A Distributionally Robust Model Predictive Control for Static and Dynamic Uncertainties in Smart Grids

Qi Li, Ye Shi, Yuning Jiang, Yuanming Shi, Haoyu Wang, H. Vincent Poor

Introduction

The integration of renewable energy sources (RESs) and electric vehicles (EVs) is a cornerstone of the modern sustainable smart grid. However, these technologies introduce significant stochasticity that challenges grid stability. Traditional control methods often struggle to balance operational costs with reliability when faced with "messy" or incomplete data. This paper presents a novel Wasserstein-based Distributionally Robust Model Predictive Control (WDR-MPC) framework designed to manage both static and dynamic uncertainties while maintaining computational efficiency.

The Challenge of Uncertainty in Smart Grids

Grid operators must contend with two distinct categories of uncertainty:

  1. Static Uncertainties: These are instantaneous errors in forecasting, such as the immediate power output of a solar array or wind turbine.
  2. Dynamic Uncertainties: These errors propagate through time. A primary example is the charging pattern of an EV; an unpredictable charging event doesn't just impact the current load but alters the battery's State of Charge (SoC), thereby influencing all future control decisions.

Existing stochastic methods often assume a known probability distribution (e.g., a Gaussian distribution) for these errors. In practice, the true distribution is rarely known, and ignoring the "memory" inherent in battery systems can lead to conservative operations or, worse, grid failure.

Methodology: The WDR-MPC Framework

The proposed WDR-MPC approach addresses these challenges through a two-stage optimization process that leverages Wasserstein ambiguity sets.

Wasserstein Ambiguity Sets

Rather than assuming a single fixed probability distribution, the model constructs a "ball" of all possible distributions that are close to historical data, as measured by the Wasserstein metric. This ensures the system remains robust against "out-of-sample" scenarios where real-world data deviates from historical patterns.

Two-Stage Optimization and Ambiguity Tubes

  • Stage 1 (Robustness): The model establishes "ambiguity tubes." These are mathematical bounds that define the worst-case evolution of dynamic errors over a given time horizon. By decoupling these uncertainties from the primary control logic, the system ensures that constraints—such as voltage limits—are never violated.
  • Stage 2 (Optimization): The stochastic problem is reformulated into a "nominal" convex form. This simplified version is pre-hardened against uncertainty, allowing for rapid solving without the computational overhead typically associated with robust optimization.

Computational Acceleration

A significant technical contribution of this work is a reformulation method that prevents the number of constraints from growing linearly with the number of data samples. This convex acceleration allows the WDR-MPC to remain scalable for large-scale power systems, a common bottleneck in distributionally robust frameworks.

Experimental Validation

The researchers validated the WDR-MPC framework using the IEEE 38-bus and IEEE 94-bus systems. To ensure realistic testing, the simulations incorporated:

  • Actual solar power generation data.
  • New York electricity demand records from June 2019.
  • Market pricing data from Finland (June 2022).

Key Results

  • Reliability: In out-of-sample testing, the WDR-MPC achieved nearly 100% reliability, significantly outperforming standard MPC and Sample Average Approximation (SAA) methods, which often failed to maintain constraints under high uncertainty.
  • Speed: The acceleration technique proved vital. On the 38-bus system with 100 samples, the accelerated WDR-MPC solved in approximately 2,660 seconds. In contrast, the standard WDR-MPC formulation failed to converge even after 50,000 seconds.
  • Cost Efficiency: By being distributionally robust rather than purely robust (which assumes the absolute worst-case), the system avoided overly conservative settings, leading to lower operational costs as more data samples were integrated.

Conclusion and Future Work

The WDR-MPC framework provides a scalable, reliable solution for managing the complex uncertainties of modern smart grids. While the current model assumes a centralized controller for radial distribution networks, future research will explore distributed scenarios for local coordination and the integration of advanced machine learning predictors to further refine forecasting accuracy within the WDR framework.

Summary updated

Abstract

The integration of various power sources, including renewables and electric vehicles, into smart grids is expanding, introducing uncertainties that can result in issues like voltage imbalances, load fluctuations, and power losses. These challenges negatively impact the reliability and stability of online scheduling in smart grids. Existing research often addresses uncertainties affecting current states but overlooks those that impact future states, such as the unpredictable charging patterns of electric vehicles. To distinguish between these, we term them static uncertainties and dynamic uncertainties, respectively. This paper introduces WDR-MPC, a novel approach that stands for two-stage Wasserstein-based Distributionally Robust (WDR) optimization within a Model Predictive Control (MPC) framework, aimed at effectively managing both types of uncertainties in smart grids. The dynamic uncertainties are first reformulated into ambiguity tubes and then the distributionally robust bounds of both dynamic and static uncertainties can be established using WDR optimization. By employing ambiguity tubes and WDR optimization, the stochastic MPC system is converted into a nominal one. Moreover, we develop a convex reformulation method to speed up WDR computation during the two-stage optimization. The distinctive contribution of this paper lies in its holistic approach to both static and dynamic uncertainties in smart grids. Comprehensive experiment results on IEEE 38-bus and 94-bus systems reveal the method’s superior performance and the potential to enhance grid stability and reliability.
BibTeX
@article{li2024distributionally,
  author = {Qi Li and Ye Shi and Yuning Jiang and Yuanming Shi and Haoyu Wang and H. Vincent Poor},
  title = {{A Distributionally Robust Model Predictive Control for Static and Dynamic Uncertainties in Smart Grids}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Smart Grid},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=9cj877GQen},
}
Figure