Spectral evolution of dark asteroid surfaces induced by space weathering over a decade

Sunao Hasegawa, F. E. DeMeo, Michaël Marsset, J. Hanuš, Chrysa Avdellidou, Marco Delbó, S. J. Bus, H. Hanayama, Takashi Horiuchi, D. Takir, Emmanuël Jehin, Marin Ferrais, Jooyeon Geem, Myungshin Im, Jinguk Seo, Yoonsoo P. Bach, Sunho Jin, Masateru Ishiguro, D. Kuroda, Richard P. Binzel, A. Nakamura, Bin Yang, Pierre VernazzaarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The surface of airless bodies like asteroids in the Solar System are known to be affected by space weathering. Experiments simulating space weathering are essential for studying the effects of this process on meteorite samples, but the problem is that the time spent to reproduce space weathering in these experiments is billions of times shorter than the actual phenomenon. In December 2010, the T-type asteroid 596 Scheila underwent a collision with a few-tens-of-meters impactor. A decade later, there is an opportunity to study how the surface layer of this asteroid is being altered by space weathering after the impact. To do so, we performed visible spectrophotometric and near-infrared spectroscopic observations of 596 Scheila. The acquired spectrum is consistent with those observed shortly after the 2010 impact event within the observational uncertainty range. This indicates that the surface color of dark asteroids is not noticeably changed by space weathering over a 10-year period. This study is the first to investigate color changes due to space weathering on an actual asteroid surface in the Solar System. Considering that fresh layers are regularly created on asteroid surfaces by collisions, we suggest a genetic link between D/T-type and dark (low albedo) X-complex asteroids and very red objects such as 269 Justitia, 732 Tjilaki (and 203 Pompeja). New observations show that 203 Pompeja has a X-type-like surface, with some local surface areas exhibiting a very red spectrum.

Introduction

Airless bodies in our solar system are constantly bombarded by solar wind and micrometeoroids—a process called space weathering. This process alters the surface chemistry and, consequently, the color (reflectance spectrum) of asteroids over millions of years. While laboratory experiments can simulate these effects, they do so at rates billions of times faster than natural processes, leaving a gap in our understanding of real-time weathering rates.

A unique opportunity arose in December 2010 when the dark, T-type asteroid 596 Scheila was struck by a smaller object. This impact effectively "resurfaced" the asteroid, exposing fresh material. By observing Scheila a decade later, researchers can treat this event as a natural experiment to measure the rate of surface evolution in the actual space environment.

Methods and Observations

To investigate the 10-year evolution of Scheila's surface, the research team performed visible spectrophotometry and near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy. New data were captured in 2022 using the SpeX spectrograph on NASA’s Infrared Telescope Facility (IRTF) and the Murikabushi Telescope in Japan.

These new observations were compared against historical datasets, including pre-impact spectra from 2002 and post-impact data from 2011. The team also analyzed other "Very Red Objects" (VROs), such as 269 Justitia and 203 Pompeja, to explore potential genetic links between these rare objects and common dark asteroids.

Results: A Decade of Spectral Stability

The primary finding of this study is that 596 Scheila’s spectrum in 2022 is virtually identical to its spectrum recorded in 2011, shortly after the impact. Within the margins of observational uncertainty, no significant reddening or spectral change occurred over the ten-year period.

Figure 1: Normalized reflectance spectra of 596 Scheila at different epochs, showing the stability of the surface color a decade after the 2010 impact event.

The NIR spectral slope of 596 Scheila was measured at 42.2% $\mu m^{-1}$ in 2022, which aligns closely with the 40.5–46.7% $\mu m^{-1}$ range observed in 2011. This consistency suggests that space weathering on dark asteroids is a much slower process than on S-type (stony) asteroids, where weathering often follows a rapid, logarithmic initial phase.

Modeling the Weathering Rate

To quantify the rate of change, the researchers modeled the spectral slope evolution using both linear and logarithmic functions. The data points collected over the decade favor a slow, linear evolution model over a logarithmic one. A logarithmic model would have predicted a significantly bluer slope than what was actually measured in 2022.

Figure 2: Spectral slope of 596 Scheila versus space weathering time. The data points (black circles) are better represented by a linear evolution model (blue line) than a logarithmic one (orange line).

Based on these findings, the team estimated a linear weathering rate of approximately 0.0018% $\mu m^{-1} yr^{-1}$ for this class of dark asteroid.

Discussion and Future Work

The study proposes a "genetic link" between common dark asteroids and the mysterious "Very Red Objects" (VROs) found in the outer main belt. It is hypothesized that freshly exposed layers on dark asteroids might initially resemble VROs, transitioning over vast timescales into more common types. Observations of 203 Pompeja further support this, showing occasional red spectra that may indicate fresh impact craters.

While a decade is brief in geological terms, these findings constrain weathering models. The authors emphasize the need for continued monitoring of Scheila and other recently impacted bodies over 50–100 years to truly pin down the long-term weathering curve.

Summary updated

Abstract

The surface of airless bodies like asteroids in the Solar System are known to be affected by space weathering. Experiments simulating space weathering are essential for studying the effects of this process on meteorite samples, but the problem is that the time spent to reproduce space weathering in these experiments is billions of times shorter than the actual phenomenon. In December 2010, the T-type asteroid 596 Scheila underwent a collision with a few-tens-of-meters impactor. A decade later, there is an opportunity to study how the surface layer of this asteroid is being altered by space weathering after the impact. To do so, we performed visible spectrophotometric and near-infrared spectroscopic observations of 596 Scheila. The acquired spectrum is consistent with those observed shortly after the 2010 impact event within the observational uncertainty range. This indicates that the surface color of dark asteroids is not noticeably changed by space weathering over a 10-year period. This study is the first to investigate color changes due to space weathering on an actual asteroid surface in the Solar System. Considering that fresh layers are regularly created on asteroid surfaces by collisions, we suggest a genetic link between D/T-type and dark (low albedo) X-complex asteroids and very red objects such as 269 Justitia, 732 Tjilaki (and 203 Pompeja). New observations show that 203 Pompeja has a X-type-like surface, with some local surface areas exhibiting a very red spectrum.
BibTeX
@misc{hasegawa2022spectral,
  author = {Sunao Hasegawa and F. E. DeMeo and Michaël Marsset and J. Hanuš and Chrysa Avdellidou and Marco Delbó and S. J. Bus and H. Hanayama and Takashi Horiuchi and D. Takir and Emmanuël Jehin and Marin Ferrais and Jooyeon Geem and Myungshin Im and Jinguk Seo and Yoonsoo P. Bach and Sunho Jin and Masateru Ishiguro and D. Kuroda and Richard P. Binzel and A. Nakamura and Bin Yang and Pierre Vernazza},
  title = {{Spectral evolution of dark asteroid surfaces induced by space weathering over a decade}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2209.09415},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2209.09415},
}
Figure