A 13-Billion-Year View of Galaxy Growth: Metallicity Gradient Evolution from the Local Universe to $z=9$ with JWST and Archival Surveys

Zihao Li, Zheng Cai, Xin Wang, Zhaozhou Li, Avishai Dekel, Kartick C. Sarkar, Eduardo Bañados, Fuyan Bian, Aklant K. Bhowmick, Laura Blecha, Sarah E. I. Bosman, Jaclyn B. Champagne, Xiaohui Fan, Emmet Golden-Marx, Hyunsung D. Jun, Mingyu Li, Xiaojing Lin, Weizhe Liu, Fengwu Sun, Maxime Trebitsch, Fabian Walter, Feige Wang, Yunjing Wu, Jinyi Yang, Huanian Zhang, Shiwu Zhang, Ming-Yang Zhuang, Siwei Zou

Abstract

The galaxy gas-phase metallicity gradients have been extensively studied over the past four decades, both in the local and high-redshift universe, as they trace the baryon cycle and growth of galaxies. With the unprecedented spatial resolution and sensitivity of JWST, it is now possible to measure metallicity and its radial gradients out to redshifts as high as $z = 9$. Here, we present a sample of 455 spectroscopically confirmed galaxies from redshifts $1.7 \lesssim z \lesssim 9$ that are spatially resolved on sub-kiloparsec (kpc) scales by deep JWST NIRCam or NIRISS Wide Field Slitless Spectroscopy (WFSS). Synthesizing these new JWST observations with legacy observations from the literature, we observe that at redshift $z > 5$, galaxy centers are more metal-rich, exhibiting negative metallicity gradients of $\sim-0.4$ dex kpc$^{-1}$. These gradients flatten over time, reaching near-zero around $z \approx 2$, coinciding with the peak of the cosmic star formation rate. Beyond this point, the gradients become negative again at lower redshifts approaching $z=0$. This evolution likely reflects transitions in galaxy formation modes: an inside-out growth phase dominated by intense central star formation with inefficient feedback and limited gas mixing during "cosmic dawn", enhanced gas mixing due to feedback-driven wind and gas accretion at "cosmic noon", and a later phase of slow evolution and reduced feedback toward the present day. These physical processes, including gas accretion and feedback, not only regulate star and galaxy formation on a cosmic scale but also shape the evolutionary pathways of individual galaxies over cosmic time.

Introduction

In astronomy, "metallicity" refers to the abundance of elements heavier than hydrogen and helium. These elements are forged in stars and redistributed by galactic winds and gas inflows. By measuring the metallicity gradient—the change in chemical composition from a galaxy's core to its outskirts—astronomers can reconstruct a galaxy’s "baryon cycle." Until recently, we lacked the resolution to see these gradients in the very early universe. This study addresses how the internal structure and chemical distribution of galaxies evolved from the first stars to the settled disks observed today.

Methodology and Datasets

The study utilized the unprecedented spatial resolution of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) to resolve galaxies on sub-kiloparsec scales. The authors employed NIRCam and NIRISS Wide Field Slitless Spectroscopy (WFSS) to capture spectra across 455 galaxies. For the most distant, faint galaxies ($z > 5$), a median stacking technique was used to derive representative radial profiles. Metallicity was determined using empirical calibrations, specifically the "R3" ratio of [O III]/H$\beta$, within a Bayesian inference framework to jointly constrain metallicity, dust extinction, and star formation rates.

The dataset integrates three major JWST programs:

  1. ASPIRE: A spectroscopic survey of biased halos in the Reionization Era.
  2. FRESCO: Deep NIRCam imaging and spectroscopy in the CANDELS fields.
  3. NGDEEP: The Next Generation Deep Extragalactic Exploratory Public Survey.

To complete the 13-billion-year timeline, these results were combined with archival data from the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) and ground-based adaptive optics surveys (VLT/SINFONI, Keck/OSIRIS) covering "Cosmic Noon" ($z \approx 2$) and the local universe ($z \approx 0$).

Results: The U-Shaped Evolution of Chemical Gradients

The synthesis of JWST and archival data reveals a dramatic "U-shaped" evolution of metallicity gradients across cosmic time. At the highest redshifts ($z > 5$), galaxies exhibit steep negative gradients, averaging approximately $-0.4$ dex kpc⁻¹. This indicates that early galaxy centers were significantly more enriched than their outskirts.

Spatially resolved emission line maps and radial metallicity profiles for galaxies at $z \approx 6$ (ASPIRE) and $z \approx 8$ (FRESCO), demonstrating steep negative gradients.

As the universe evolved toward "Cosmic Noon" ($z \approx 2$), these gradients flattened significantly, reaching near-zero. The flattening peaks at $z \approx 2.1$, coinciding with the peak of cosmic star formation. Following this epoch, as star formation activity declined, the gradients began to steepen again toward the present day ($z=0$).

Summary of measured metallicity gradients for the high-redshift JWST samples.

Discussion: Physical Drivers of Galactic Growth

This evolutionary trend reflects shifting modes of galaxy formation:

  • The "Inside-Out" Phase ($z > 5$): Steep negative gradients suggest centers are rapidly forming stars and self-enriching, while outskirts are fed by pristine, metal-poor gas from the intergalactic medium.
  • The Great Mixing ($z \approx 2$): The flattening of gradients suggests that intense feedback from supernovae and massive stars, combined with violent gas inflows, effectively "stirred the pot," mixing metals throughout the galaxy.
  • The Return to Order ($z < 2$): As the universe aged, galaxies transitioned from turbulent, feedback-dominated systems to more settled, secularly evolving disks, allowing gradients to steepen once more.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work provides a comprehensive 13-billion-year map of chemical evolution, aligning well with "bursty" feedback models like the FIRE simulations. Future research will focus on refining these measurements by accounting for spatial variations in dust attenuation and utilizing "direct method" temperature measurements (e.g., [O III]$\lambda$4363) to further calibrate chemical maps in the early universe.

Summary updated

Abstract

The galaxy gas-phase metallicity gradients have been extensively studied over the past four decades, both in the local and high-redshift universe, as they trace the baryon cycle and growth of galaxies. With the unprecedented spatial resolution and sensitivity of JWST, it is now possible to measure metallicity and its radial gradients out to redshifts as high as $z = 9$. Here, we present a sample of 455 spectroscopically confirmed galaxies from redshifts $1.7 \lesssim z \lesssim 9$ that are spatially resolved on sub-kiloparsec (kpc) scales by deep JWST NIRCam or NIRISS Wide Field Slitless Spectroscopy (WFSS). Synthesizing these new JWST observations with legacy observations from the literature, we observe that at redshift $z &gt; 5$, galaxy centers are more metal-rich, exhibiting negative metallicity gradients of $\sim-0.4$ dex kpc$^{-1}$. These gradients flatten over time, reaching near-zero around $z \approx 2$, coinciding with the peak of the cosmic star formation rate. Beyond this point, the gradients become negative again at lower redshifts approaching $z=0$. This evolution likely reflects transitions in galaxy formation modes: an inside-out growth phase dominated by intense central star formation with inefficient feedback and limited gas mixing during ``cosmic dawn", enhanced gas mixing due to feedback-driven wind and gas accretion at ``cosmic noon", and a later phase of slow evolution and reduced feedback toward the present day. These physical processes, including gas accretion and feedback, not only regulate star and galaxy formation on a cosmic scale but also shape the evolutionary pathways of individual galaxies over cosmic time.
BibTeX
@article{li2025billion,
  author = {Zihao Li and Zheng Cai and Xin Wang and Zhaozhou Li and Avishai Dekel and Kartick C. Sarkar and Eduardo Bañados and Fuyan Bian and Aklant K. Bhowmick and Laura Blecha and Sarah E. I. Bosman and Jaclyn B. Champagne and Xiaohui Fan and Emmet Golden-Marx and Hyunsung D. Jun and Mingyu Li and Xiaojing Lin and Weizhe Liu and Fengwu Sun and Maxime Trebitsch and Fabian Walter and Feige Wang and Yunjing Wu and Jinyi Yang and Huanian Zhang and Shiwu Zhang and Ming-Yang Zhuang and Siwei Zou},
  title = {{A 13-Billion-Year View of Galaxy Growth: Metallicity Gradient Evolution from the Local Universe to $z=9$ with JWST and Archival Surveys}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4365/adfa70},
}

Loading related content...

Figure