Exilio, migración y Pandemia (2020-2022)

Adalberto Enrique Santana Hernández, Teodoro Aguilar Ortega, Laura Castañeda García, Depeng Li, F Castro, Hayled Martín Reyes Martín, María de las Mercedes Sierra Kehoe, Rolan Eduardo Soto López, Rubén Torres Martínez, Margarita Aurora Vargas Canales, Margarita Hilda Vilchis RodríguezOpenalex Unknown 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Los inicios de la tercera década del siglo XXI se encuentran signados por un gran acontecimiento mundial: la aparición de una de las epidemias más impactantes de la escena contemporánea. El desarrollo del coronavirus (COVID-19) comenzó a manifestarse con fuerza vertiginosa en todo el orbe en los primeros meses de 2020. Para finales de noviembre de 2021, la cifra de infectados alcanzaba los 262,143,965 con 5,207,160 fallecidos a nivel global. Esta pandemia, que alcanzó su punto más álgido en la tercera ola y vio el surgimiento de variantes como ómicron, no solo representó un desafío sanitario, sino que se entrelazó profundamente con los procesos históricos y contemporáneos de exilio y migración en Iberoamérica.

The Triple Crisis: History, Migration, and Health

This research addresses what can be termed a "triple crisis" of the early 2020s: the historical legacy of political exile, the modern reality of irregular migration, and the sudden shock of a global pandemic. While the link between human mobility and the spread of disease is as old as history itself, the 2020-2022 period represented a unique shift in how displacement is managed.

The authors argue that the pandemic acted as a catalyst, exposing the "necropolitics" of border control. Governments frequently utilized "sanitary security" as a convenient pretext to harden borders and justify the exclusion of vulnerable populations. By bridging the gap between historical humanities—studying exiled intellectuals and artists—and contemporary social science, this work seeks to understand how displacement is both managed by states and resisted by individuals during a global emergency.

Interdisciplinary Methodology and Data

To capture the complexity of this intersection, the study employs a diverse methodological toolkit. This includes historical and archival research into the lives of exiled figures such as David Alfaro Siqueiros and Félix Varela, alongside qualitative sociology and ethnography. Fieldwork involved semi-structured interviews and observations, particularly focusing on internal migration in Mérida, Yucatán, and the influx of Haitian migrants at the Mexican borders.

The seal of the Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (UNAM), which preserves the Raúl Estrada Discua photographic archive.

The research draws on several critical datasets:

  • The Raúl Estrada Discua Archive: A collection of nearly 8,000 photographic pieces held by UNAM, used to analyze the historical ethnographic representation of indigenous and marginalized groups.
  • Public Health Metrics: COVID-19 data from Johns Hopkins University to contextualize the scale of the crisis.
  • Migration Statistics: Data from the Mexican National Institute of Migration (INM) and U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) regarding detentions and expulsions.
  • Field Interviews: Qualitative data from specific migrant cohorts, including Haitian residents in Tijuana and service-sector migrants in Mérida.

Key Insights: The Necropolitics of Borders

A central theme of the research is the "securitization" of migration. The pandemic provided a "golden opportunity" for wealthy nations to halt migration under the guise of biosecurity. A primary example is the implementation of Title 42 in the United States, which led to over a million expulsions of irregular migrants, justified as a virus-prevention measure rather than a standard immigration policy.

Migrants navigating the complexities of displacement and public health protocols during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Furthermore, the study identifies a "two-speed" city dynamic in locations like Mérida. While a "paradisiacal" image is marketed to wealthy migrants, the essential labor of migrants from the south—who serve as cleaners, drivers, and delivery workers—is rendered invisible and increasingly precarious during lockdowns. This socio-economic fragility is a hallmark of the pandemic's impact on displaced populations.

Results and Regional Impacts

The research highlights several stark realities:

  • Border Lethality: There was a sharp increase in migrant deaths at the Mexican borders. Containment policies forced migrants into more dangerous, "invisible" routes, resulting in a 48% increase in deaths at the southern border in 2019 alone as policies tightened.
  • Haitian Vulnerability: The 2021 Haitian migration wave revealed a "city-prison" dynamic in Tapachula, where thousands were stranded without legal status, facing systemic racism and a lack of medical care.
  • Vaccine Geopolitics: The book contrasts the "monopolization" of vaccines by Western powers with the "solidarity diplomacy" of actors like Cuba and China, who provided medical brigades and vaccines to the Global South.

Conclusion: Toward a Humanist Policy

The authors acknowledge that the long-term effects of "Long COVID" on global migration patterns are still unfolding. However, the immediate conclusion is clear: migration will not stop unless structural causes such as poverty, violence, and climate change are addressed. The research calls for a fundamental shift away from punitive, military-led border management toward a humanist model that centers the rights and dignity of the traveler, regardless of their legal status.

Summary updated

Abstract

Los inicios de la tercera década del siglo xxi se encuentran signados por un gran acontecimiento mundial: la aparición de una de las epidemias más impactantes de la escena contemporánea, nos referimos al desarrollo que con fuerza vertiginosa comenzó a manifestarse en todo el orbe en los primeros meses de 2020. Se trató de la expansión del llamado coronavirus, propagación que hasta el momento de escribir estas líneas (30 de noviembre de 2021) alcanzaba en el orbe la cifra de 262,143,965 infectados y 5,207,160 fallecidos (según la University Johns Hopkins). Pandemia que adquirió su punto más álgido en la tercera ola, pero que a finales del 2021 alcanzó nueva fuerza, especialmente en los países europeos junto con la cuarta ola y la aparición de la variante ómicron, originada en Sudáfrica.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hernandez2023exilio,
  author = {Adalberto Enrique Santana Hernández and Teodoro Aguilar Ortega and Laura Castañeda García and Depeng Li and F Castro and Hayled Martín Reyes Martín and María de las Mercedes Sierra Kehoe and Rolan Eduardo Soto López and Rubén Torres Martínez and Margarita Aurora Vargas Canales and Margarita Hilda Vilchis Rodríguez},
  title = {{Exilio, migración y Pandemia (2020-2022)}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.22201/cialc.9786073081184p.2023},
}
Figure