Generalized Malleable Scheduling under $M^\natural$-Concave Processing Speeds

Dimitris Fotakis, Jannik Matuschke, Orestis Papadigenopoulos

TL;DR

This paper tackles the complex problem of scheduling jobs that can be split across multiple machines to minimize overall completion time (makespan). The authors introduce a novel constant-factor approximation algorithm for a generalized version of this problem where machine speeds are not uniform and depend on the specific job and the combination of machines used. This work significantly expands the types of processing speed functions for which efficient scheduling is possible and also offers a new approach to fair resource allocation problems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The core problem is Generalized Malleable Scheduling. Imagine you have a set of tasks (jobs) that can be broken down and run in parallel on a pool of machines. The catch is that the time it takes to complete a job depends not just on how many machines are assigned to it, but which specific machines are assigned and how their "speeds" combine for that particular job. This is a more realistic scenario than simpler models where machines are identical or their speeds combine in a straightforward way. The goal is to assign jobs to machines and decide when they start to finish all jobs as quickly as possible (minimize the makespan).

Previous work had achieved constant-factor approximations for simpler versions of this problem, but the authors here tackle a more general and challenging case: job-dependent $M^\natural$-concave processing speed functions. This class of functions captures complex interactions between machines that are not easily modeled by simpler functions. Finding efficient algorithms for such complex speed functions is crucial for real-world applications in high-performance computing, logistics, and more.

Methods

The authors develop a constant-factor approximation algorithm for the generalized malleable scheduling problem. Their approach is multi-faceted and relies heavily on techniques from discrete convexity and linear programming (LP).

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Configuration LP Relaxation: They formulate a linear program that relaxes the original scheduling problem. The optimal solutions to this LP provide crucial information about job assignments and machine "weights."
  • Matroid Theory: They leverage the properties of matroids to model and approximate the complex processing speed functions. Specifically, they show that the sets of machines that maximize a job's processing speed form a structure related to matroids, which allows for efficient algorithmic manipulation.
  • LP Rounding and Decomposition: The algorithm decomposes the problem into three stages, each handling a different type of job based on the LP solution. They employ sophisticated LP rounding techniques (e.g., from Lenstra et al. for unrelated machines) and algorithms for specific problems like the "WELFARE" problem to assign jobs.
  • Black-Box Reduction to Fair Allocation: A significant theoretical contribution is a reduction from the generalized malleable scheduling problem to the Max-Min Fair Allocation (MMFA) problem. This allows them to leverage their scheduling algorithm to design resource-augmented approximation algorithms for fair resource allocation, where some items might be shared or split among agents.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical algorithm design and analysis, not on empirical evaluation with specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • $M^\natural$-concavity is Key: The paper demonstrates that $M^\natural$-concave functions, a class of functions exhibiting "gross substitutability," are amenable to constant-factor approximation for generalized malleable scheduling. This significantly broadens the scope of problems solvable with such guarantees.
  • Matroids as a Powerful Abstraction: The connection between the optimal machine sets for maximizing processing speed and matroids is a crucial insight. This allows the authors to leverage well-established matroid algorithms and properties to handle the complexity of the speed functions.
  • Decomposition for Tractability: Breaking down the problem into three distinct job types based on the LP solution is a clever strategy. It allows them to apply specialized algorithms to each subproblem, ultimately combining them for a global solution.
  • Scheduling as a Tool for Fair Allocation: The reduction to MMFA is a powerful theoretical result. It shows how problems in one domain can inspire solutions in another, suggesting that the techniques developed for scheduling might have broader implications for fair resource distribution.

Key Results

  • Constant-Factor Approximation: The paper presents a polynomial-time algorithm that provides a constant-factor approximation for generalized malleable scheduling with $M^\natural$-concave processing speeds. The approximation ratio is stated as 193 in Theorem 9, though the authors mention that optimizing this constant is a future research direction.
  • Connection to MMFA: A black-box reduction is established, showing that an $\alpha$-approximation algorithm for generalized malleable scheduling implies an $[\alpha]$-augmented $\alpha$-approximation algorithm for MMFA.
  • Specific Corollaries:
    • A 2-augmented 2-approximation for the SANTA CLAUS problem (a special case of MMFA with linear utilities).
  • A $O(1)$-augmentation $O(1)$-approximation algorithm for MMFA with $M^\natural$-concave utilities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximation Ratio: The authors acknowledge that the constant in their approximation ratio (193) is not optimized and significant further research would be needed to achieve a smaller, single-digit constant.
  • Submodular Functions: An open question is whether a constant-factor approximation exists for the broader class of submodular processing speed functions, for which only a logarithmic approximation is currently known. The techniques used for $M^\natural$-concave functions (like the matroid-based approximation and elimination of low-speed assignments) rely on properties not present in all submodular functions, suggesting that overcoming these issues is a key direction for future research.
  • Practical Implementation: While the algorithms are theoretically sound, their practical implementation and performance on real-world instances would be an interesting area to explore.

Summary updated

Abstract

In generalized malleable scheduling, jobs can be allocated and processed simultaneously on multiple machines so as to reduce the overall makespan of the schedule. The required processing time for each job is determined by the joint processing speed of the allocated machines. We study the case that processing speeds are job-dependent $M^\natural$-concave functions and provide a constant-factor approximation for this setting, significantly expanding the realm of functions for which such an approximation is possible. Further, we explore the connection between malleable scheduling and the problem of fairly allocating items to a set of agents with distinct utility functions, devising a black-box reduction that allows to obtain resource-augmented approximation algorithms for the latter.
BibTeX
@article{fotakis2022generalized,
  author = {Dimitris Fotakis and Jannik Matuschke and Orestis Papadigenopoulos},
  title = {{Generalized Malleable Scheduling under $M^\textbackslash\{\}natural$-Concave Processing Speeds}},
  journal = {Math. Program.},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s10107-023-02054-z},
}
Figure