Correction to: Supramolecular deep eutectic solvent: a powerful tool for pre‑concentration of trace metals in edible oil

Peng Sun, Chao Wang, Shuo Li, Nan Li, Yuling GaoAnalytical 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

In the field of analytical chemistry, precision is paramount. Correction notices, while administrative in nature, serve as critical updates to maintain the "source of truth" necessary for experimental replication and theoretical understanding. This paper addresses a significant graphical error in a study regarding the use of supramolecular deep eutectic solvents (SUPRADES) for detecting trace metals in food products.

The Role of SUPRADES in Trace Metal Analysis

The original research introduced a robust method for pre-concentrating trace metals in edible oils using SUPRADES. These solvents represent a class of "green" chemistry tools designed to extract specific analytes from complex matrices. However, the initial publication contained a structural inaccuracy in Table 1, which defines the chemical components of these solvents.

Specifically, the molecular structure for 2-hydroxypropyl-β-cyclodextrin—the primary Hydrogen Bond Acceptor (HBA) used in all six solvent variations—was depicted incorrectly. In chemical research, accurate structural representation is essential for understanding the molecular interactions, such as hydrogen bonding and host-guest inclusion, that enable the solvent to extract metals from fatty matrices like oil.

Chemical Composition and Methodology

The study utilized six distinct Supramolecular Deep Eutectic Solvents (SUPRADES 1–6). These are synthesized by pairing a single HBA with various Hydrogen Bond Donors (HBDs):

  • Hydrogen Bond Acceptor (HBA): 2-hydroxypropyl-β-cyclodextrin.
  • Hydrogen Bond Donors (HBDs): A series of organic acids including DL-lactic acid, Citric acid, Acetic acid, Formic acid, Malic acid, and L-ascorbic acid.

The correction provides the visually accurate structure of the HBA. This molecule features a characteristic cyclic oligosaccharide ring of β-cyclodextrin modified with hydroxypropyl groups. This specific modification is vital as it dictates the solubility and the "cavity" properties of the cyclodextrin, directly impacting its effectiveness in analytical applications.

Key Insights: Structural Precision and Green Chemistry

The correction highlights several important aspects of modern analytical methodology:

  1. Importance of Structural Precision: Even in high-impact journals, errors in complex diagrams can occur. This correction ensures that researchers attempting to replicate or build upon these SUPRADES systems have the correct chemical blueprint.
  2. Cyclodextrins as "Hosts": Using a cyclodextrin derivative as an HBA is a sophisticated approach. Cyclodextrins possess hydrophobic cavities capable of hosting guest molecules while maintaining a hydrophilic exterior. In a supramolecular eutectic solvent, these properties likely enhance selective extraction of trace metals while excluding bulk triacylglycerols.
  3. Tunable Green Chemistry: The diversity of HBDs (naturally occurring acids like malic or citric acid) paired with a single HBA demonstrates how solvent properties can be "tuned" for specific analytical requirements.

Corrected Data Presentation

The primary outcome of this notice is the presentation of the corrected Table 1, which clarifies the chemical identity of the solvents used.

The corrected Table 1, detailing the accurate molecular structure of 2-hydroxypropyl-β-cyclodextrin and its pairings with various Hydrogen Bond Donors (HBDs).

The original structure lacked the explicit representation of the hydroxypropyl substituents on the glucose units of the macrocycle. By rectifying this diagram, the authors ensure that the chemical identity of the SUPRADES used in the pre-concentration process is unambiguous.

Conclusion

This correction restores the integrity of the original study's descriptive data. While it does not introduce new experimental findings, it provides the necessary clarity for future researchers to perform computational modeling or further experimental optimization of SUPRADES-based extraction methods.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2024correction,
  author = {Peng Sun and Chao Wang and Shuo Li and Nan Li and Yuling Gao},
  title = {{Correction to: Supramolecular deep eutectic solvent: a powerful tool for pre‑concentration of trace metals in edible oil}},
  booktitle = {Analytical},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s00216-024-05372-z},
}
Figure