Can a Supersymmetry-Breaking Mechanism Produce the Spectrum That R(D*) Needs?

Two puzzles in particle physics have been studied almost entirely apart. The first is about the pattern of superpartner masses. If supersymmetry exists, the scalar partners of quarks and leptons cannot all be light: light partners would cause unobserved flavor-changing processes. They also cannot all be heavy, because then the Higgs mass needs delicate fine-tuning. Theorists therefore build mechanisms that make some superpartners light and others heavy for structural reasons. The second puzzle is experimental. B mesons decay into tau leptons more often than the Standard Model predicts, an excess measured in the ratios $R(D)$ and $R(D^*)$. A related excess in the muon-to-electron ratios $R_K$ and $R_{K^*}$ has since largely disappeared. This proposal asks whether a concrete supersymmetry-breaking mechanism can generate the specific, lopsided superpartner spectrum that the supersymmetric explanation of $R(D^{(*)})$ requires. It also asks what that spectrum costs in Higgs fine-tuning once the vanished $R_K$ anomaly is treated as a constraint rather than a target.

The opportunity exists because of a change in the data. The best supersymmetric account of the B anomalies, Revisiting R-parity violating interactions as an explanation of the B-physics anomalies, was built to fit both the tau excess and the muon excess. Two terms need defining here. R-parity is a symmetry that normally forbids superpartners from coupling singly to ordinary quarks and leptons; R-parity violation (RPV) allows such couplings. In that paper, an RPV coupling lets a right-handed bottom squark (the scalar partner of the bottom quark) act at tree level like a leptoquark, a particle that turns a quark into a lepton. The paper had to impose a strange spectrum by hand: all left-handed superpartners pushed out of reach, right-handed ones near a TeV, and the right-handed stau much heavier than the right-handed sbottom. Its fit was limited by mixing between $B_s$ and its antiparticle and by precision measurements of Z-boson couplings. Since then, Constraints on Lepton Universality Violation from Rare B Decays showed that with full LHCb and CMS Run 1 and 2 data, $R_{K^{(*)}}$ is close to 1. It also showed that a fit with free hadronic parameters leaves the new-physics coefficients $C_9^{NP}, C_{10}^{NP}$ consistent with zero. The loop diagrams that once had to produce a large muon effect must now produce almost none. Nobody has asked what spectrum that implies, or whether any mediation mechanism can produce it.

Core Claim

We claim that the post-2022 data turn the supersymmetric explanation of $R(D^{(*)})$ into a sharp, falsifiable statement about the superpartner mass spectrum. The statement has two diagnostic features. The first is a chiral split, meaning left-handed sfermions heavier than right-handed ones. The second is an inverted lepton–quark ordering, $m_{\tilde\tau_R} > m_{\tilde b_R}$. Standard gauge mediation predicts the opposite ordering, because the sbottom feels color while the right-handed stau feels only hypercharge. So if the refit still demands a heavy stau and a light sbottom, ordinary gauge mediation is ruled out as the source. Any viable mechanism must then contain an extra, family- and chirality-dependent contribution that lifts $\tilde\tau_R$.

We propose one concrete candidate, which we call chiral flavor mediation. It combines two ingredients. The first is Higgsed flavor gauge mediation, which gives an inverted hierarchy: light third generation, heavy first two. Here it is restricted to the SU(2)-singlet down quarks and charged leptons. The second is a family-dependent U(1)′ gauge symmetry whose D-term (a positive mass shift from an extra gauge force) raises $\tilde\tau_R$. The left-handed doublets get their masses from a separate, heavier messenger sector.

The new element is not the RPV fit. It is a closed loop: we refit the spectrum with updated data, test whether the mechanism can reach that spectrum, and measure the naturalness price. Each step can fail independently.

Relation to Prior Work

Three papers motivate the question by showing that the spectrum was imposed and never derived. The RPV paper above used a $U(2)_q\times U(2)_e$ horizontal symmetry to organize the couplings. It put in the decoupled left-handed sector by hand and reported only about a 30% improvement in $b\to s\ell\ell$. Its follow-up, B-physics anomalies: The bridge between R-parity violating supersymmetry and flavored dark matter, rescued the Z-coupling problem by adding a flavored dark-matter superfield whose loops cancel the unwanted shifts. It treated squark masses as free parameters, predates the $R_K\approx 1$ data, and never checked Higgs naturalness. We keep the minimal RPV content, update the data, and ask whether a spectrum from a mediation mechanism removes the need for extra fields.

Three papers supply methods for the mediation stage. Flavor mediation delivers natural SUSY and The new flavor of Higgsed gauge mediation gauge an $SU(3)_F$ flavor symmetry broken along the top-Yukawa direction. This gives light stops and sbottoms at 300–600 GeV, first- and second-generation squarks at 4–6 TeV, and a near-degenerate first two generations ($\tilde\delta_{12}<2\times10^{-5}$). These papers note that transitions between the second and third generations should appear in B physics, but they never computed semileptonic observables. They also split generations, not chiralities, and they preserve R-parity. We reuse their loop mass formulas but apply the flavor group only to the right-handed singlets. Lifting slepton masses with a non-universal, non-anomalous U(1)'_NAF in Anomaly Mediated SUSY Breaking supplies the family-dependent D-term technique. It uses a Fayet–Iliopoulos term of about $1.5\times(100\text{ GeV})^2$ and runs the spectrum with SoftSUSY. That paper left its light-stau parameter region, where RPV would be needed, unexplored. We use its charges as a starting template for lifting $\tilde\tau_R$. Auxiliary gauge mediation: a new route to mini-split supersymmetry splits scalars from gauginos but keeps all scalars universally heavy, so it cannot produce the chiral split alone.

Three lines of work constrain the proposal and supply its competitors. Minimal Explanation of Flavor Anomalies: B-Meson Decays, Muon Magnetic Moment, and the Cabibbo Angle shows that a non-supersymmetric scalar $S_1$, with the quantum numbers of $\tilde b_R^*$, plus a charged singlet fits the anomalies at about 5.5 TeV. Semileptonic B-physics anomalies: A general EFT analysis within U(2)^n flavor symmetry fits them with effective operators. It states that flavor symmetry alone is insufficient and that third-generation dominance must be assumed. Constraints on new physics from radiative B decays bounds $\text{Re}(C_7^{NP})\in[-0.018,0.012]$ at $1\sigma$. This bound matters for us because light Higgsinos and stops feed the photon dipole coefficient $C_7$.

Research Program

The first stage is a phenomenological refit that defines the target. We take the RPV operator $\lambda'_{ijk}L_iQ_jD^c_k$ with the $U(2)$ coupling hierarchy of the Trifinopoulos paper, and forbid the baryon-number-violating couplings. We fit $R(D)$, $R(D^*)$, $B_s$ mixing, $B\to\tau\nu$, $Z\to\tau\tau$ and $Z\to\nu\bar\nu$, radiative $b\to s\gamma$, and the full $b\to s\ell\ell$ set with $R_{K^{(*)}}$ near 1. Neutral currents are fit both with sum-rule hadronic inputs and with the data-driven hadronic treatment of the HEPfit analysis, so that charming-penguin uncertainty is carried through rather than assumed away.

Unlike the original work, we do not force the left-handed sector to decouple. The left-handed sfermion mass, the right-handed sbottom and stau masses, and the Higgsino mass enter as free parameters. The output is the region of spectrum space consistent with data, and in particular whether the chiral split and $m_{\tilde\tau_R}>m_{\tilde b_R}$ are still required. If the loop tension with $B_s$ mixing relaxes once $C_9^\mu$ no longer needs to be large, the required spectrum may become less extreme. That outcome would itself be a finding.

The second stage builds chiral flavor mediation and maps its few high-scale inputs onto low-scale spectra. The high-scale inputs are the messenger scale, the flavor-gauge couplings for $D^c$ and $E^c$, the flavor-breaking scales, the U(1)′ D-term and its charges, and the scale of the doublet messengers. Anomaly cancellation for the singlet-only flavor group needs spectator fields, and the RPV couplings must align with the flavor-breaking directions; both must be specified explicitly. The spectra are run with SoftSUSY and passed to flavio. The test is whether the image of the mechanism's parameter space overlaps the stage-one target region, and at what fine-tuning cost.

For fine-tuning we use the standard sensitivity measure

$$\Delta = \max_{p}\left|\frac{\partial \ln m_Z^2}{\partial \ln p}\right|,$$

where $p$ runs over the high-scale input parameters and $m_Z$ is the Z-boson mass. This measure is large when a small change in any input badly shifts the electroweak scale.

The central physics issue is that decoupling the left-handed doublets also makes $\tilde t_L$ heavy, which raises $\Delta$. We will report the minimum achievable $\Delta$ inside the target region rather than hide it. We will also report two collider handles that the mechanism fixes but the simplified models leave free: the ratio $m_{\tilde\tau_R}/m_{\tilde b_R}$, and the gluino mass relative to the light sbottom.

The third stage is the parameter search. The combined chain of spectrum generator, flavor fit, and collider recast is expensive, and the viable region is likely thin and disconnected. We therefore run the batched active search b-CASTOR from Bayesian active search on parameter space: A 95 GeV spin-0 resonance in the (B-L)SSM. It uses a Gaussian-process surrogate, a stand-in model that predicts which untried parameter points will pass the constraints. We compare it against standard Markov-chain Monte Carlo sampling under the same call budget. The search is a tool here, not the contribution. Its job is to make the negative statement "no viable point exists" credible.

Baselines

The naive reference point is the Standard Model with the data-driven hadronic treatment of Constraints on Lepton Universality Violation from Rare B Decays. That paper reports the Standard Model point lying inside the 68% region for neutral currents, but it cannot move $R(D^{(*)})$. All models are scored as $\Delta\chi^2$ against this reference, on one frozen observable set encoded in flavio, with identical hadronic inputs.

The strongest existing competitor for fit quality is the $S_1+\phi^+$ scalar model. It reports $\Delta\chi^2=82$ at mediator masses around 5.5 TeV, but on an older observable set that also included $(g-2)_\mu$, the Cabibbo angle, and the then-anomalous $R_{K^{(*)}}$. That number is therefore not directly comparable. We will refit that model on our frozen set with the same sampler and call budget, restricted to the B-physics and electroweak observables. Beating it means that the mediated model reaches a $\Delta\chi^2$ within about one unit per extra effective parameter while also predicting the mass correlations the scalar model leaves free. A clearly better $\Delta\chi^2$ is not expected and is not the claim.

The strongest supersymmetric baseline is the phenomenological RPV spectrum of the Trifinopoulos paper, refit on the same data. Its reported result is only qualitative: about a 30% improvement in $b\to s\ell\ell$ and an incomplete $R(D^{(*)})$ fit limited by Z couplings. It is the ceiling for the mediated model, because the mechanism can only reach a subset of that paper's free spectra. The mediated model succeeds if it recovers most of that ceiling's $\Delta\chi^2$ with far fewer free parameters.

The $U(2)^n$ effective-operator fit gives a model-independent upper bound on what any heavy mediator can achieve. That paper reports roughly 10% tuning.

The ablation that isolates the key ingredient removes the U(1)′ D-term, leaving flavor mediation with the ordinary gauge-mediated $m_{\tilde b_R}>m_{\tilde\tau_R}$ ordering. If this ablated model fits equally well, the claimed necessity of the extra lepton-lifting contribution is false.

For the search, the reference is b-CASTOR's reported 1,636 satisfactory points against 25 for Markov-chain Monte Carlo in 3,240 calls in the (B-L)SSM. No reported result was found on Lacuna for either method on RPV flavor spectra.

Why not just…?

Why not just use the $S_1$ leptoquark and skip supersymmetry? This is the real threat. On fit quality alone, a free scalar will match or beat any constrained supersymmetric spectrum. Supersymmetry earns its place only if the mechanism predicts correlations that a free scalar cannot: the stau-to-sbottom ratio, gluino and wino masses tied to $m_{\tilde b_R}$, and a computable $\Delta$. If stage two finds that the mechanism reaches the target region only by tuning its inputs until they effectively reproduce free parameters, we will report that supersymmetry adds nothing here.

Why not just refit the phenomenological RPV spectrum with new data and stop? That is stage one, and it is publishable on its own. It cannot, however, say whether the spectrum it needs is producible. The ordering $m_{\tilde\tau_R}>m_{\tilde b_R}$ contradicts ordinary gauge mediation, so the refit alone leaves open whether the explanation is consistent with any known breaking mechanism. The ablation above answers that directly.

Why not attribute everything to hadronic uncertainty? This works for $b\to s\ell\ell$, as the HEPfit analysis shows. It cannot touch the tree-level $b\to c\tau\nu$ ratios, where form factors largely cancel. We adopt the hadronic-uncertainty view for neutral currents by fitting with free hadronic parameters, so our conclusions do not depend on charming-penguin estimates.

Why not just add the flavored dark-matter superfield to fix the Z couplings? That works phenomenologically, but it adds a sector chosen for the purpose. Stage one tests whether, with $C_9$ no longer needing to be large, the RPV couplings required by $R(D^{(*)})$ alone stay below the Z-coupling bound. If they do not, the minimal model fails. That would be a clean negative result, and it would justify the extension.

Proposed Experiments and Decisive Checks

The first decisive check is the refit. If $R(D^{(*)})$ still cannot be fit within the Z-coupling limits when the neutral-current requirement is removed, minimal RPV supersymmetry is excluded as the explanation, and the remaining stages become moot. The second check is the stau-ordering test: whether the preferred region keeps $m_{\tilde\tau_R}>m_{\tilde b_R}$, and whether the D-term ablation loses fit quality. The third check is the overlap between the mechanism's image and the target region, reported with minimum $\Delta$ and with the stop and gluino masses checked against LHC direct searches. A spectrum is kept only if it also satisfies the $C_7$ bound, since light Higgsinos and stops feed the photon dipole. The fourth check is the sampler comparison. It must show that the viable-region conclusion is stable, meaning it holds with both samplers and the same call budget, so that a claimed empty region is not an artifact of search failure.

The outcome is a yes or no, with a price attached, on whether any known supersymmetry-breaking mechanism can produce the $R(D^{(*)})$ spectrum. It also yields a list of collider mass ratios that would falsify a positive answer.

References

  1. Revisiting R-parity violating interactions as an explanation of the B-physics anomalies
  2. Constraints on lepton universality violation from rare <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>B</mml:mi></mml:math> decays
  3. <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>B</mml:mi></mml:math>-physics anomalies: The bridge between <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>R</mml:mi></mml:math>-parity violating supersymmetry and flavored dark matter
  4. Flavor mediation delivers natural SUSY
  5. The new flavor of Higgsed gauge mediation
  6. Lifting slepton masses with a non-universal, non-anomalous <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" altimg="si1.gif" overflow="scroll"><mml:mi>U</mml:mi><mml:msubsup><mml:mrow><mml:mo stretchy="false">(</mml:mo><mml:mn>1</mml:mn><mml:mo stretchy="false">)</mml:mo></mml:mrow><mml:mi mathvariant="normal">NAF</mml:mi><mml:mo>′</mml:mo></mml:msubsup></mml:math> in Anomaly Mediated SUSY Breaking
  7. Auxiliary gauge mediation: a new route to mini-split supersymmetry
  8. Minimal Explanation of Flavor Anomalies: <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>B</mml:mi></mml:math>-Meson Decays, Muon Magnetic Moment, and the Cabibbo Angle
  9. Semileptonic <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>B</mml:mi></mml:math>-physics anomalies: A general EFT analysis within <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>U</mml:mi><mml:mo stretchy="false">(</mml:mo><mml:mn>2</mml:mn><mml:msup><mml:mo stretchy="false">)</mml:mo><mml:mi>n</mml:mi></mml:msup></mml:math> flavor symmetry
  10. Constraints on new physics from radiative B decays
  11. Bayesian active search on parameter space: A 95 GeV spin-0 resonance in the ($B-L$)SSM