Introduction
This erratum provides a critical correction to the experimental data originally published in Science China Chemistry (2018) regarding a composite catalyst for Friedel-Crafts acylation. The primary focus is the rectification of Figure 9, which illustrates the relationship between catalyst loading and chemical conversion. Accurate data in this area is essential for understanding the efficiency of heteropoly acid encapsulation within metal-organic frameworks (MOFs).
Methodology
The research explores the "ship-in-a-bottle" synthesis of 12-tungstophosphoric acid (HPW) within the pores of a Zr-BTC MOF. This design aims to leverage the high catalytic activity of HPW while mitigating its solubility and leaching issues.
The catalytic performance was evaluated using the acylation of anisole with benzoyl chloride (BoC) at a 1:2 molar ratio. Reactions were conducted at 120 °C for 6 hours. The study varied the weight percentage (wt%) of HPW within the Zr-BTC framework and measured the resulting conversion percentage as a function of the total catalyst content added to the reaction mixture.
Results and Discussion
The corrected Figure 9 (shown below) distinguishes the performance of five different catalyst compositions, ranging from pristine Zr-BTC to various HPW loadings.
The Loading Paradox
A key insight from the corrected data is the non-linear relationship between HPW loading and catalytic performance. While increasing the HPW content generally enhances activity, there is a clear "sweet spot." The 28.2 wt% HPW@Zr-BTC (curve e) emerged as the most effective catalyst, achieving nearly 95% conversion. Interestingly, a higher loading of 32.2 wt% (curve d) resulted in lower conversion rates. This suggests that excessive HPW loading may lead to pore crowding or structural blockages within the MOF, hindering the diffusion of reactants to active sites.
Comparative Performance
At a standard catalyst content of 4 wt% in the reaction:
- 28.2 wt% loading (e): ~85% conversion.
- 32.2 wt% loading (d): ~75% conversion.
- 18.6 wt% loading (b): ~60% conversion.
- Pristine Zr-BTC (a): ~40% conversion.
The significant jump in activity from pristine Zr-BTC to the HPW-loaded composites confirms that the encapsulated heteropoly acid is the primary driver of the acylation reaction.
Conclusion
The corrected data reinforces the effectiveness of the HPW@Zr-BTC system but highlights a critical loading threshold of approximately 28 wt%. Beyond this point, catalytic efficiency declines, likely due to reduced accessibility of the active sites. This correction ensures that future research into MOF-encapsulated catalysts can accurately build upon these findings, focusing on optimizing pore architecture to maintain high activity at even higher loadings.
Summary updated