Report on 1806.08679v1

Wilbur Shirley, Kevin Slagle, Xie Chen, Chenghua LinOpenalex Unknown 2018 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Based on several previous examples, we summarize explicitly the general procedure to gauge models with subsystem symmetries, which are symmetries with generators that have support within a sub-manifold of the system. The gauging process can be applied to any local quantum model on a lattice that is invariant under the subsystem symmetry. We focus primarily on simple 3D paramagnetic states with planar symmetries. For these systems, the gauged theory may exhibit foliated fracton order and we find that the species of symmetry charges in the paramagnet directly determine the resulting foliated fracton order. Moreover, we find that gauging linear subsystem symmetries in 2D or 3D models results in a self-duality similar to gauging global symmetries in 1D.

Introduction

In condensed matter physics, "gauging" is a foundational mathematical tool used to map systems with global symmetries to gauge theories. A classic example is the mapping of the 2D Ising model to the Toric Code. Recently, the discovery of fracton orders—phases where elementary excitations (fractons) exhibit restricted mobility—has sparked interest in their relationship with subsystem symmetries. These are symmetries that act only on specific sub-manifolds of a lattice, such as lines or planes, rather than the entire system.

While a connection between these concepts was suspected, a general, explicit procedure for gauging across diverse lattice geometries was missing. This work establishes a systematic framework for gauging any local quantum model with subsystem symmetry, revealing how the geometry of the original symmetry dictates the mobility of excitations in the resulting gauge theory.

The Gauging Procedure

The authors propose a five-step "recipe" to transform a lattice model with subsystem symmetry into a gauge theory:

  1. Identify Minimal Couplings: Determine the smallest sets of operators that, while not on-site symmetric, can combine to form any symmetry-respecting term.
  2. Assign Gauge Fields: Introduce new degrees of freedom (gauge fields, $\tau$) at the centers of these minimal coupling terms.
  3. Define Local Symmetry (Gauss’s Law): Construct a local "vertex term" that couples the original symmetry charge to surrounding gauge fields.
  4. Modify the Hamiltonian: Replace original interaction terms with gauge-invariant versions by coupling them to the new gauge fields.
  5. Add Flux Terms: Identify independent sets of minimal couplings whose product is the identity and add their corresponding gauge-field products as "flux" terms to the Hamiltonian.
Conceptual overview of the gauging process, transforming a 3D model with planar subsystem symmetry into a 3D foliated fracton model.

Key Insights: Mobility and Foliation

A central result of this framework is the Mobility Correspondence. The "fracton-ness" of the gauged theory is pre-determined by the geometry of the subsystem symmetry. For instance, a charge located at the intersection of three symmetry planes becomes an immobile fracton. If it sits at the intersection of two planes, it becomes a lineon (restricted to a line), and if constrained by only one plane, it is a planon.

Furthermore, the models are described as "foliated" because increasing the system size in the ungauged model requires adding an entire plane of degrees of freedom (a new symmetry generator). In the gauged version, this corresponds to adding a layer of a 2D topological phase, such as a 2D gauge theory.

Key Results

By applying this procedure to various 3D lattices (Cubic, FCC, BCC), the authors successfully unified several known models. Notably, they demonstrated that the famous X-cube model and the checkerboard model are related; the checkerboard model is equivalent to two copies of the X-cube model when derived from an FCC lattice.

Illustration of the 3D lattice operators, including vertex and cube terms, that emerge from the gauging procedure to define models like the X-cube fracton phase.

Beyond discrete models, the authors extended the logic to continuous $U(1)$ tensor gauge theories, relating dipole moment conservation to the emergence of gapless fracton phases. They also identified a self-duality in gauging linear symmetries in 2D or 3D, mirroring the behavior of global symmetries in 1D.

Limitations and Future Work

The current framework is limited to Abelian symmetry groups. Extending this systematic gauging to non-Abelian subsystem symmetries remains a significant open challenge. Additionally, while the paper maps "weak" Subsystem Symmetry Protected Topological (SSPT) phases (stacks of 2D layers), the existence and gauging of "truly" 3D non-trivial SSPTs require further investigation. Future research will also need to explore the detailed braiding statistics of gauge fluxes in more exotic lattice geometries to see if they deviate from standard fracton behaviors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on several previous examples, we summarize explicitly the general procedure to gauge models with subsystem symmetries, which are symmetries with generators that have support within a sub-manifold of the system.The gauging process can be applied to any local quantum model on a lattice that is invariant under the subsystem symmetry.We focus primarily on simple 3D paramagnetic states with planar symmetries.For these systems, the gauged theory may exhibit foliated fracton order and we find that the species of symmetry charges in the paramagnet directly determine the resulting foliated fracton order.Moreover, we find that gauging linear subsystem symmetries in 2D or 3D models results in a self-duality similar to gauging global symmetries in 1D.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shirley2018report,
  author = {Wilbur Shirley and Kevin Slagle and Xie Chen and Chenghua Lin},
  title = {{Report on 1806.08679v1}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.21468/scipost.report.680},
}
Figure