Report on 1812.01613v2

Kevin Slagle, David Aasen, Dominic J. WilliamsonOpenalex Unknown 2019 · DOI · arXiv · OpenAlex

Abstract

Foliated fracton order is a qualitatively new kind of phase of matter. It is similar to topological order, but with the fundamental difference that a layered structure, referred to as a foliation, plays an essential role and determines the mobility restrictions of the topological excitations. In this work, we introduce a new kind of field theory to describe these phases: a foliated field theory. We also introduce a new string-membrane-net condensation picture of these phases, which is analogous to the string-net condensation picture of topological order.

Introduction: Beyond Standard Topological Order

In condensed matter physics, "topological order"—exemplified by the Fractional Quantum Hall Effect—is typically described by Topological Field Theories (TQFTs). A defining characteristic of TQFTs is their independence from the underlying geometry; the physics remains invariant under smooth deformations of space.

However, the discovery of fracton order has challenged this paradigm. In these phases, excitations exhibit "subdimensional" mobility:

  • Fractons are immobile in isolation.
  • Lineons are restricted to 1D lines.
  • Planons are restricted to 2D planes.

Unlike standard topological phases, fracton physics depends explicitly on a geometric structure known as a foliation—a stack of 2D layers. This paper introduces a "foliated field theory" to bridge the gap between these exotic phases and the language of continuous field theory.

Visualizing foliations: (a) a standard cubic arrangement and (b) a more general non-orthogonal foliation structure.

Theoretical Framework: Foliated Field Theory

The authors construct a Lagrangian using differential forms that couples dynamical gauge fields to non-dynamical "foliation fields" ($e^k_\mu$). These fields effectively "count" the layers within the foliation. While General Relativity couples to a metric, this theory couples specifically to the layering structure of space.

This approach allows for the description of fracton phases on curved manifolds, extending beyond the simple cubic lattices of earlier models. The mobility constraints of particles emerge naturally from the requirement of gauge invariance within a theory that "sees" these layers.

The Hierarchy of Mobility

A key insight of the work is that the number of intersecting foliations ($n_f$) directly determines the mobility of the resulting excitations. As shown in the table below, increasing the number of foliations further restricts the movement of charges.

Relationship between the number of foliations ($n_f$), charge mobility types, and corresponding lattice models.

If a particle exists at the intersection of three layers ($n_f=3$), it becomes a fracton (0D). If it resides on the intersection of two layers, it is a lineon (1D), and on a single layer, it is a planon (2D).

String-Membrane-Net Condensation

The paper also generalizes the "string-net" condensation picture used for standard topological order. In the proposed string-membrane-net model, the vacuum is a superposition of 1D strings and 2D membranes. Specific "gluing" rules dictate that strings must reside on the boundaries of membranes, and strings within individual layers must form closed loops. This provides a unified physical mechanism for the emergence of restricted-mobility excitations.

Key Results and Equivalence

  • Continuous Description: The authors successfully derived a Lagrangian that serves as a continuous description for Type-I fracton phases.
  • Ground State Degeneracy (GSD): The theory reproduces the "subextensive" GSD—a hallmark of fractons where the number of ground states grows with system size. For a torus, the result matches known lattice calculations: $GSD = N^{2L_x + 2L_y + 2L_z - 3}$.
  • Model Mapping: Through local unitary circuits, the authors proved their model is physically equivalent to the X-cube model (for 3 foliations) and the anisotropic lineon model (for 2 foliations).

Limitations and Future Directions

While this framework provides a robust description of "foliated" (Type-I) fractons, several challenges remain:

  • Quantization: Properly quantizing a theory with an infinite continuum of layers involves mathematical subtleties regarding "large" gauge transformations.
  • Non-Abelian Extensions: The current work focuses on Abelian gauge groups ($Z_N$ or $U(1)$). Developing "foliated string-nets" for non-Abelian groups is a significant open problem.
  • Type-II Fractons: This framework does not yet encompass Type-II fractons, which feature fractal-like excitations and do not appear to rely on simple layered structures.
  • Dynamical Foliations: Future research may explore making the foliation "dynamical," allowing layers to fluctuate, potentially leading to entirely new classes of Topological Quantum Field Theories.

Summary updated

Abstract

Foliated fracton order is a qualitatively new kind of phase of matter. It is similar to topological order, but with the fundamental difference that a layered structure, referred to as a foliation, plays an essential role and determines the mobility restrictions of the topological excitations. In this work, we introduce a new kind of field theory to describe these phases: a foliated field theory. We also introduce a new string-membrane-net condensation picture of these phases, which is analogous to the string-net condensation picture of topological order.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{slagle2019report,
  author = {Kevin Slagle and David Aasen and Dominic J. Williamson},
  title = {{Report on 1812.01613v2}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.21468/scipost.report.861},
}
Figure