Y-DWMS: A Digital Watermark Management System Based on Smart Contracts

Liming Fang, Bo Zhao, Liming Fang 0001, Hanyi Zhang, Chunpeng Ge, Weizhi Meng, Liang Liu, Chunhua Su

TL;DR

This paper introduces Y-DWMS, a novel digital rights management (DRM) system that leverages smart contracts and digital watermarking to create a robust framework for protecting digital content. By incentivizing reporting and making infringement prohibitively costly through game theory, Y-DWMS aims to fundamentally deter piracy and ensure copyright holders are compensated.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The digital age has made it incredibly easy to copy and distribute digital content like films, music, and books. This ease of replication, however, leads to widespread copyright infringement, causing significant financial losses for creators and rights holders. Existing Digital Rights Management (DRM) systems, while employing various techniques like encryption and watermarking, have proven insufficient in deterring sophisticated infringers or recovering losses effectively. The core challenge is to create a system that not only prevents infringement but also ensures immediate and undeniable compensation for copyright holders when it does occur, even in the face of evolving piracy tactics.

Methods

The Y-DWMS system is built upon several key components:

  • Smart Contracts: These self-executing contracts on a blockchain automate the processes of purchasing, reporting, and compensating. This ensures transparency, immutability, and immediate settlement of rewards and punishments.
  • Digital Watermarking: Each piece of content is embedded with a unique watermark that can identify the infringer if the content is illegally distributed.
  • YODA (Enabling Computationally Intensive Contracts): To handle the computationally demanding task of digital watermarking within the constraints of smart contract execution (e.g., on Ethereum), the paper utilizes YODA. This method allows for efficient and secure execution of complex computations by a selected set of miners, reducing costs while maintaining integrity.
  • Game Theory Analysis: The paper employs game theory to model user behavior. It assumes users are rational, selfish, and greedy. By designing a system where non-infringement is always the dominant strategy, Y-DWMS aims to make the cost of infringement so high that rational users will always choose to comply. This is achieved by creating a competitive environment where informers are rewarded and infringers are heavily penalized.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Infringement as a "Losing Game": The core insight is that by carefully designing incentives and penalties using smart contracts and game theory, the system can make infringement a guaranteed losing proposition for rational users, effectively eliminating it as a viable strategy.
  • Informer as a Deterrent: Rewarding informers significantly amplifies the cost of infringement. An infringer not only faces direct penalties but also the constant threat of being reported by other users seeking rewards.
  • Smart Contracts for Instant Justice: The immutability and automation of smart contracts mean that rewards and punishments are settled instantly and undeniably, removing the delays and uncertainties that plague traditional systems.
  • Countering Countermeasures: The paper demonstrates how Y-DWMS can resist common counter-strategies, such as malicious smart contracts designed to nullify punishments, by making the reward mechanism for informers unpredictable to the infringer.

Key Results

The paper's analysis, primarily through game theory, demonstrates that:

  • Infringement Cost Amplified to Infinity: Under certain conditions (sufficient deposit, large user base), the cost of infringement can be theoretically amplified to infinity, making it irrational for any user to attempt.
  • Copyright Holders Suffer No Losses: The system is designed such that copyright holders are guaranteed to recover their losses, and in many scenarios, they do not bear any losses at all.
  • Informers Always Rewarded: Informers are consistently rewarded for reporting infringements, incentivizing their participation.
  • Resistance to Collusion: The system is designed to resist collusion between infringers and miners, a common vulnerability in other smart contract-based systems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Account Security: The effectiveness of Y-DWMS relies heavily on the security of user accounts. If accounts are compromised through technical means, the system's game-theoretic advantages could be undermined, and tracing such infringements would be difficult.
  • Ethereum Platform Vulnerabilities: While the Y-DWMS design is robust, its implementation on platforms like Ethereum is subject to existing platform vulnerabilities (e.g., DAO loopholes). The paper suggests considering platforms with better access control mechanisms, like Hyperledger.
  • Digital Watermark Robustness: The paper assumes ideal digital watermark algorithms. However, the robustness, efficiency, and implementation difficulty of such algorithms in real-world scenarios still require further proof.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest implementing Y-DWMS on a secure smart contract platform as a crucial next step. Further research into robust digital watermarking algorithms and effective access control systems for smart contracts is also recommended.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the development of information technology, films, music, and other publications are inclined to be distributed in digitalized form. However, the low cost of data replication and dissemination leads to digital rights problems and brings huge economic losses. Up to now, existing digital rights management (DRM) schemes have been powerless to deter attempts of infringing digital rights and recover losses of copyright holders. This paper presents a YODA-based digital watermark management system (Y-DWMS), adopting non-repudiation of smart contract and blockchain, to implement a DRM mechanism to infinitely amplify the cost of infringement and recover losses copyright holders suffered once the infringement is reported. We adopt game analysis to prove that in Y-DWMS, the decision of non-infringement always dominates rational users, so as to fundamentally eradicate the infringement of digital rights, which current mainstream DRM schemes cannot reach.
BibTeX
@article{fang2019y,
  author = {Liming Fang and Bo Zhao and Liming Fang and Hanyi Zhang and Chunpeng Ge and Weizhi Meng and Liang Liu and Chunhua Su},
  title = {{Y-DWMS: A Digital Watermark Management System Based on Smart Contracts}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/s19143091},
}
Figure