A 13 Billion Year View of Galaxy Growth: Metallicity Gradient Evolution from the Local Universe to z = 9 with JWST and Archival Surveys

Zihao Li, Zheng Cai, Xin Wang, Zhaozhou Li, Avishai Dekel, Kartick C. Sarkar, Eduardo Bañados, Fuyan Bian, Aklant K. Bhowmick, Laura Blecha, Sarah E. I. Bosman, Jaclyn B. Champagne, Xiaohui Fan, Emmet Golden-Marx, Hyunsung D. Jun, Mingyu Li, Xiaojing Lin, Weizhe Liu, Fengwu Sun, Maxime Trebitsch, Fabian Walter, Feige Wang, Yunjing Wu, Jinyi Yang, Huanian Zhang, Shiwu Zhang, Ming-Yang Zhuang, Siwei Zou

TL;DR

This paper uses the unprecedented power of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) to trace the evolution of metallicity gradients in galaxies from the early universe (z=9) to today. They find that metallicity gradients evolve significantly over cosmic time, flattening around the peak of star formation and becoming negative again in the local universe, offering crucial insights into galaxy formation modes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how galaxies grow and evolve is a fundamental question in astrophysics. A key tracer of this evolution is the "metallicity gradient" – how the abundance of heavy elements (metals) changes from the center of a galaxy to its outskirts. These gradients are thought to reflect the interplay of gas accretion, star formation, and feedback processes over cosmic time. However, previous studies were limited by the spatial resolution and sensitivity needed to measure these gradients accurately, especially in the early universe (high redshift). This paper aims to bridge this gap by using JWST's capabilities to measure metallicity gradients out to z=9, providing a comprehensive 13-billion-year view of galaxy growth.

Methods

The authors combine new JWST observations with archival data to create a large sample of galaxies. They use deep JWST NIRCam and NIRISS Wide Field Slitless Spectroscopy (WFSS) to obtain spatially resolved spectra. Key techniques include:

  • Spectroscopic analysis: Measuring emission line fluxes to determine gas-phase metallicity.
  • Metallicity calibrations: Utilizing established strong-line diagnostics (like R3 and R2) to convert line ratios to metallicity, with careful consideration for potential biases at high redshift.
  • Stacking techniques: Combining multiple galaxy spectra and images to enhance signal-to-noise and probe regions with lower surface brightness, especially for high-redshift galaxies.
  • Radial profile analysis: Measuring metallicity as a function of radius (in both kpc and effective radius units) to derive metallicity gradients.
  • SED fitting: Using spectral energy distribution fitting to estimate stellar masses and other physical properties.
  • Mock tests: Performing simulations to assess uncertainties and validate their measurement techniques.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from several JWST programs:

  • ASPIRE survey: "A Spectroscopic survey of biased halos In the Reionization Era."
  • FRESCO survey: "First Reionization Epoch Spectroscopically Complete Observations."
  • NGDEEP survey: "The Next Generation Deep Extragalactic Exploratory Public Survey."

These JWST datasets are complemented by:

  • Archival literature data: Including observations from HST and ground-based telescopes, covering a wide range of redshifts and methodologies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cosmic evolution of metallicity gradients: The most striking insight is the clear evolution of metallicity gradients over cosmic time, showing distinct phases: an initial steepening, a flattening, and a subsequent steepening. This suggests fundamental shifts in galaxy formation processes.
  • "Cosmic Dawn" (z > 5): Galaxies in this early epoch exhibit steep negative metallicity gradients, implying inefficient mixing and "inside-out" growth dominated by central star formation.
  • "Cosmic Noon" (z ~ 2): Around the peak of cosmic star formation, gradients flatten significantly. This is attributed to enhanced gas mixing driven by feedback and accretion.
  • Local Universe (z < 2): Gradients become negative again, suggesting a transition to more settled, secular evolution with reduced feedback.
  • Mass-Metallicity-Gradient Relation (MZGR): The relationship between stellar mass and metallicity gradient also evolves, indicating different feedback regimes at different cosmic epochs.

Key Results

  • Metallicity gradients at z > 5: Steep negative gradients of approximately -0.4 dex kpc⁻¹ are observed.
  • Metallicity gradients at z ~ 2: Gradients flatten to near-zero.
  • Metallicity gradients at z < 2: Gradients become negative again, approaching values seen in the local universe.
  • Sample size: The study analyzes a sample of 455 spectroscopically confirmed galaxies.
  • Spatial resolution: JWST enables sub-kiloparsec resolution, crucial for resolving these gradients.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Metallicity calibration uncertainties: While the authors tested different calibrations, some residual uncertainty remains, particularly for high-redshift galaxies.
  • Dust attenuation: Correcting for dust is challenging, especially at high redshifts, introducing uncertainties in SFR and metallicity measurements.
  • AGN contamination: While efforts were made to exclude AGN-dominated sources, the possibility of residual contamination, especially at high redshift, is acknowledged.
  • Simulation comparisons: While simulations provide valuable context, degeneracies in feedback prescriptions and other physical processes make direct comparisons challenging.

Future work could involve:

  • Expanding the sample size and redshift coverage.
  • Improving dust correction techniques.
  • More detailed comparisons with advanced cosmological simulations that better capture the complex interplay of feedback, accretion, and gas mixing.
  • Investigating the role of galaxy morphology and environment on metallicity gradient evolution.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Galaxy gas-phase metallicity gradients have been extensively studied over the past four decades, both in the local and in the high-redshift Universe, as they trace the baryon cycle and growth of galaxies. With the unprecedented spatial resolution and sensitivity of JWST, it is now possible to measure metallicity and its radial gradients out to redshifts as high as z = 9. Here, we present a sample of 455 spectroscopically confirmed galaxies from redshifts 1.7 ≲ z ≲ 9 that are spatially resolved on subkiloparsec scales by deep JWST NIRCam or NIRISS Wide Field Slitless Spectroscopy. Synthesizing these new JWST observations with legacy observations from the literature, we observe that at redshift z &gt; 5, galaxy centers are more metal rich, exhibiting negative metallicity gradients of ∼−0.4 dex kpc −1 . These gradients flatten over time, reaching near zero around z ≈ 2, coinciding with the peak of the cosmic star formation rate. Beyond this point, the gradients become negative again at lower redshifts approaching z = 0. This evolution likely reflects transitions in galaxy formation modes: an inside-out growth phase dominated by intense central star formation with inefficient feedback and limited gas mixing during “cosmic dawn,” enhanced gas mixing due to feedback-driven wind and gas accretion at “cosmic noon,” and a later phase of slow evolution and reduced feedback toward the present day. These physical processes, including gas accretion and feedback, not only regulate star and galaxy formation on a cosmic scale but also shape the evolutionary pathways of individual galaxies over cosmic time.
BibTeX
@article{li2025billion,
  author = {Zihao Li and Zheng Cai and Xin Wang and Zhaozhou Li and Avishai Dekel and Kartick C. Sarkar and Eduardo Bañados and Fuyan Bian and Aklant K. Bhowmick and Laura Blecha and Sarah E. I. Bosman and Jaclyn B. Champagne and Xiaohui Fan and Emmet Golden-Marx and Hyunsung D. Jun and Mingyu Li and Xiaojing Lin and Weizhe Liu and Fengwu Sun and Maxime Trebitsch and Fabian Walter and Feige Wang and Yunjing Wu and Jinyi Yang and Huanian Zhang and Shiwu Zhang and Ming-Yang Zhuang and Siwei Zou},
  title = {{A 13 Billion Year View of Galaxy Growth: Metallicity Gradient Evolution from the Local Universe to <i>z</i> = 9 with JWST and Archival Surveys}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4365/adfa70},
}

Loading related content...

Figure