Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS) were originally envisioned as "nearly passive" mirrors for electromagnetic waves—arrays of low-cost elements that could steer signals without the power-hungry electronics of traditional base stations. However, as research has matured, a fundamental physical limitation has emerged: multiplicative fading. Because a passive RIS merely reflects an already attenuated signal, the path loss is the product of the transmitter-to-RIS and RIS-to-receiver distances, often rendering the gains negligible in the presence of a direct line-of-sight signal.
To overcome this, the research direction has shifted toward Active and Hybrid RIS architectures. These systems integrate power-consuming components—amplifiers, sensors, and switching networks—to transform the wireless environment from a passive obstacle into a programmable, active participant in the network.
The Multiplicative Fading Bottleneck
The primary motivation for moving beyond passive surfaces is the "double-fading" effect. In a passive RIS setup, the signal must travel two hops, and the resulting path loss is significantly higher than a single-hop transmission. Zijian Zhang and Linglong Dai demonstrate in Active RIS vs. Passive RIS: Which Will Prevail in 6G? that passive surfaces only provide meaningful capacity gains in very specific "dead zone" scenarios.
By integrating reflection-type amplifiers into each element, an Active RIS can compensate for this path loss at the surface itself. This architectural shift allows the surface to provide massive capacity boosts—up to 130% in some experimental setups—by breaking the multiplicative fading bottleneck Active RISs: Signal Modeling, Asymptotic Analysis, and Beamforming Design.
The Energy Efficiency Paradox
While active components solve the signal strength problem, they introduce a new challenge: energy consumption. A truly passive surface consumes zero power, but a practical RIS requires a CMOS backplane and control circuitry to manage phase shifts. Zhaohui Yang and Walid Saad point out that the energy cost of activating a surface may exceed the marginal gain in signal quality Energy-Efficient Wireless Communications with Distributed Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces.
This creates an optimization problem where the goal is to maximize "bits per Joule." Researchers like Yulan Gao and Dusit Niyato have proposed modular architectures and resource management algorithms that selectively "trigger" only the most effective groups of reflecting elements Reflection Resource Management for Intelligent Reflecting Surface Aided Wireless Networks. By treating reflection as a manageable resource rather than an "always-on" utility, networks can achieve high signal quality without prohibitive power overhead.
Hybrid and Multi-Functional Architectures
To balance the low cost of passive surfaces with the performance of active ones, the field is converging on Hybrid architectures:
- Hybrid Relay-Reflecting Surfaces (HRRIS): These integrate a small number of active amplifying elements into a mostly passive surface, as explored by Nhan T. Nguyen and Markku Juntti Low-Latency and Secure Computation Offloading Assisted by Hybrid Relay-Reflecting Intelligent Surface.
- Simultaneously Transmitting and Reflecting Surfaces (STARS): Proposed by Xidong Mu and Zhaolin Wang, these surfaces provide 360-degree coverage by simultaneously reflecting and refracting signals Simultaneously Transmitting and Reflecting Surfaces (STARS) for Multi-Functional 6G.
- RDARS (Reconfigurable Distributed Antenna and Reflecting Surface): This hybrid architecture allows individual elements to switch dynamically between active transmission and passive reflection. Chengwang Ji and Feifei Gao utilize model-driven deep learning to manage these complex mode-switching decisions in real-time Model-Driven Deep Learning Enhanced Joint Beamforming and Mode Switching for RDARS-Aided MIMO Systems.
Integrating Sensing and Communication (ISAC)
The evolution of RIS is not just about signal strength, but also about environmental awareness. By adding a tiny amount of active hardware or sensing elements to the surface, researchers can "short-circuit" the path loss typically found in 6G sensing. Wanli Ni and Dusit Niyato describe Multi-Functional RIS (MF-RIS) that can amplify, refract, and directly sense signals, achieving millimeter-level localization accuracy Multi-Functional RIS Integrated Sensing and Communications for 6G Networks.
Conclusion
The research trajectory for intelligent surfaces is moving away from the "idealized passive" model toward a pragmatic, active-passive hybrid. As Ertugrul Basar notes, the "Ultimate RIS" will likely be a multi-functional device capable of PHY slicing—dynamically multiplexing between communication, sensing, and computing modes Present and Future of Reconfigurable Intelligent Surface-Empowered Communications. The challenge for 6G will be managing the hardware complexity and power consumption of these active components to ensure they remain a sustainable alternative to traditional infrastructure.