionally equivalent to the physical task across seven dimensions: Physical, Environmental, Task, Timing, Learning, Emotion, and Perspective. Training consisted of 12 sessions guided by audio and video prompts to standardize the imagery experience.

Results

The primary metric was the 1RM of elbow flexion measured in kilograms. Statistical analysis using independent T-tests and one-way ANOVA revealed that only specific imagery speeds yielded strength gains.

Comparison of 1RM strength (kg) pre-test (blue) and post-test (orange) across the four experimental groups.

As shown in the data, the Fast Speed Group (FMG) and Real Speed Group (RTG) demonstrated significant improvements in 1RM strength. The FMG showed the most substantial growth, with an average increase of 0.91 kg ($p < 0.01$), followed by the RTG with an increase of 0.58 kg ($p = 0.01$). Conversely, the Slow Speed Group (SMG) showed no significant change ($p = 0.75$), and the Control Group (CTL) experienced a slight decrease in performance (-0.53 kg, $p = 0.02$).

Detailed statistical breakdown of pre- and post-test 1RM results, including t-values and significance levels for each group.

Discussion

The findings support the "Psychoneuromuscular Theory," which posits that vivid visualization triggers low-level neural impulses to the muscles. When the timing of imagery matches the real-world task (functional equivalence), these neural pathways are reinforced more effectively.

The lack of improvement in the Slow Speed Group suggests that slow-motion imagery may be perceived by the brain as a different cognitive task—perhaps focusing on technique or form rather than power—which fails to translate into maximum strength gains. Furthermore, the extended duration of slow imagery might increase cognitive load, potentially exhausting working memory or diluting the focus on the explosive intent required for a 1RM lift. The slight decrease in the control group may be attributed to a lack of intervention or minor fatigue over the study period.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that the speed of motor imagery is a critical factor in strength training interventions. For athletes looking to enhance maximum power, mental rehearsal should be performed at real-time or fast speeds to ensure functional equivalence and neural reinforcement of the target movement. Future research should explore if these findings apply to more complex, multi-joint movements like squats or deadlifts.

Summary updated

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to explore the difference of the influence of motor imagery with different speeds on the maximum power of the exercisers, to find the image mode suitable for improving the performance of maximum power, and to explore the possible functional differences between motor imagery with different speeds. A mixed study design of 4 groups×2 tests was adopted. 79 subjects were randomly divided into slow group (n=19), real speed group (n=19), fast group (n=22) and a control group (n=19). The experiment is divided into three parts: pretest of elbow bending strength, image training and post-test of elbow bending strength. The results showed that the strength performance of the real speed group and the fast group increased significantly after the intervention (p<0.01), while there was no significant difference between the slow speed group and the control group. Comparing the changes in the maximum strength of elbow flexion measured before and after the members of different speed groups, it was found that the changes between groups were significantly different (p<0.01). Specifically, the growth of the maximum strength of elbow flexion in the fast group (p<0.01) and the real speed group (p=0.01) was significantly greater than that in the control group, while there was no significant difference in the growth of elbow flexion strength between the other groups. Conclusion: (1) Real speed and fast motor image training can promote the strength performance of the subjects; (2) When using different motor imagery training speeds, subjects have different functional understandings of the content of imagery.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2024study,
  author = {Chen Feng and Huang Zhi-jian},
  title = {{A Study on the Influence of Motor Imagery Training at Different Speeds on the Maximum Strength of Elbow Flexion}},
  booktitle = {Leisure},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.35534/lsh.0402015},
}
Figure