Observation of the $ψ(1^3D_2)$ state in $e^+e^-\toπ^+π^-γχ_{c1}$ at BESIII

F. De Mori, R. Baldini Ferroli, Lei Li, P. R. Li, T. Li, W. D. Li, X. L. Li, J. F. Chang, G. Chelkov, G. Chen, Z. B. Li, H. S. Chen, J. C. Chen, Mianna Chen, S. J. Chen, X. Chen, H. M. Liu, J. Liu, Y. B. Chen, Jinwei Hu, K. Liu, H. P. Cheng, Tao Hu, Y. Hu, L. D. Liu, G. M. Huang, X. Chu, H. P. Huang, P. L. Liu, G. Cibinetto, J. Huang, Q. Liu, D. Cronin-Hennessy, X. T. Huang, S. B. Liu, H. L. Dai, Yanyan Huang, J. P. Dai, X. Liu, T. Hussain, A. Dbeyssi, D. Dedovich, Q. P. Ji, Z. Y. Deng, A. Denig, Xin Ji, I. Denysenko, Y. B. Liu, M. Destefanis, Lijun Jiang, Z. A. Liu, X. S. Jiang, Y. Ding, J. B. Jiao, Chunfang Dong, Z. Jiao, D. P. Jin, J. Dong, Shi Jin, L. Y. Dong, T. Johansson, M. Y. Dong, A. Julin, N. Kalantar-Nayestanaki, S. X. Du, X. L. Kang, Pengfei Duan, J. Z. Fan, M. Kavatsyuk, J. Fang, B. C. Ke, S. S. Fang, R. Kliemt, X. Fang, Yuqiang Fang, B. Kloss, O. B. Kolcu, L. Fava, F. Feldbauer, B. Kopf, G. Felici, M. Kornicer, C. Q. Feng, W. Kuehn, E. Fioravanti, M. FritscharXiv 2015 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: We report the observation of the $X(3823)$ in the process $e^+e^-\to \pi^+\pi^-X(3823) \to \pi^+\pi^-\gamma\chi_{c1}$ with a statistical significance of $6.2\sigma$, in data samples at center-of-mass energies $\sqrt{s}=$4.230, 4.260, 4.360, 4.420 and 4.600~GeV collected with the BESIII detector at the BEPCII electron positron collider. The measured mass of the $X(3823)$ is $(3821.7\pm 1.3\pm 0.7)$~MeV/$c^2$, where the first error is statistical and the second systematic, and the width is less than $16$~MeV at the 90% confidence level. The products of the Born cross sections for $e^+e^-\to \pi^+\pi^-X(3823)$ and the branching ratio $\mathcal{B}[X(3823)\to \gamma\chi_{c1,c2}]$ are also measured. These measurements are in good agreement with the assignment of the $X(3823)$ as the $\psi(1^3D_2)$ charmonium state.

1. Introduction

The study of charmonium—bound states of a charm quark and an anti-charm quark—serves as a critical testing ground for Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). While states below the open-charm threshold are well-mapped, the spectrum above this threshold is populated by numerous "XYZ" states that challenge standard quark models. Identifying the "missing" conventional states predicted by theory is essential to distinguishing normal hadronic matter from exotic configurations like tetraquarks. This paper reports the definitive observation of the $X(3823)$, identified as the long-sought $\psi(1^3D_2)$ charmonium state.

2. Experimental Methodology

The BESIII Collaboration utilized the BEPCII electron-positron collider to collect data at center-of-mass energies between 4.230 and 4.600 GeV, totaling an integrated luminosity of 4.67 fb⁻¹. The search focused on the specific decay chain: $$e^+e^- \to \pi^+\pi^- X(3823) \to \pi^+\pi^- \gamma \chi_{c1}$$ followed by $\chi_{c1} \to \gamma J/\psi$ and $J/\psi \to \ell^+\ell^-$.

To isolate the signal, a four-constraint (4C) kinematic fit was applied to ensure energy and momentum conservation. The $X(3823)$ signal was extracted using an unbinned maximum likelihood fit to the recoil mass of the $\pi^+\pi^-$ system, $M_{\text{recoil}}(\pi^+\pi^-)$, which identifies the "missing mass" corresponding to the produced particle.

3. Observation of the $X(3823)$

The analysis revealed a clear signal for the $X(3823)$ with a statistical significance of $6.2\sigma$, well above the discovery threshold. The measured mass is $3821.7 \pm 1.3 (\text{stat}) \pm 0.7 (\text{syst})$ MeV/$c^2$, which aligns closely with theoretical expectations for the $1^3D_2$ state.

The recoil mass spectrum of $\pi^+\pi^-$ shows a distinct peak for the $X(3823)$ state alongside the $\psi(2S)$ peak, providing the primary evidence for discovery.

A notable feature of the $X(3823)$ is its narrow width, determined to be less than 16 MeV at the 90% confidence level. This narrowness is a hallmark of the $1^3D_2$ state; parity conservation prevents it from decaying easily into $D\bar{D}$ pairs, leading to a suppressed total width despite being above the open-charm threshold.

4. Production and Theoretical Implications

The collaboration also investigated the production mechanism and branching ratios. The ratio of branching fractions $\mathcal{B}[X(3823) \to \gamma \chi_{c2}] / \mathcal{B}[X(3823) \to \gamma \chi_{c1}]$ was found to be less than 0.42. This specific "fingerprint" strongly supports the $1^3D_2$ assignment over other potential candidates.

Born cross-sections for $e^+e^- \to \pi^+\pi^- X(3823)$ at different center-of-mass energies, compared with fits for the $Y(4360)$ and $\psi(4415)$ resonances.

The energy dependence of the Born cross-section suggests that the $X(3823)$ may be produced through the decay of higher-lying vector charmonium-like states, such as the $Y(4360)$ or $\psi(4415)$, rather than through a flat continuum process.

5. Conclusion

The observation of the $X(3823)$ at BESIII completes a significant portion of the charmonium spectrum. Its mass, narrow width, and decay properties are all consistent with the $\psi(1^3D_2)$ state. While current statistics limit a full spin-parity analysis, this discovery provides a solid benchmark for future studies at BESIII and Belle II, which will aim to further refine the properties of this state and its role in the complex landscape of heavy quarkonium physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report the observation of the $X(3823)$ in the process $e^+e^-\to π^+π^-X(3823) \to π^+π^-γχ_{c1}$ with a statistical significance of $6.2σ$, in data samples at center-of-mass energies $\sqrt{s}=$4.230, 4.260, 4.360, 4.420 and 4.600~GeV collected with the BESIII detector at the BEPCII electron positron collider. The measured mass of the $X(3823)$ is $(3821.7\pm 1.3\pm 0.7)$~MeV/$c^2$, where the first error is statistical and the second systematic, and the width is less than $16$~MeV at the 90\% confidence level. The products of the Born cross sections for $e^+e^-\to π^+π^-X(3823)$ and the branching ratio $\mathcal{B}[X(3823)\to γχ_{c1,c2}]$ are also measured. These measurements are in good agreement with the assignment of the $X(3823)$ as the $ψ(1^3D_2)$ charmonium state.
BibTeX
@misc{mori2015observation,
  author = {F. De Mori and R. Baldini Ferroli and Lei Li and P. R. Li and T. Li and W. D. Li and W. G. Li and X. L. Li and J. F. Chang and G. Chelkov and X. M. Li and G. Chen and X. N. Li and X. Q. Li and Z. B. Li and H. S. Chen and H. Y. Chen and J. C. Chen and Mianna Chen and S. J. Chen and X. Chen and H. M. Liu and X. R. Chen and J. Liu and Y. B. Chen and J. Y. Liu and Jinwei Hu and K. Liu and H. P. Cheng and Tao Hu and Y. Hu and L. D. Liu and G. M. Huang and X. Chu and G. S. Huang and H. P. Huang and P. L. Liu and G. Cibinetto and J. Huang and Q. Liu and D. Cronin-Hennessy and X. T. Huang and S. B. Liu and H. L. Dai and Yanyan Huang and J. P. Dai and X. Liu and T. Hussain and A. Dbeyssi and D. Dedovich and Q. P. Ji and Z. Y. Deng and Q. P. Ji and A. Denig and Xin Ji and I. Denysenko and X. L. Ji and Y. B. Liu and M. Destefanis and Lijun Jiang and Z. A. Liu and F. De Mori and L. W. Jiang and X. S. Jiang and Y. Ding and J. B. Jiao and Chunfang Dong and Z. Jiao and Zhiqing Liu and D. P. Jin and J. Dong and Shi Jin and L. Y. Dong and T. Johansson and M. Y. Dong and A. Julin and N. Kalantar-Nayestanaki and S. X. Du and X. L. Kang and Pengfei Duan and X. S. Kang and J. Z. Fan and M. Kavatsyuk and J. Fang and B. C. Ke and S. S. Fang and R. Kliemt and X. Fang and Yuqiang Fang and B. Kloss and O. B. Kolcu and L. Fava and F. Feldbauer and B. Kopf and G. Felici and M. Kornicer and C. Q. Feng and W. Kuehn and E. Fioravanti and M. Fritsch},
  title = {{Observation of the $ψ(1^3D\_2)$ state in $e^+e^-\textbackslash\{\}toπ^+π^-γχ\_\{c1\}$ at BESIII}},
  year = {2015},
  eprint = {1503.08203},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1503.08203},
}
Figure