Experiences and needs of front-line nurses during the COVID-19 pandemic: A systematic review and qualitative meta-synthesis

Shenglan Ding, Shuhua Deng, Yilan Zhang, Qingxia Wang, Zhiping Liu, Jing Huang, Xiaorong YangFrontiers in Public Health 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This systematic review and qualitative meta-synthesis, published in Frontiers in Public Health, aggregates the lived experiences of front-line nurses during the COVID-19 pandemic. By synthesizing 70 qualitative studies, the authors provide a high-level roadmap of the psychological trajectory, systemic failures, and eventual professional growth experienced by the "backbone" of the healthcare response. (PROSPERO: CRD42021255468).

Introduction: The Human Cost of the Pandemic

While the clinical impact of COVID-19 is well-documented, the "human cost" to the nursing workforce is often captured only in fragmented, localized qualitative studies. A single study in one region may not offer generalizable evidence for global policy. Nurses accounted for 68% of the medical staff in some of the hardest-hit areas, yet they faced disproportionate risks, including high infection rates and significant psychological distress. This paper addresses this gap by performing a qualitative meta-synthesis to identify universal themes in nursing experiences and needs.

Methodology

The researchers employed a rigorous systematic review process searching seven major databases (including PubMed, CINAHL, and PsycINFO) and two preprint servers (MedRxiv, bioRxiv) for studies published between December 2019 and January 2022.

The search strategy was guided by the SPIDER tool (Sample, Phenomenon of Interest, Design, Evaluation, Research Type), a variant of PICO specifically designed for qualitative research.

Search terms and domains defined by the SPIDER tool.

The selection process followed a structured flow, ultimately narrowing down 5,091 identified records to 70 high-quality qualitative studies included in the synthesis.

Flow chart of search results and study selection.

Included studies were evaluated using the Critical Appraisal Skills Program (CASP) tool. The authors used meta-aggregation, a three-stage process where findings are extracted, categorized based on similarity in meaning, and finally grouped into synthesized themes.

Data Overview and Geographic Scope

The "dataset" consists of 70 primary qualitative studies involving thousands of participants across more than 15 countries. The highest concentrations of data came from China (19), Iran (16), Turkey (8), and the US (7). Most studies captured the "first wave" of the pandemic (January to October 2020), providing a window into the period of maximum systemic uncertainty.

Key Insights: The Nursing Experience

The synthesis revealed several profound themes regarding the lived experience of nurses:

  • The "Nightingale" Paradox: Nurses felt a deep professional duty to volunteer, yet this altruism was often met with systemic betrayal due to inadequate PPE and manpower.
  • Dynamic Psychological Trajectory: Distress was not static; it moved from early uncertainty to a peak negative state during adaptation, eventually transitioning toward positive growth as protocols stabilized and patient recoveries increased.
  • The Burden of Stigma: A recurring theme was social rejection. Nurses reported being treated like "lepers" by their communities, leading to isolation that exacerbated work-related trauma.
  • Technology and "Nurses' Guilt": While tools like iPads connected families, nurses felt the loss of physical touch was an ethical failure in providing compassionate care.
  • Management as a Stressor: Stress often stemmed from "impulsive" and "contradictory" management decisions, such as constantly changing mask protocols and unfair work distribution.

Synthesis Results: Five Pillars of Support

The meta-synthesis produced five overarching findings:

  1. Vulnerability despite dedication: Nurses faced deep-seated fear for themselves and their families.
  2. Systemic Challenges: Universal shortages of PPE and manpower were compounded by negative public attitudes.
  3. Partial Coping: Nurses utilized media, peer support, and active learning to survive.
  4. Pivotal Needs: Five pillars of support were identified: Counseling, Training, Information, Resources, and Investment.
  5. Post-Traumatic Growth: Many reported increased professional identity and empathy despite the hardships.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The review highlights the need for "scientific support echelons"—structured, pre-planned backup systems for nursing staff. Integrating simulation-based crisis training into standard nursing education is essential to build resilience before the next global healthcare crisis. Future work should address language bias (as this review only included English-language publications) and the long-term burnout phase seen in later pandemic waves.

Summary updated

Abstract

https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/, PROSPERO: CRD42021255468.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ding2022experiences,
  author = {Shenglan Ding and Shuhua Deng and Yilan Zhang and Qingxia Wang and Zhiping Liu and Jing Huang and Xiaorong Yang},
  title = {{Experiences and needs of front-line nurses during the COVID-19 pandemic: A systematic review and qualitative meta-synthesis}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2022.805631},
}
Figure