Flavor Dependent Mass Hierarchies in Supersymmetry

36 concepts20 papers1 proposal

The Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) historically relied on the assumption of flavor universality—the idea that all three generations of squarks and sleptons share roughly the same mass scale. However, this assumption creates a severe theoretical tension. If all superpartners are light enough to solve the electroweak hierarchy problem, they induce large flavor-changing neutral currents (FCNCs) and electric dipole moments (EDMs) that flatly contradict experimental data. Conversely, if all superpartners are pushed to high energy scales to evade these bounds, the theory loses its naturalness.

To resolve this impasse, a prominent research direction abandons flavor universality in favor of structured, generation-dependent mass hierarchies. By decoupling the mass scales of different superpartners both "vertically" (separating scalars from fermions) and "horizontally" (separating the third generation from the first two), these models satisfy stringent experimental constraints while preserving the core virtues of supersymmetry.

The Vertical Split: Gaugino-Sfermion Separation

The simplest way to protect a supersymmetric model from flavor and CP-violating constraints is to make the scalar superpartners (squarks and sleptons) extremely heavy, while keeping the fermionic superpartners (gauginos) relatively light. This is known as a "split" or "mini-split" spectrum.

This mass gap works as a decoupling mechanism. Heavy scalars suppress the loop-level diagrams that contribute to dangerous physical observables, such as the electric dipole moments of the electron and neutron. As demonstrated by Kane et al. 2010, maintaining a large gap between light gauginos and heavy sfermions naturally brings theoretical predictions in line with strict experimental limits on CP violation. Meanwhile, keeping the gauginos (like the gluino, Wino, and Higgsino) relatively light ensures that gauge coupling unification is preserved and provides viable dark matter candidates, as explored by Kane et al. 2005.

To achieve this separation without manual fine-tuning, models must rely on structural mechanisms that inherently treat scalars and fermions differently during supersymmetry breaking:

  • Geometric Suppression in String/M-Theory: In compactifications of M-theory on seven-dimensional manifolds with $G_2$ holonomy, the masses of gauge-mediating superpartners are structurally suppressed. Acharya et al. 2006 and Acharya et al. 2008 showed that these frameworks naturally yield a split spectrum where scalars sit at 30–100 TeV, while gauginos remain at the sub-TeV to low-TeV scale.
  • Differential Loop Suppression: Alternatively, the mass gap can be engineered through the quantum corrections of gauge interactions. Kahn et al. 2013 introduced "auxiliary gauge mediation," a framework where scalar masses are generated at the two-loop level, whereas gaugino masses are restricted to the three-loop level. This loop-factor separation naturally splits the energy scales of the superpartners without relying on arbitrary parameters.

The Horizontal Split: Gauged Flavor Symmetries

While a uniform vertical split protects the theory from flavor violations, it can introduce fine-tuning back into the Higgs sector. To stabilize the Higgs boson mass naturally, we do not need all squarks to be light; we only need the third-generation squarks (the stop and sbottom) to be light, because they couple most strongly to the Higgs field via the large top quark Yukawa coupling. The first- and second-generation squarks can be safely heavy.

This configuration is known as "Natural SUSY" or an inverted mass hierarchy, where the largest Standard Model fermion masses (the third generation) correspond to the lightest superpartner masses. To make this work, the mechanism that communicates supersymmetry breaking to the visible sector must be sensitive to the generation index. This sensitivity is achieved by gauging the flavor symmetries of the Standard Model.

Standard Universal SUSY            Inverted / Flavor-Mediated SUSY
=======================            ===============================
Mass                               Mass
 ^                                  ^
 |  [1st, 2nd, 3rd Gen Squarks]     |  [1st & 2nd Gen Squarks] (Heavy; evades LHC)
 |                                  |
 |                                  |  [3rd Gen Squarks (Stops)] (Light; natural Higgs)
 +------------------------->        +------------------------->

Craig et al. 2012 and Craig et al. 2012 demonstrated that by gauging an anomaly-free flavor symmetry (such as $SU(3)$ or its subgroups) and breaking it at high energy scales, the gauge bosons associated with specific generations become heavy. When supersymmetry breaking is mediated through these flavor-gauge interactions, the high-scale breaking suppresses the transmission of mass to the third generation. This naturally leaves the third-generation squarks light enough to address the hierarchy problem while keeping the first two generations heavy enough to satisfy collider bounds.

The Froggatt-Nielsen Filter

A parallel approach to generation non-universality uses abelian gauge groups ($U(1)'$) to simultaneously solve the Standard Model flavor puzzle (why particle masses are so widely distributed) and organize the superpartner spectrum.

By assigning distinct, non-universal gauge charges to different generations, the gauge symmetry acts as a filter. Chen 2010 and Chen 2011 utilized this setup to implement the Froggatt-Nielsen mechanism. In this framework, effective Yukawa couplings are generated by higher-dimensional operators suppressed by a high mass scale $\Lambda$:

$$Y_{ij} \sim \left( \frac{\langle \theta \rangle}{\Lambda} \right)^{q_i + q_j}$$

where $\langle \theta \rangle$ is the vacuum expectation value of a scalar field (the "flavon"), and $q_i, q_j$ are the generation-dependent charges. Because the expansion parameter $\epsilon = \langle \theta \rangle / \Lambda$ is small, small differences in gauge charges translate exponentially into large, hierarchical mass splits. The author demonstrated that this single structural choice simultaneously explains the observed fermion mass hierarchies and lifts the masses of problematic sleptons to stable, experimentally viable scales.

Observational Signatures at the Collider Scale

Because these models reject mass degeneracy, they do not produce the generic missing-energy signatures of minimal supersymmetric models. Instead, their highly structured mass spectra leave distinct, qualitative footprints in high-energy data:

  • Heavy-Flavor Decay Chains: When the first two generations of squarks are decoupled or when gluinos are split from scalars, the allowed decay pathways change dramatically. For example, the authors of Kahn et al. 2013 showed that a light third generation forces heavy gluinos to decay preferentially into top and bottom quarks rather than lighter flavors, altering the expected ratio of heavy-flavor jets in collider detectors.
  • Flavor-Dependent Gauge Bosons: Non-universal charge assignments require the existence of new, heavy neutral gauge bosons ($Z'$). Because these bosons inherit the generation-dependent couplings of the underlying flavor symmetry, they do not decay universally. Chen 2010 demonstrated that a flavorful $Z'$ couples differently to electrons and muons, creating distinct dilepton decay rates and forward-backward asymmetries that can be directly distinguished from standard, flavor-universal forces.
  • RG-Invariant Mass Sum Rules: Even when masses evolve from high energy scales down to the electroweak scale via the Renormalization Group (RG), generation-dependent symmetries preserve specific linear combinations of masses. As shown in Chen 2011, these invariant mass sum rules remain constant across energy scales, providing a clean, algebraic target for experimental verification.

Key Foundational Work

Supersymmetric spectrum in SO(10) GUTs with gauge-mediated supersymmetry breaking (1999) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.
SO(10) GUTs with gauge mediated supersymmetry breaking (1999) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.
Some phenomenology of intersecting D-brane models (2005) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.
History & citationVersion 2 · 2026-10-04

Current · Permanent link

  1. Version 2 (latest) · 2026-10-04 · 20 papers
  2. Version 1 · 2026-10-04 · 14 papers
Cite this direction

Latest version (a living page):

@misc{lacuna_supersymmetric_mass_hierarchy_6d852ef5,
  title = {supersymmetric mass hierarchy},
  author = {{Lacuna}},
  howpublished = {Lacuna research direction},
  year = {2026},
  url = {https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/direction/supersymmetric-mass-hierarchy/rdr_6d852ef589d2498e9eaf557a05f68f7b},
  note = {Latest version of a living research direction; cite a version for a fixed text. Accessed 2026-11-20},
}

This exact version (version 2, frozen text):

@misc{lacuna_supersymmetric_mass_hierarchy_6d852ef5_v2,
  title = {supersymmetric mass hierarchy},
  author = {{Lacuna}},
  howpublished = {Lacuna research direction},
  year = {2026},
  url = {https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/direction/supersymmetric-mass-hierarchy/rdr_6d852ef589d2498e9eaf557a05f68f7b/v/2},
  note = {Version 2, frozen 2026-10-04. Accessed 2026-11-20},
}
About

These directions overlap with this one through shared papers.

See something wrong? Report a mistake