Report on 2105.09363v2

Po-Shen Hsin, Kevin SlagleOpenalex Unknown 2021 · DOI · arXiv · OpenAlex

Abstract

We investigate the properties of foliated gauge fields and construct several foliated field theories in 3+1d that describe foliated fracton orders both with and without matter, including recent hybrid fracton models. These field theories describe Abelian or non-Abelian gauge theories coupled to foliated gauge fields, falling into two classes: electric models and magnetic models. We demonstrate that these two classes enjoy a duality. Additionally, we construct a model for a subsystem-symmetry protected topological (SSPT) phase, analogous to a one-form symmetry protected topological phase, with the subsystem symmetry acting on codimension-two subregions. The corresponding gauged SSPT phase is constructed as a foliated two-form gauge theory, yielding variants of the X-cube model with identical ground state degeneracy and fusion but distinct particle statistics.

Introduction

Fracton phases of matter represent a significant departure from the standard paradigm of Topological Quantum Field Theory (TQFT). While TQFTs are generally insensitive to the underlying geometry of the manifold, fracton models exhibit "UV/IR mixing," where low-energy observables—such as the ground state degeneracy (GSD)—depend on the total number of lattice sites. This sensitivity to microscopic details is linked to the restricted mobility of excitations: fractons are immobile, lineons move only along 1D lines, and planons are restricted to 2D planes.

This paper provides a rigorous continuum field theory framework to describe these exotic phases using "foliated" gauge fields. By moving beyond standard TQFTs, the authors show how these fields can capture the unique geometric constraints of fracton orders, bridging the gap between discrete lattice models and smooth manifold descriptions.

The Foliated Field Theory Framework

The core innovation of this work is the development of Foliated Quantum Field Theory (FQFT). In this framework, gauge fields ($A^k, B^k$) are defined relative to a set of 1-forms ($e^k$) that specify the "foliation" (the layers or planes) of spacetime.

Unlike standard theories where fields must be smooth, FQFT allows for fields with delta-function singularities or discontinuities along the "leaves" of the foliation. This mathematical structure encodes the physical reality of fracton systems: the physics on one plane can be largely independent of the adjacent plane. The authors categorize these theories into two distinct but related classes:

  1. Electric Models: These consist of ordinary gauge theories coupled to foliated fields via specific symmetry twists.
  2. Magnetic Models: In these theories, the gauge field itself is intrinsically constrained by the foliation structure.

To ensure these continuum descriptions are physically grounded, the authors provide a correspondence to exactly solvable lattice Hamiltonian models (commuting projector models) that realize the same physics.

Duality and Subsystem Symmetries

A major theoretical contribution of the paper is the proof of an exact duality between electric and magnetic foliated theories. This duality suggests that many seemingly distinct fracton models are actually different mathematical representations of the same underlying physical phase. The authors provide explicit mappings for operators, such as Wilson lines and Wilson surfaces, across this duality.

Furthermore, the paper explores the concept of Subsystem-Symmetry Protected Topological (SSPT) phases. These are analogous to standard Symmetry Protected Topological (SPT) phases (like topological insulators) but are protected by symmetries that act only on sub-regions, specifically codimension-two subregions (lines in 3D). By gauging these subsystem symmetries, the authors construct new types of fracton topological orders.

Key Results: GSD and the X-cube Variant

The framework allows for the derivation of a general formula for the Ground State Degeneracy (GSD) of foliated two-form gauge theories on a 3-torus ($T^3$):

$$GSD = \prod_i q_i^{2r_i(L_x+L_y+L_z)-c_i}$$

This formula quantitatively captures the UV/IR mixing, demonstrating how the number of states grows exponentially with the linear size of the system ($L_x, L_y, L_z$).

One of the most striking applications of this theory is the construction of a variant of the well-known X-cube model. This new model possesses the same GSD and fusion rules as the original X-cube model but exhibits different braiding statistics. This result is crucial because it proves that "coarse" features like GSD are insufficient to uniquely identify a fracton phase, highlighting the need for the detailed statistical analysis provided by the foliated field theory.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the foliated gauge theory framework is powerful, it currently focuses on "Type-I" fracton orders—those with a clear planar or foliated structure. It does not yet directly apply to "Type-II" models, such as Haah’s Code, which lack such a structure. Additionally, the current work assumes flat foliations (where the 1-forms are closed, $de^k = 0$). Future research into curved foliations and the specific physics of gapless boundary modes will be essential to complete the continuum description of fracton matter.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the properties of foliated gauge fields and construct several foliated field theories in 3+1d that describe foliated fracton orders both with and without matter, including the recent hybrid fracton models. These field theories describe Abelian or non-Abelian gauge theories coupled to foliated gauge fields, and they fall into two classes of models that we call the electric models and the magnetic models. We show that these two classes of foliated field theories enjoy a duality. We also construct a model (using foliated gauge fields and an exactly solvable lattice Hamiltonian model) for a subsystem-symmetry protected topological (SSPT) phase, which is analogous to a one-form symmetry protected topological phase, with the subsystem symmetry acting on codimension-two subregions. We construct the corresponding gauged SSPT phase as a foliated two-form gauge theory. Some instances of the gauged SSPT phase are a variant of the X-cube model with the same ground state degeneracy and the same fusion, but different particle statistics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hsin2021report,
  author = {Po-Shen Hsin and Kevin Slagle},
  title = {{Report on 2105.09363v2}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21468/scipost.report.3175},
}
Figure