In particle physics, "balancing the books" is a fundamental requirement for a complete theory. When a heavy particle like a $D$ meson or a charmonium state decays, it can transform into a variety of lighter particles. Physicists track these transformations using two primary methods: inclusive measurements, which count the total production rate of a specific daughter particle (e.g., "how many $\phi$ mesons are produced in total?"), and exclusive measurements, which isolate a single, specific decay pathway (e.g., "$D^0 \to \phi \pi^0$").
The central challenge identified across decades of research at the BES and CLEO experiments is that these two numbers often do not add up. The sum of all known exclusive decay modes frequently falls short of the total inclusive rate, leaving a "missing fraction" that points to undiscovered physics or uncatalogued multi-body processes.
The Accounting Problem
The discrepancy between inclusive and exclusive rates is more than a bookkeeping error; it represents a gap in our understanding of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). If we know the total width of a particle—essentially its lifetime—but cannot account for 10% or 20% of where that energy goes, our model of the "strong force" that binds quarks together is incomplete.
For example, JZ Bai and the BES Collaboration performed direct measurements of $D \to \phi X$, finding that while we can measure the total rate of $\phi$ meson production, the specific exclusive channels that produce them are not all documented. This "missing physics" makes it difficult to determine if current models are simply missing complex multi-body decays or if there is a more fundamental misunderstanding of charm decay mechanisms.
Hunting for Missing Modes
To close this gap, researchers perform a "global inventory" of decay products. In Inclusive hadron yields from $D_s^+$ decays, S. Dobbs and J. Libby used the CLEO detector to measure the yields of pions, kaons, and etas. By fitting this data globally, they revealed that a significant portion of the $D_s^+$ meson's decay is driven by "annihilation" processes—where the constituent quarks destroy each other—which are often missed in exclusive searches.
Similarly, Jun Ge and I. P. J. Shipsey targeted specific exclusive hadronic decays involving the $\omega$ meson. By identifying previously unobserved modes, they successfully accounted for nearly the entire inclusive $\omega$ production rate in $D_s^+$ decays, effectively "closing the books" for that specific particle.
Mapping the Charmonium Landscape
The problem is particularly acute in the "charmonium" family—particles made of a charm and an anti-charm quark. Theoretical models predict a gluon-rich environment that should produce a wide variety of hadronic final states. However, many of these remain experimentally elusive.
F. De Mori and J.Z. Bai have led numerous efforts at BES II to find these missing pieces, such as the first measurement of $J/\psi \to \gamma f_2(1270) f_2(1270)$. These rare exclusive decays are essential for mapping the full decay topology. Without them, as noted in work on $\chi_c$ mesons by D. M. Asner and R. A. Briere, we cannot perform the high-precision tests of QCD required to validate the Standard Model.
Precision and the 1% Gap
As detectors have become more sensitive, the "accounting" has become more precise, but the gaps have not entirely disappeared. Recent work by the BESIII Collaboration, led by M. Ablikim, analyzed inclusive decays of $D$ mesons into $K_S^0$. Even with massive datasets, they found a persistent 1% to 2% discrepancy between the total inclusive rate and the sum of all known exclusive paths.
This remaining gap is likely composed of "complex multi-body decays"—scenarios where a particle decays into five, six, or seven daughter particles simultaneously. These are notoriously difficult to detect individually because their signals are faint and easily lost in background noise. However, by quantifying the "missing width," researchers can provide a target for future high-luminosity experiments to finally complete the empirical map of heavy quark transitions.