Yin-Yang vortex on UTe2 (011) surface

Ruotong Yin, Yuanji Li, Zengyi Du, Dongsheng Yuan, Shiyuan Wang, Jiashuo Gong, Mingzhe Li, Ziyuan Chen, Jiakang Zhang, Yu Guang Wang, Ziwei Xue, Xinchun Lai, Shiyong Tan, Da Wang, Qiang-Hua Wang, Donglai Feng, Y. J. YanarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

This research paper, published by a collaborative team from several Chinese institutions, details the discovery of a unique magnetic phenomenon on the surface of Uranium ditelluride ($UTe_2$), a material long suspected of being a rare "spin-triplet" superconductor.

TL;DR

Researchers have observed a novel "Yin-Yang" shaped magnetic vortex on the surface of $UTe_2$ using ultra-low-temperature scanning tunneling microscopy. This distinct spatial pattern provides direct evidence for spin-triplet pairing and significantly narrows down the possible mathematical descriptions (order parameters) of its superconducting state.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of superconductivity, most materials exhibit "spin-singlet" pairing, where electrons pair up with opposite spins. $UTe_2$ is a prime candidate for the much rarer "spin-triplet" pairing, where electron spins point in the same direction. This state is highly sought after because it can host Majorana fermions—quasiparticles that are their own antiparticles and could serve as the building blocks for fault-tolerant topological quantum computers.

However, confirming the exact nature of $UTe_2$’s superconducting "order parameter" (the mathematical function describing the pair state) has been a major challenge. Different experimental techniques have yielded conflicting results. The authors of this paper aimed to use magnetic vortices—tiny "tornadoes" of magnetic flux that penetrate superconductors—as a diagnostic tool to finally pin down the pairing symmetry.

Methods

The team employed several high-precision techniques:

  • Sample Synthesis: They grew high-quality $UTe_2$ single crystals using a molten salt flux method, achieving a high residual resistance ratio (a proxy for crystal purity).
  • STM/STS: They used Scanning Tunneling Microscopy and Spectroscopy at ultra-low temperatures (~40 mK) and high magnetic fields (up to 8 T). This allowed them to map the Local Density of States (LDOS) with atomic resolution.
  • Theoretical Modeling: To interpret the strange "Yin-Yang" patterns they saw, the team performed numerical simulations using the Bogoliubov-de Gennes (BdG) Hamiltonian. They tested different pairing symmetries ($A_u, B_{1u}, B_{2u}, B_{3u}$) against their experimental data.

Datasets

As this is an experimental physics paper rather than a machine learning study, there are no external "datasets" in the traditional sense. The primary data consists of:

  • Topographic images of the $UTe_2$ (011) surface.
  • Spectroscopic maps ($dI/dV$ maps) showing the spatial distribution of electronic states at varying magnetic fields.
  • Line profiles of the superconducting gap and vortex core states.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Yin-Yang Signature: Unlike standard superconductors where vortices look like simple symmetric dots, these vortices show a "dark-bright" contrast. One half (the "Yang" part) shows a sharp peak in electronic states at zero energy, while the other half (the "Yin" part) shows a surprisingly deep and sharp superconducting gap.
  • Surface State Interplay: The researchers realized this asymmetry isn't a fluke of the vortex itself, but rather an interaction between the vortex and the material's topologically protected surface states. The vortex "distorts" these surface states asymmetrically.
  • Symmetry Constraints: The "Yin-Yang" pattern only appears in simulations when specific spin-triplet pairing conditions are met. Specifically, the $d$-vector (which describes the spin-triplet state) must have at least two non-zero components of comparable magnitude.

Key Results

  • Quantized Flux: The number of Yin-Yang vortices increased linearly with the applied magnetic field, confirming they are indeed quantized magnetic flux tubes.
  • Orientation: The boundary between the "Yin" and "Yang" sections consistently aligns with the crystallographic $a$-axis of the crystal.
  • Coherence Lengths: The team measured the Ginzburg-Landau coherence lengths, finding $\xi_a \approx 15.1$ nm. Interestingly, the "Yang" part of the vortex is significantly smaller ($\sim 4.5$ nm) than the "Yin" part ($\sim 7.5$ nm).
  • Exclusion of s-wave: Theoretical models for conventional $s$-wave pairing failed to produce the Yin-Yang pattern, reinforcing the conclusion that $UTe_2$ is a spin-triplet superconductor.

Limitations and Future Work

While the study provides a "smoking gun" for spin-triplet pairing, it doesn't yet uniquely identify a single pairing symmetry. The results are consistent with three different symmetries ($B_{1u}, B_{2u},$ and $B_{3u}$).

The authors note that further experiments—perhaps looking at different crystal surfaces or using different magnetic field orientations—will be needed to distinguish between these remaining candidates. Additionally, the "Note added" section mentions that two other independent groups recently reported similar findings, suggesting a growing consensus in the field regarding these unique vortex structures.

Summary updated

Abstract

UTe2 is a promising candidate for spin-triplet superconductor, yet its exact superconducting order parameter remains highly debated. Here, via scanning tunneling microscopy/spectroscopy, we observe a novel type of magnetic vortex with distinct dark-bright contrast in local density of states on UTe2 (011) surface under a perpendicular magnetic field, resembling the conjugate structure of Yin-Yang diagram in Taoism. Each Yin-Yang vortex contains a quantized magnetic flux, and the boundary between the Yin and Yang parts aligns with the crystallographic a-axis of UTe2. The vortex states exhibit intriguing behaviors -- a sharp zero-energy conductance peak exists at the Yang part, while a superconducting gap with pronounced coherence peaks exists at the Yin part, which is even sharper than those measured far from the vortex core or in the absence of magnetic field. By theoretical modeling, we show that the Yin-Yang vortices on UTe2 (011) surface can be explained by the asymmetric vortex-derived local distortion of the zero-energy surface states associated with spin-triplet pairing with appropriate d-vectors. Therefore, the observation of Yin-Yang vortex confirms the spin-triplet pairing in UTe2 and imposes constraints on the candidate d-vector for the spin-triplet pairing.
BibTeX
@misc{yin2025yin,
  author = {Ruotong Yin and Yuanji Li and Zengyi Du and Dongsheng Yuan and Shiyuan Wang and Jiashuo Gong and Mingzhe Li and Ziyuan Chen and Jiakang Zhang and Yu Guang Wang and Ziwei Xue and Xinchun Lai and Shiyong Tan and Da Wang and Qiang-Hua Wang and Donglai Feng and Y. J. Yan},
  title = {{Yin-Yang vortex on UTe2 (011) surface}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2503.21506},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.21506},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure