Dagstuhl Manifestos 2018

4 papers
The 2018 edition of Dagstuhl Manifestos comprised six publications that outlined strategic research directions across several core areas of computer science. A primary focus was the principles of data management, with contributions from authors such as Dan Suciu, Diego Calvanese, and Leonid Libkin. These works examined the theoretical foundations and future challenges of managing complex data systems in an increasingly data-driven landscape. Additional research themes included the application of tensor computing to the Internet of Things (IoT) and the development of formal argumentation within artificial intelligence. Another notable trend involved shifting the focus of information retrieval, natural language processing, and recommender systems toward predictive science. This transition aims to move beyond retrospective evaluation to forecasting system performance. Together, these manifestos reflect a broader effort to establish rigorous frameworks for emerging technologies and to improve the predictive accuracy of information-driven disciplines.

Top Research Directions

The 10 research directions with Dagstuhl Manifestos 2018 papers, ranked by paper count, next to 2014. Share is the fraction of the edition’s papers in the direction.

#Direction20182014Share 2018Share 20142014 rank
1Bridging the Offline to Online Evaluation Gap1025.0%0.0%—
2Descriptive Modeling of Human Argumentation and Belief Revision1025.0%0.0%—
3Modeling the Evolution of Argumentative Disputes1025.0%0.0%—
4Probabilistic Query Evaluation and Data Management1025.0%0.0%—
5Reducing Complex Reasoning Problems to Propositional Satisfiability1025.0%0.0%—
6Scaling Data Systems for Volume and Structural Complexity1025.0%0.0%—
7Subgroup Performance Masking in Machine Learning Evaluation1025.0%0.0%—
8The Expanding Boundaries of Modern Data Management1025.0%0.0%—
9Translating Natural Language to Formal Logic1025.0%0.0%—
10Unified Index Notation for Tensor Computations1025.0%0.0%—

Download all directions as CSV

Institutions

Institutions credited by Dagstuhl Manifestos 2018 papers: a paper credits every institution named in its affiliations, once. 22 institutions share 2 credited papers.

#InstitutionPapersShare20142014 rank
100k4h2615 150.0%0—
2Drexel University 150.0%0—
3Hong Kong University of Science and Technology 150.0%0—
4IBM Research - Thomas J. Watson Research Center 150.0%0—
5Paderborn University 150.0%0—
6Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile 150.0%0—
7Siemens (Germany) 150.0%0—
8Technion – Israel Institute of Technology 150.0%0—
9Tel Aviv University 150.0%0—
10TU Dortmund University 150.0%0—
11TU Wien 150.0%0—
12University at Albany, State University of New York 150.0%0—
13University of Bayreuth 150.0%0—
14University of California San Diego 150.0%0—
15University of California, Irvine 150.0%0—
16University of California, Santa Barbara 150.0%0—
17University of Chile 150.0%0—
18University of Copenhagen 150.0%0—
19University of Edinburgh 150.0%0—
20University of Warsaw 150.0%0—
21University of Washington 150.0%0—
22Université de Montpellier 150.0%0—

Download all institutions as CSV

About this data

Papers. Dagstuhl Manifestos 2018 lists 4 papers on Lacuna, duplicate versions counted once; rejected and withdrawn submissions are left out.

Directions. Directions are Lacuna’s clustering of the concept elements extracted from each paper, so a paper can belong to several and direction counts add up to more than the paper count. A direction’s share is its papers divided by the edition’s papers. Comparisons with 2014 use shares, since the edition went from 1 to 4 papers.

Institutions. A paper credits each institution named in its affiliations, resolved to a ROR record, once. 2 of 4 papers (50.0%) credit at least one institution and are the base for institution shares; the rest have no resolved affiliation yet.

Data. Counts come from Lacuna’s data build of 2026-11-18 and change as papers are added. Tables as CSV: directions · institutions. Cite as: Lacuna, “Dagstuhl Manifestos 2018”, https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/venue/dagstuhl-manifestos/2018.

Top Authors

AuthorPapers
Beishui Liao1
Benny Kimelfeld1
Dan Suciu1
Elizabeth M. Daly1
Filip Murlak1
Julia Stoyanovich1
Marcelo Arenas1
Pablo Barcelo1
Volker Tresp1
Werner Geyer1

Impactful Papers

Papers from Dagstuhl Manifestos 2018 that shaped research clusters.

Influential

Papers

Title
From Evaluating to Forecasting Performance: How to Turn Information Retrieval, Natural Language Processing and Recommender Systems into Predictive Sciences (Dagstuhl Perspectives Workshop 17442)
Present and Future of Formal Argumentation (Dagstuhl Perspectives Workshop 15362)
Research Directions for Principles of Data Management (Dagstuhl Perspectives Workshop 16151)
Tensor Computing for Internet of Things (Dagstuhl Perspectives Workshop 16152)