Abstract
Water ice is a fundamental building material of comets and other bodies in the outer solar system. Yet, the properties of cometary water ice are challenging to study, due to its volatility and the typical distances at which comets are observed. Cometary outbursts, impulsive mass-loss events that can liberate large amounts of material, offer opportunities to directly observe and characterize cometary water ice. We present a study of comet 243P/NEAT, instigated by a $-3$ mag outburst that occurred in December 2018. Optical images and a 251-day lightcurve were examined to characterize the outburst and the comet's quiescent activity. Variations in the quiescent lightcurve appear to be dominated by coma asymmetries, rather than changing activity levels as the comet approached and receded from the Sun. Furthermore, the lightcurve shows evidence for 1 to 2 additional small outbursts ($-0.3$ mag) occurring in September 2018. The large December 2018 outburst likely ejected water ice grains, yet no signatures of ice were found in color photometry, a color map, nor a near-infrared spectrum. We discuss possible dynamical and thermal reasons for this non-detection. In this context, we examined the comae of comets 103P/Hartley 2 and C/2013 US$_{10}$ (Catalina), and show that a one-to-one mapping between continuum color and the presence of water ice cannot be supported. We also discuss possible causes for the large outburst, and find that there is an apparent grouping in the kinetic energy per mass estimates for the outbursts of 5 comets.
Introduction
Water ice is a fundamental building block of the outer solar system, but studying it in comets is notoriously difficult. By the time a comet gets close enough to the Sun for observation, its surface ice has usually sublimated, leaving behind a crust of dry dust. However, comets occasionally undergo outbursts—explosive mass-loss events triggered by cliff collapses, internal pressure, or ice phase changes. These outbursts act like natural excavation events, violently ejecting pristine, subsurface material into space. This study investigates a massive outburst from Comet 243P/NEAT in December 2018 to see if we can directly observe and characterize cometary water ice, and to better understand the physical mechanisms that drive these explosive events.
Methodology and Data Synthesis
To dissect the comet's behavior, the researchers combined observational astronomy with physical modeling. Long-term monitoring was provided by sky surveys including the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF), ATLAS, and the Catalina Sky Survey (CSS). Targeted follow-up was conducted using the Las Cumbres Observatory (LCOGT), TRAPPIST, and the Lowell Discovery Telescope (LDT). Four days after the peak of the outburst, near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy was obtained using the IRTF/SpeX instrument to search for water ice absorption bands at 1.5 and 2.0 $\mu$m. These observations were supported by 3D dust dynamical modeling and ice sublimation calculations to reverse-engineer the outburst physics.
The 2018 Outburst and Lightcurve Analysis
The comet's activity was characterized by a 251-day lightcurve, which revealed a massive $-3$ magnitude spike in December 2018. This event ejected approximately $3 \times 10^7$ kg of dust, equivalent to a 24-meter radius boulder. Interestingly, the lightcurve also suggests the occurrence of smaller, tentative outbursts in September 2018, as indicated by deviations from the quiescent model.
The "Missing Ice" and the Fallacy of Color
Despite the outburst excavating material from depths where water ice must exist, no ice was detected in the NIR spectrum (upper limit <3% absorption depth). Dynamical models suggest that small, pure ice grains were ejected too rapidly to be captured in the observation slit, while larger grains contaminated with even 0.5% dark dust would sublimate within hours at the comet's heliocentric distance.
Furthermore, the comet's optical color remained red throughout the event. In cometary science, it is often assumed that "bluer" colors indicate water ice. However, this study challenges that assumption. By comparing 243P/NEAT's data with archival observations of Comet 103P/Hartley 2, the authors demonstrated that scattering properties of dust can mask the color signature of ice, as highly icy regions can appear just as red as ice-free ones.
Discussion and Energetics
The kinetic energy of the 243P/NEAT outburst was calculated at $\sim 76$ J/kg. Comparing this to other comets, the authors identified a potential grouping of outbursts into "low energy" ($\sim 10^1 - 10^2$ J/kg) and "high energy" ($\sim 10^4 - 10^5$ J/kg) categories. This grouping may depend on the abundance of trapped super-volatile gases (like CO or CO$_2$) released during the crystallization of amorphous water ice.
Conclusions
The study of Comet 243P/NEAT highlights the rapid sublimation of "dirty" ice grains and cautions against using optical color as a definitive proxy for water ice. Future investigations of cometary outbursts require rapid-response spectroscopy within hours of detection to capture transient ice signatures before they vanish.
Summary updated