Abstract
This fascinating study compares and contrasts the immense internal migration movements in China and Indonesia. Over the next two decades, approximately two-thirds of the rural labour force is expected to migrate, transforming their respective societies from primarily rural to urban based.
Introduction
The transition from rural to urban societies represents one of the most significant demographic shifts in modern history. By 2007, China alone saw 135 million rural migrants relocate to cities—a movement of unprecedented scale. Edited by Xin Meng and Chris Manning, The Great Migration (2010) provides a rigorous comparative analysis of these movements in China and Indonesia, exploring how different governance models shape the economic, health, and educational outcomes of hundreds of millions of individuals.
The "Migrant Gap" and Institutional Barriers
A central theme of the research is the "migrant gap." While rural-to-urban migration is essential for urban economic growth, migrants often face systemic discrimination, lower wages, and limited access to social services compared to "local" urban residents. The study contrasts China’s restrictive institutional framework with Indonesia’s more liberal migration policies.
In China, the hukou (household registration) system acts as a significant constraint, effectively serving as an "institutional tax." Even when migrants find work, they face a wage penalty and lack access to urban health and education because their rights remain tied to their place of birth. Conversely, the study suggests that Indonesia’s lack of such rigid institutional barriers allows for better integration into the urban fabric, with migrants generally faring better on health and poverty indicators.
Methodology and Data
The findings presented in the book are the primary output of the first year of the Rural–Urban Migration in China and Indonesia (RUMiCI) project, a five-year longitudinal study. The researchers utilized a multi-disciplinary approach, combining quantitative econometric analysis (such as Probit regressions and Shapley-value decomposition) with comparative institutional studies.
The RUMiCI Survey (2008) provided the core dataset:
- China: Data from 15 major cities and their corresponding rural migrant-sending provinces.
- Indonesia: Data from four major urban centers (Tangerang, Samarinda, Medan, and Makassar) and surrounding rural areas.
Key Insights and Results
- Inequality Paradox: Interestingly, while migrants in China face discrimination, their presence actually contributes to a more equal distribution of income within urban areas by filling low-to-mid-tier labor gaps.
- Poverty Reduction: Despite the hardships of the transition, migration remains the single most effective tool for lowering rural poverty in both nations. In China, migration has led to a significant rise in rural household remittances.
- The "Left-Behind" Generation: A significant portion of the research focuses on the children of migrants. The study finds that whether a child moves to the city with their parents or stays in the village significantly impacts their long-term educational and health trajectories.
Conclusion
The book highlights a critical "policy lag": while economic migration happens rapidly, institutional reform regarding social services for migrants often trails behind. This creates a "permanent temporary" class of citizens, particularly in China. As a baseline for the RUMiCI project, this study underscores the need for robust longitudinal tracking to understand the long-term assimilation and welfare of these massive migrant populations.
Summary updated