Retraction Note: Multimodal interface interaction design model based on dynamic augmented reality

Fei Kong, Yu-Min WangMultimedia 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

Check for updates icon associated with the retraction notice.

Overview

In 2023, the journal Multimedia Tools and Applications issued a formal retraction for a 2019 article titled "Multimodal interface interaction design model based on dynamic augmented reality." This note serves as a critical update for the research community, signaling that the findings and models presented in the original work are no longer considered reliable and have been removed from the scientific record.

The Integrity Crisis in Guest-Edited Issues

The retraction stems from a broader investigation into the integrity of special guest-edited issues. These issues, while intended to highlight niche or emerging topics, have occasionally been exploited by "paper mills" or subjected to manipulated peer review processes.

Springer Nature logo.

In this specific case, the publisher, Springer Nature, found that the editorial handling of the article was compromised. The peer review reports that initially facilitated the paper's publication did not meet the journal's standards for scientific rigor. Furthermore, the content was deemed potentially out of scope for the journal, suggesting a failure in the initial screening and editorial oversight process.

Red Flags: Citation Manipulation and Lack of Accountability

A key factor in the retraction was the discovery of "inappropriate or irrelevant references." This is a common indicator of citation manipulation, where authors or editors include unrelated citations to artificially boost the bibliometric metrics of other papers or researchers, undermining the integrity of academic indexing.

Additionally, the investigation faced a significant hurdle: the inability to contact the authors, Fei Kong and Yumin Wang. The lack of valid contact information and the authors' failure to respond to the investigation are hallmarks of compromised research, further eroding confidence in the work's legitimacy.

Conclusion and Impact

The primary result of this notice is the formal invalidation of the 2019 study. The Editor-in-Chief has explicitly stated a total loss of confidence in the paper’s results and conclusions.

For researchers in the field of Augmented Reality (AR), the takeaway is definitive: any design models or multimodal interface frameworks derived from this 2019 paper should be discarded and not used as a foundation for future engineering or design projects. This case underscores the ongoing need for robust oversight in academic publishing, particularly regarding guest-edited supplements.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{kong2022retraction,
  author = {Fei Kong and Yu-Min Wang},
  title = {{Retraction Note: Multimodal interface interaction design model based on dynamic augmented reality}},
  booktitle = {Multimedia},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s11042-022-13996-5},
}
Figure