Evidence of nematic order and nodal superconducting gap along [110] direction in RbFe2As2

Xi Liu, Ran Tao, Mingqiang Ren, Wei Chen, Qi Yao, Thomas Wolf, Y. J. Yan, Tong Zhang, Donglai FengNature Communications 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Unconventional superconductivity often intertwines with various forms of order, such as the nematic order which breaks the rotational symmetry of the lattice. Here we report a scanning tunneling microscopy study on RbFe<sub>2</sub>As<sub>2</sub>, a heavily hole-doped Fe-based superconductor (FeSC). We observe significant symmetry breaking in its electronic structure and magnetic vortex which differentiates the (π, π) and (π, -π) directions of the unfolded Brillouin zone. It is thus a novel nematic state, distinct from the nematicity of undoped/lightly-doped FeSCs which breaks the (π, 0)/(0, π) equivalence. Moreover, we observe a clear V-shaped superconducting gap. The gap is suppressed on surface Rb vacancies and step edges, and the suppression is particularly strong at the [110]-oriented edges. This is possibly due to a $d_{x^2-y^2}$-like pairing component with nodes along the [110] directions. Our results thus highlight the intimate connection between nematicity and superconducting pairing in iron-based superconductors.

Introduction

In the field of unconventional superconductivity, "nematicity" refers to a state where electrons break the rotational symmetry of the crystal lattice without altering its translational symmetry. In most iron-based superconductors (FeSCs), this nematicity occurs along the [100] direction, corresponding to the Fe-Fe bonds. However, as these materials are heavily "hole-doped," the electronic environment changes significantly. This study investigates RbFe$_2$As$_2$, a material at the extreme end of hole-doping, to determine how nematicity and the superconducting pairing mechanism evolve when the system is pushed far from its parent state.

Methods

The research team utilized Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM) at ultra-low temperatures (down to 20 mK). This technique provided high-resolution topographic imaging of the atomic lattice and surface defects, as well as spectroscopic measurements (dI/dV curves) to map the material's electronic structure. They also employed vortex imaging to observe the shape of magnetic vortices and surface potassium (K) dosing to tune the electron concentration in situ.

Figure 1: STM topography of Type A and Type B surfaces, atomic models, and spectroscopic signatures of the electronic state.

Key Insights: The 45-Degree Twist and Nodal Gap

The most striking discovery is that electronic symmetry breaking ($C_4$ to $C_2$) in RbFe$_2$As$_2$ occurs along the [110] diagonal direction, rather than the [100] Fe-Fe bond direction typical of other FeSCs. This represents a fundamentally different nematic phase.

Furthermore, the superconducting gap exhibits a distinct "V-shape" rather than the "U-shape" characteristic of fully gapped superconductors. This V-shape is a hallmark of a nodal gap, indicating specific directions in the crystal where the superconducting protection disappears.

Figure 2: Detailed dI/dV spectra of the superconducting gap on Type A and Type B surfaces, showing the V-shaped profile and fits to a nodal gap model.

Key Results

  • Gap Fitting: The superconducting gap on the standard (Type A) surface was well-fitted by a nodal function with a maximum value ($\Delta_0$) of 0.47 meV.
  • Edge Sensitivity: Gap suppression was found to be significantly stronger at [110]-oriented atomic step edges. This is a "smoking gun" for $d_{x^2-y^2}$-like pairing, where the nodes of the superconducting wavefunction point along the diagonals.
  • Anisotropic Coherence: Vortex imaging revealed elongated cores. On the standard surface, coherence lengths were $\xi_L \approx 15.0$ nm and $\xi_S \approx 12.5$ nm. On more anisotropic "Type B" surfaces, this ratio increased to $\sim$1.63, suggesting that local strain plays a major role in pinning this nematic state.
  • K-Dosing Effects: Adding electrons via potassium dosing suppressed the diagonal nematicity but increased the superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$) to roughly 12 K. This suggests that this specific type of nematicity may compete with, rather than enhance, superconductivity.

Conclusion

While the [110] nematicity is clear, the exact mechanism driving it—whether spin fluctuations or orbital ordering—remains a subject for further theoretical refinement. Future work will focus on whether this diagonal nematicity is a universal feature of all heavily hole-doped 122-type iron pnictides and how it might be manipulated to achieve higher-temperature superconductivity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Unconventional superconductivity often intertwines with various forms of order, such as the nematic order which breaks the rotational symmetry of the lattice. Here we report a scanning tunneling microscopy study on RbFe<sub>2</sub>As<sub>2</sub>, a heavily hole-doped Fe-based superconductor (FeSC). We observe significant symmetry breaking in its electronic structure and magnetic vortex which differentiates the (π, π) and (π, -π) directions of the unfolded Brillouin zone. It is thus a novel nematic state, distinct from the nematicity of undoped/lightly-doped FeSCs which breaks the (π, 0)/(0, π) equivalence. Moreover, we observe a clear V-shaped superconducting gap. The gap is suppressed on surface Rb vacancies and step edges, and the suppression is particularly strong at the [110]-oriented edges. This is possibly due to a [Formula: see text] like pairing component with nodes along the [110] directions. Our results thus highlight the intimate connection between nematicity and superconducting pairing in iron-based superconductors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2019evidence,
  author = {Xi Liu and Ran Tao and Mingqiang Ren and Wei Chen and Qi Yao and Thomas Wolf and Y. J. Yan and Tong Zhang and Donglai Feng},
  title = {{Evidence of nematic order and nodal superconducting gap along [110] direction in RbFe2As2}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-019-08962-z},
}
Figure