A Constant-Factor Approximation for Generalized Malleable Scheduling under M♮-Concave Processing Speeds

Dimitris Fotakis, Jannik Matuschke, Orestis Papadigenopoulos

TL;DR

This paper presents a constant-factor approximation algorithm for a generalized job scheduling problem where jobs can be split across multiple machines, and their processing speed depends on the machines used in a complex way ($M^\natural$-concave functions). This significantly broadens the types of processing speed functions for which efficient scheduling is possible. The authors also show how this scheduling problem can be used to tackle fair resource allocation problems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the problem of Generalized Malleable Scheduling. In this scenario, we have a set of jobs that can be processed in parallel on multiple machines. Crucially, a job can be assigned to a subset of machines, and its processing time is determined by the joint processing speed of those machines. This is more flexible than traditional models where a job is assigned to a single machine or a fixed number of identical machines.

The core challenge is that the processing speed functions can be quite complex. Specifically, they are job-dependent $M^\natural$-concave functions. This means the speed at which a job runs depends not only on the set of machines it's assigned to but also on the specific job itself, and the way this speed changes with the addition or removal of machines follows a particular mathematical property ($M^\natural$-concavity, also known as gross substitutability). This property is important because it captures realistic scenarios where adding more machines doesn't always proportionally speed up a job, and there can be complex interactions between machines.

Previous work had achieved constant-factor approximations for simpler cases (like identical machines or specific types of speed functions), but extending this to the more general $M^\natural$-concave functions was an open problem. The paper aims to provide a constant-factor approximation algorithm for this more general and realistic setting.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of techniques from discrete convexity and linear programming (LP).

  1. Configuration LP Relaxation: They formulate a linear program (GS) that relaxes the assignment problem. This LP allows for fractional assignments of jobs to sets of machines. The dual of this LP (GS-D) provides crucial information about the "value" of machines for each job.
  2. Matroid Theory: They leverage the property that $M^\natural$-concave functions induce specific structures called matroids. This allows them to relate the dual LP solution to weighted matroids, which are well-understood combinatorial objects.
  3. LP Rounding: The fractional solutions from the LP are then "rounded" to obtain integer assignments. This involves several steps:
  4. Partitioning Jobs: Jobs are categorized into three groups based on their assignments in the LP solution (single-machine assignments, low-speed assignments, and high-speed assignments).
  5. Specialized Algorithms: Different rounding techniques are applied to each job group. For instance, they use algorithms for unrelated machine scheduling and a "WELFARE MAXIMIZATION" problem (which is solvable efficiently for $M^\natural$-concave functions).
  6. Polymatroid Intersection: For the most complex group of jobs, they reformulate the problem as an intersection of polymatroids, a structure that guarantees integral solutions can be found efficiently.
  7. Black-Box Reduction: A key conceptual contribution is a reduction from the malleable scheduling problem to the Max-Min Fair Allocation (MMFA) problem. This allows them to leverage their scheduling algorithm to obtain approximation algorithms for fair resource allocation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The problem is theoretical and focuses on algorithmic design rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • $M^\natural$-concavity is the key: The paper demonstrates that the $M^\natural$-concavity property of processing speed functions is crucial for achieving constant-factor approximations. This property, related to "gross substitutability" in economics, allows for powerful structural decompositions and algorithmic techniques.
  • LP relaxation as a powerful tool: The configuration LP and its dual provide a rich source of information that can be translated into assignments. The dual variables ($\lambda_j, \mu_i$) effectively represent the "value" or "cost" associated with jobs and machines, respectively.
  • Decomposition is essential: Breaking down the problem into three distinct job types (single-machine, low-speed, high-speed) simplifies the overall approach. Each subproblem can then be tackled with tailored algorithmic tools.
  • Matroids and Polymatroids as bridges: The connection between $M^\natural$-concave functions and matroids/polymatroids is a powerful insight. It allows the use of combinatorial optimization techniques to solve what initially appears to be a continuous optimization problem.
  • Scheduling as a tool for fairness: The reduction to Max-Min Fair Allocation is a significant conceptual leap. It shows that problems in seemingly different domains can be related and that solutions from one can inform the other.

Key Results

  • Constant-Factor Approximation: The paper presents a polynomial-time algorithm that provides a constant-factor approximation for generalized malleable scheduling with $M^\natural$-concave processing speeds. The approximation ratio is stated as 193 in Theorem 9, though the authors note they did not focus on optimizing the constant.
  • Connection to Fair Allocation: A black-box reduction is provided that transforms an $\alpha$-approximation algorithm for malleable scheduling into an $\alpha$-augmented $\alpha$-approximation algorithm for the Max-Min Fair Allocation problem.
  • Specific Results for MMFA: This reduction leads to a 2-augmented 2-approximation for SANTA CLAUS (a specific MMFA instance) and a $O(1)$-augmented $O(1)$-approximation for MMFA with $M^\natural$-concave utilities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximation Constant: The authors explicitly state they did not focus on optimizing the constant in the approximation ratio. Achieving a small, single-digit constant is mentioned as an interesting direction for future research, likely requiring new insights.
  • Submodular vs. $M^\natural$-concave: The current algorithm heavily relies on the structural properties of $M^\natural$-concavity. The paper notes that the techniques used (like approximations via weighted matroids and elimination of low-speed assignments) are specific to $M^\natural$-concavity and not directly applicable to the more general submodular processing speed functions, for which only a logarithmic approximation is known. Overcoming this gap is a key future research direction.
  • Inapproximability for XOS: The paper references a strong inapproximability result for the even more general "XOS functions" in scheduling, highlighting the difficulty of achieving constant-factor approximations in the broadest settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

In generalized malleable scheduling, jobs can be allocated and processed simultaneously on multiple machines so as to reduce the overall makespan of the schedule. The required processing time for each job is determined by the joint processing speed of the allocated machines. We study the case that processing speeds are job-dependent $M^\natural$-concave functions and provide a constant-factor approximation for this setting, significantly expanding the realm of functions for which such an approximation is possible. Further, we explore the connection between malleable scheduling and the problem of fairly allocating items to a set of agents with distinct utility functions, devising a black-box reduction that allows to obtain resource-augmented approximation algorithms for the latter.
BibTeX
@article{fotakis2022constant,
  author = {Dimitris Fotakis and Jannik Matuschke and Orestis Papadigenopoulos},
  title = {{A Constant-Factor Approximation for Generalized Malleable Scheduling under M♮-Concave Processing Speeds}},
  journal = {Math. Program.},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s10107-023-02054-z},
}
Figure