In the field of twistronics, stacking two-dimensional materials at precise relative rotation angles provides a powerful mechanism to engineer exotic quantum states. As reviewed by Yuhang Jiang in Physical properties of novel electronic states related to flat band in twisted two-dimensional quantum materials, these twisted structures create moiré superlattices that flatten electronic bands. This flattening suppresses electron kinetic energy and allows strong electron-electron correlations to dominate, giving rise to phenomena like unconventional superconductivity, correlated insulators, and topological phases.
However, theoretical models typically assume a pristine, geometrically perfect lattice. In reality, experimental fabrication introduces structural non-uniformities. Small spatial variations in the rotation angle—known as twist angle disorder—and local mechanical strain can significantly degrade or entirely obscure these delicate quantum geometric properties, a challenge highlighted by Zhihai He in Giant nonlinear Hall effect in twisted bilayer WTe2. Understanding how local structural variations govern macroscopic electronic behavior is critical to unlocking the true potential of 2D heterostructures.
The Puddle Picture and Smeared Transitions
Why does a tiny variation in twist angle or strain have such a massive impact on macroscopic measurements? The core intuition lies in understanding how long-wavelength inhomogeneities break a uniform material into a network of distinct mesoscale "puddles."
In Continuous Mott Transition in Moiré Semiconductors: Role of Long-Wavelength Inhomogeneities, Sunghoon Kim et al. demonstrate that variations in twist angle or local strain create regions with slightly different local electronic properties. When an experimenter tunes a global parameter (such as doping or temperature) to drive a phase transition—like a sharp Mott insulating transition—different puddles reach the transition threshold at different times. Instead of a sudden, collective macroscopic jump in resistivity, the transition is smeared out into a continuous process.
This spatial variation explains why clean, sharp theoretical predictions often manifest as smoothed-out curves in bulk experimental transport data. Similarly, Jingxu Xie et al. observed in Engineering correlated insulators in bilayer graphene with a remote Coulomb superlattice that local variations in twist angle and strain within stacked van der Waals heterostructures disrupt the uniformity of induced quantum states. This structural inhomogeneity leads to inconsistent transport properties, such as the loss of metallic behavior between correlated insulating peaks.
Visualizing the Inhomogeneous Landscape
To confirm that these materials behave like a patchwork of electronic puddles rather than a uniform sheet, researchers must look below the macroscopic scale. Using nanoscale conductivity imaging techniques like Microwave Impedance Microscopy (MIM), Zhaodong Chu et al. directly visualized this spatial heterogeneity in Nanoscale Conductivity Imaging of Correlated Electronic States in WSe2/WS2 Moiré Superlattices. Their imaging revealed that local strain and defects directly alter correlated electronic states across the sample, underscoring the need for local probes to capture intrinsic physics.
This spatial sensitivity is particularly acute for collective electronic modes. In Observation of interband collective excitations in twisted bilayer graphene, Niels C. H. Hesp et al. found that mid-infrared interband plasmons are highly sensitive to local lattice distortions. Because of this, collective excitations frequently manifest inconsistently across a sample, restricted only to specific, optically active patches. Bulk optical measurements average over these variations, masking the true local dynamics and highlighting the challenge of controlling local strain during fabrication.
Strain Gradients and Topological Masking
The disruption caused by structural non-uniformity extends beyond moiré materials to single- and few-layer systems. When a 2D sheet undergoes mechanical deformation, it rarely stretches uniformly. Substrate imperfections or fabrication inconsistencies create localized wrinkles, ripples, and strain gradients, as discussed by Hong Li et al. in Optoelectronic crystal of artificial atoms in strain-textured molybdenum disulphide.
These localized variations fundamentally reshape the local electronic landscape. For instance, Seon-Myeong Choi et al. showed in Effects of strain on electronic properties of graphene that non-uniform deformations introduce complex local phenomena, such as pseudomagnetic fields, that homogeneous approximations completely miss.
When layers slide or shift relative to one another, these imperfections can alter topological behavior. Young-Woo Son et al. demonstrated in Electronic topological transition in sliding bilayer graphene that sub-atomic lateral shifts can trigger electronic topological transitions. However, if a sample contains local ripples or strain gradients, the resulting variations create a highly non-uniform electronic landscape that masks or alters the expected global topological transition. Similarly, surface defects and step edges can shift the local Dirac point position, as shown by Glenn Wagner et al. in Probing chiral symmetry with a topological domain wall sensor, complicating how experimentalists interpret global quantum states like Landau level crossings.
The Danger of Macroscopic Averaging
The challenge of spatial inhomogeneity is a recurring theme across condensed matter physics, bridging 2D van der Waals heterostructures and bulk correlated materials like unconventional superconductors. When a material exhibits strong electronic anisotropy or complex pairing states, local strain and defects can act as extrinsic pinning centers or break symmetries locally.
For example, in Evidence of nematic order and nodal superconducting gap along [110] direction in RbFe2As2, Xi Liu et al. highlight that electronic anisotropy is highly sensitive to local lattice strain. Macroscopic measurements risk averaging over these diverse local states, making it exceptionally difficult to isolate intrinsic material properties from extrinsic environmental effects.
To model these phenomena accurately, theoretical frameworks must explicitly incorporate spatial non-uniformity. As demonstrated by Andrew C. Yuan et al. in Strain-induced time reversal breaking and half quantum vortices near a putative superconducting tetracritical point in Sr2RuO4, self-consistently solving lattice models with spatially varying parameters reveals how local strain can break time-reversal symmetry at domain walls and pin vortices. This local variation explains complex experimental signatures that uniform models fail to resolve—a concept mirroring how local defects create preferential pathways for magnetic flux entry in superconducting thin films, as studied by J. R. Kirtley et al. in Fluxoid dynamics in superconducting thin film rings.
Key Foundational Work
Effects of strain on electronic properties of graphene (2010) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.
Fluxoid dynamics in superconducting thin film rings (2003) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.