A Review on Impact of Covid-19 on Labor Migration: Ethical Lessons for Human Resource Management (HRM)

Rashmi Prabha Singh, Abhishek Singh, Divya Sharma, Shweta MishraGurukul 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The COVID-19 pandemic triggered a global crisis in Human Resource Management (HRM), exposing deep vulnerabilities within labor structures. While the organized sector successfully transitioned to remote work through technological support, industrial and manufacturing units reliant on on-site human resources faced catastrophic job losses. This paper examines the mass labor migration that occurred in India, focusing on the populous states of Uttar Pradesh (UP) and Bihar. By reviewing government and private sector responses, this study identifies critical ethical lessons for HRM, advocating for resilient policies and ethical guidelines to manage future health emergencies.

Introduction: The Pandemic and the Labor Crisis

The COVID-19 pandemic was more than a health crisis; it was a transformative event for global labor markets. According to the International Labour Organization (ILO), the pandemic reduced global working hours by approximately 7% in the second quarter of 2020—equivalent to the loss of 195 million full-time jobs. In India, the crisis manifested as a massive "reverse migration," where millions of workers in the unorganized sector were forced to return to their home towns following the sudden imposition of lockdowns.

Traditional HRM frameworks, typically designed for stable environments and salaried employees, proved ill-equipped to handle the logistical and ethical complexities of a migrant workforce. This paper analyzes the disparity between sectors and the resulting humanitarian challenges.

The Digital Divide: Organized vs. Unorganized Sectors

The pandemic highlighted a stark "technological privilege." The organized sector utilized digital platforms to protect jobs and maintain productivity. In contrast, the unorganized sector—comprising contract laborers, street vendors, and daily wage workers—faced total economic collapse.

Data from the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) indicates that approximately 122 million jobs were lost in 2020, with three-quarters of these losses occurring among wage laborers and minor dealers in the unorganized sector. The economic impact was disproportionate: informal workers faced a staggering wage loss of approximately ₹81,122 crore, while the formal sector's loss was limited to ₹5,326 crore. This divide underscores the urgent need for HRM strategies that extend beyond white-collar environments.

The Humanitarian Crisis of Reverse Migration

The mass exodus of migrant workers from urban centers to rural states like Uttar Pradesh and Bihar represented a significant failure of both state and corporate social responsibility. Millions were forced to walk hundreds of kilometers due to a lack of transportation and immediate loss of income.

Beyond the immediate physical hardship, the "remobilization" of this labor force has proven difficult. The trauma of the reverse migration created a lasting hesitancy among workers to return to urban industrial hubs, leading to persistent labor shortages and project delays in the post-lockdown period. This "remobilization paradox" suggests that HRM must prioritize worker trust and psychological well-being to ensure long-term industrial stability.

Policy and Institutional Interventions

In response to the crisis, the Indian government and various international agencies launched several relief packages and social security schemes. These initiatives aimed to provide immediate sustenance and long-term structural support to the displaced workforce.

Table 1: Key Government Schemes and Relief Packages for Migrant Workers.

While schemes like "One Nation One Ration Card" and the "PM Garib Kalyan Yojana" provided essential short-term relief, they also revealed the structural flaws of the unorganized sector, such as the lack of formal contracts and social security benefits. The pandemic brought to light the pressing need for labor reforms and improved financial inclusion.

Ethical Lessons for HRM

The core of the HRM failure during COVID-19 was an ethical one. Most organizations lacked contingency plans for a health crisis, resulting in reactive and often "disrupting" behavior toward laborers. Ethical HRM in the future must move toward a proactive model that includes robust surveillance, emergency equipment, and clear communication strategies.

Table 2: Roles of Various Agencies in Supporting Migrants during the Pandemic.

As shown in Table 2, a multi-agency approach was required to address the diverse needs of migrants, from psychological well-being programs like 'Ummeed' to specific advisories for women migrants. This highlights that future HRM policies must be gender-sensitive and inclusive of the most vulnerable groups.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The pandemic has provided a harsh but necessary lesson: HRM cannot be a "one-size-fits-all" discipline. To build resilience, future work must focus on:

  • Digital Databases: Establishing robust records for migrant workers to ensure they can be traced and supported during crises.
  • Evidence-Based Communication: Developing strategies to prevent misinformation and maintain worker trust.
  • Ethical Preparedness: Integrating crisis management and social responsibility into the core of HRM policy.

By addressing these structural and ethical gaps, organizations and governments can ensure that the labor class is not left behind in future global emergencies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Purpose: The COVID-19 has caused severe issues concerning Human Resource Management (HRM, hereafter) and organizations worldwide. Organized sectors using the work from home culture equipped with various technological supports managed their organizations and protected their jobs. However, many people lost jobs in other professional units that could not cope with technical support, such as industrial and manufacturing units, which run through on-site human resources. Indeed, this has been an issue much relevant for the HRM strategists and policy-makers. However, this paper draws attention to a significant matter relating to HRM: the mass labour migration that occurred due to COVID19 across the globe. India's two most populated states, Uttar Pradesh (UP) and Bihar, have faced severe social and economic problems because of large-scale migration. States across the county have been ordered to evacuate the people who are migrants from the other states for the proper health management to combat the pandemic. Central and state governments supported different packages. International organizations like UNDP also worked with states to help such people. However, there are tough ethical lessons to learn from this pandemic experience. This paper reviews the HRM policies and programs of the Government and Private sectors by addressing these issues. It offers some essential ethical guidelines for HRM in the view of health emergencies like COVID-19.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{singh2024review,
  author = {Rashmi Prabha Singh and Abhishek Singh and Divya Sharma and Shweta Mishra},
  title = {{A Review on Impact of Covid-19 on Labor Migration: Ethical Lessons for Human Resource Management (HRM)}},
  booktitle = {Gurukul},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.48205/gbr.v20.7},
}
Figure