YesU from Bacillus subtilis preferentially binds fucosylated glycans

Joe Tiralongo, Oren Cooper, Thomas Litfin, Yuedong Yang, Rebecca M. King, Jian Zhan, Huiying Zhao, Nicolai V. Bovin, Christopher J. Day, Yaoqi ZhouScientific 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the function of an uncharacterized bacterial protein, YesU, using a combination of computational prediction and experimental validation. They discovered that YesU, contrary to initial predictions, preferentially binds to fucosylated glycans, suggesting a role in bacterial adhesion to the mammalian gut.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how proteins interact with carbohydrates (glycans) is crucial for many biological processes, from cell communication to pathogen recognition. However, these interactions are notoriously difficult to study due to low binding affinities, the inherent flexibility of glycans, and their lack of a simple linear sequence like DNA or proteins. This makes it challenging to predict protein function based solely on sequence or even structure. The authors previously developed a computational tool, SPOT-Struc, to identify potential carbohydrate-binding proteins (CBPs) by comparing protein structures and predicting binding affinity. This study aims to experimentally validate the prediction for one such protein, YesU from Bacillus subtilis, and to precisely determine its glycan binding specificity, which was initially predicted to be for high mannose-type glycans.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Computational Prediction (SPOT-Struc): This technique was used as a starting point to identify YesU as a potential CBP and to predict its initial binding target (high mannose-type glycans).
  • Protein Expression and Purification: YesU was expressed in E. coli and purified to homogeneity using a His-tag affinity purification method.
  • Glycan Array Analysis: This high-throughput screening method uses a surface coated with a diverse library of glycans to identify which glycans a protein binds to.
  • Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR): This technique provides quantitative data on the binding affinity (dissociation constant, K<sub>D</sub>) of YesU to specific glycans identified by the array analysis.
  • Structure-Based Alignment: YesU's structure was compared to known lectins (carbohydrate-binding proteins) to understand its structural similarities and potential functional relationships.
  • Molecular Docking (Vina-Carb): This computational method was used to predict the binding pose and affinity of a specific glycan (Lewis<sup>x</sup>) to the YesU structure.
  • Bacterial Adhesion Assays: The functional relevance of YesU's glycan binding was tested by examining the ability of B. subtilis to adhere to intestinal cells in the presence of different glycans, which could act as inhibitors.

Datasets

  • Glycan Libraries: The study utilized diverse glycan libraries for both glycan array analysis and SPR experiments. These libraries contained a wide range of fucosylated and non-fucosylated glycans, including Lewis antigens, lacto-N-neotetraose derivatives, and high mannose structures.
  • Protein Structures: Publicly available protein structures from the RCSB Protein Data Bank (PDB) were used for structure-based alignment, including YesU (1oq1) and several known lectins (e.g., VIP36, UEA-I, GS-IV).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Computational predictions are a powerful starting point, but experimental validation is crucial: SPOT-Struc correctly identified YesU as a CBP, but its initial prediction of high mannose binding was inaccurate. This highlights the need for experimental verification to refine functional annotations.
  • YesU is a fucose-binding lectin, not a mannose-binding lectin: This is a significant finding, as it contradicts the initial computational prediction and suggests a different biological role for YesU.
  • Structural similarity can be misleading for functional prediction: While YesU shares structural similarities with mannose-binding lectins like VIP36, its actual binding specificity is for fucosylated glycans, aligning more closely with certain legume lectins.
  • Fucosylated glycans are key to B. subtilis adhesion: The inhibition of bacterial adherence by fucosylated glycans strongly suggests that YesU plays a role in the interaction of B. subtilis with the mammalian gastrointestinal tract.
  • The importance of glycan presentation: The study hints that the way glycans are presented on an array or in a biological context can influence observed binding, as seen with truncated versus longer fucosylated structures.

Key Results

  • Glycan Array and SPR: YesU showed significant binding to fucosylated glycans, particularly Lewis<sup>x</sup> (Le<sup>x</sup>) and lacto-N-fucopentaose III (LNFP III), with high affinity (K<sub>D</sub> values around 0.14-0.15 µM). It did not bind to high mannose-type glycans.
  • Structure-Based Alignment: YesU was found to be structurally similar to legume lectins UEA-I and GS-IV, which are known fucose-binding lectins.
  • Molecular Docking: Docking of Le<sup>x</sup> into the YesU structure predicted a binding affinity of -4.3 kcal/mol, with specific residues like His105, Arg133, and Tyr101 implicated in binding.
  • Bacterial Adhesion: Le<sup>x</sup> and Le<sup>y</sup> significantly inhibited the adherence of B. subtilis to Caco-2 intestinal cells (by >50%), while non-fucosylated glycans showed little to no inhibition.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited glycan presentation: The authors acknowledge that glycan array data can sometimes be influenced by how glycans are presented, potentially leading to false negatives. This was addressed by using SPR for quantitative validation.
  • Experimental validation of binding sites: While molecular docking and sequence-based predictions suggest specific binding residues, further experimental studies are needed to unequivocally validate these proposed binding sites.
  • Mechanism of secretion: The paper discusses the possibility of signal peptide/Sec independent secretion for YesU, similar to other bacterial toxins, but the exact mechanism in B. subtilis remains to be elucidated.
  • In vivo relevance: While the study provides strong evidence for YesU's role in adhesion, further in vivo studies would be beneficial to confirm its function in the complex environment of the mammalian gut.

The authors suggest that their work validates the use of computational prediction tools like SPOT-Struc for identifying potential CBPs, but emphasizes the critical need for experimental validation to accurately determine their specific binding targets and biological roles.

Summary updated

Abstract

The interaction of carbohydrate-binding proteins (CBPs) with their corresponding glycan ligands is challenging to study both experimentally and computationally. This is in part due to their low binding affinity, high flexibility, and the lack of a linear sequence in carbohydrates, as exists in nucleic acids and proteins. We recently described a function-prediction technique called SPOT-Struc that identifies CBPs by global structural alignment and binding-affinity prediction. Here we experimentally determined the carbohydrate specificity and binding affinity of YesU (RCSB PDB ID: 1oq1), an uncharacterized protein from Bacillus subtilis that SPOT-Struc predicted would bind high mannose-type glycans. Glycan array analyses however revealed glycan binding patterns similar to those exhibited by fucose (Fuc)-binding lectins, with SPR analysis revealing high affinity binding to Lewis<sup>x</sup> and lacto-N-fucopentaose III. Structure based alignment of YesU revealed high similarity to the legume lectins UEA-I and GS-IV, and docking of Lewis<sup>x</sup> into YesU revealed a complex structure model with predicted binding affinity of -4.3 kcal/mol. Moreover the adherence of B. subtilis to intestinal cells was significantly inhibited by Le<sup>x</sup> and Le<sup>y</sup> but by not non-fucosylated glycans, suggesting the interaction of YesU to fucosylated glycans may be involved in the adhesion of B. subtilis to the gastrointestinal tract of mammals.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tiralongo2018yesu,
  author = {Joe Tiralongo and Oren Cooper and Thomas Litfin and Yuedong Yang and Rebecca M. King and Jian Zhan and Huiying Zhao and Nicolai V. Bovin and Christopher J. Day and Yaoqi Zhou},
  title = {{YesU from Bacillus subtilis preferentially binds fucosylated glycans}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-018-31241-8},
}
Figure