X-ray emission in IllustrisTNG circum-cluster environments

Euclid Collaboration, Daniela Galárraga-Espinosa, Massimiliano Bonamente, Stephen G. Walker, M S Mirakhor, Richard Lieu, C. Laigle, E. Bonnassieux, Charlotte Welker, Stefano Gallo, Tony Bonnaire, Jade PasteAstronomy 2026 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the origin of the mysterious "soft X-ray excess" observed in galaxy clusters, which appears as extra emission in lower energy X-rays beyond what's expected from the hot gas. Using the IllustrisTNG cosmological simulation, they find this excess is primarily caused by thermal emission from a warmer, more diffuse gas phase (WARM gas) residing in clumps (WCGM) within clusters and filaments (WHIM) outside them. This suggests the soft X-ray excess can act as a tracer of a cluster's dynamical state.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Galaxy clusters are filled with extremely hot, diffuse gas called the intracluster medium (ICM), which emits strongly in X-rays. However, observations have consistently shown an excess of X-ray emission at lower energies (0.2-1 keV) that cannot be fully explained by the hot ICM alone. This "soft X-ray excess" has been a puzzle for decades, with its origin being debated: is it from thermal emission of a cooler gas component, or perhaps non-thermal processes? Understanding this excess is crucial for accurately characterizing the baryonic content and physical state of galaxy clusters and their surrounding environments.

Methods

The researchers leverage the IllustrisTNG cosmological simulation, specifically the TNG300-1 run, which provides a large volume and high resolution to model galaxy formation and evolution. They focus on the gas within and around 138 simulated galaxy clusters. To analyze the X-ray emission, they divide the gas into three phases:

  • HOT gas: The traditional ICM with temperatures $T \ge 10^7$ K.
  • WARM gas: A broader category with temperatures $10^5 < T < 10^7$ K, further split into:
  • WCGM (Warm Circumgalactic Medium): Denser clumps within the cluster ($n_e \ge 10^{-4}$ cm$^{-3}$).
  • WHIM (Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium): More diffuse gas found in filaments ($n_e < 10^{-4}$ cm$^{-3}$).

They calculate radial profiles of thermodynamic properties (density, temperature, metallicity) and then simulate the X-ray surface brightness for each gas phase. By comparing the simulated emission from these phases to observational data, they aim to pinpoint the source of the soft X-ray excess.

Datasets

The primary dataset used is the IllustrisTNG simulation (TNG300-1 run), specifically focusing on 138 simulated galaxy clusters at redshift $z=0$.

For comparison and validation, they use observational data from:

  • ROSAT: Including data from Bonamente et al. (2002, 2003, 2009, 2022) for soft X-ray excess measurements in various clusters, notably the Coma cluster.
  • XMM-Newton: Used for observations of the Coma cluster (Mirakhor & Walker 2020).
  • eRosita: Used for averaged surface brightness profiles of clusters (Lyskova et al. 2023).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • WARM gas is the culprit: The soft X-ray excess is not from the hot ICM but from the cooler, warmer gas phases (WARM gas).
  • Location matters: The origin of the excess differs depending on the radial distance from the cluster center.
  • Inside clusters ($r < r_{200}$): Dense WCGM clumps within substructures (like satellite galaxies) are the primary source.
  • Near the virial radius ($1 < r/r_{200} < 2$): A combination of WCGM clumps and diffuse WHIM gas in filaments contributes.
  • Outside clusters ($r > 2 r_{200}$): Diffuse WHIM gas within cosmic filaments becomes the dominant contributor.
  • Clumpiness is key: The more clumpy the WARM gas is, the higher the soft X-ray excess, especially within clusters.
  • Dynamical state proxy: The soft X-ray excess appears to be correlated with the dynamical state of the cluster, with more unrelaxed clusters exhibiting a higher excess. This suggests it could be a useful diagnostic tool.
  • Filaments are important: WHIM gas residing in filaments plays a crucial role in the soft X-ray emission, particularly in the outer regions.

Key Results

  • The thermal emission from WCGM clumps and WHIM filaments in IllustrisTNG successfully reproduces the observed soft X-ray excess up to the virial radius, matching observations of the Coma cluster and other massive clusters.
  • The WCGM gas fraction within clusters strongly correlates with the inner soft X-ray excess, with a correlation coefficient of $\sim 0.5$.
  • Outside the virial radius, the soft X-ray excess is primarily driven by the WHIM gas fraction in filaments, showing a strong anticorrelation with substructure fractions.
  • The simulation predicts that the soft X-ray excess is generally stronger in lower-mass clusters and in less dynamically relaxed systems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Resolution: The simulation's resolution (~ kiloparsec) might not fully capture all substructures, potentially affecting the accuracy of inner soft excess estimates.
  • Non-thermal processes: The study focuses on thermal emission and does not account for potential contributions from non-thermal processes like turbulence and shocks, which could influence the soft X-ray emission.
  • Observational challenges: Detecting the soft excess, especially in the outer regions, is challenging due to diffuse background noise and the need for accurate background subtraction. Future missions with better sensitivity and background handling capabilities are needed.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that distinguishing between different structures (clusters, groups, filaments, clumps) rather than just gas phases will be crucial for a more detailed understanding of X-ray emission in circum-cluster environments. They also highlight the potential for future missions like LEM and the Hot Universe Baryon Surveyor to detect WHIM emission.

Summary updated

Abstract

Context. An excess of soft X–ray emission (∼0.2 − 1 keV) above the contribution from the hot intracluster medium (ICM) has been detected in a number of galaxy clusters, including the Coma cluster. The physical origin of this emitting medium above the hot ICM has not yet been determined, in particular, it is unclear whether it is thermal or nonthermal. Aims. We investigate the gas phase and gas structure that reproduce the soft excess radiation from the cluster core to the outskirts best using simulations. Method. By using the IllustrisTNG simulation (TNG300), we predict the radial profile of thermodynamic properties and the soft X–ray surface brightness of 138 clusters within 5 × r 200 . Their X–ray emission was simulated for the hot ICM gas phase ( T ≥ 10 7 K), the entire warm–hot medium at a temperature T = 10 5 − 7 K (WARM), and for the diffuse and low–density warm–hot intergalactic medium (WHIM). Results. The soft excess inside clusters appears to be produced by substructures of the WARM gas phase that host dense warm clumps, that is, the warm circumgalactic medium (WCGM), and the inner soft excess is strongly correlated with substructure and the WCGM mass fractions. Outside of the virial radius, the fraction of WHIM gas that is mostly inside filaments that are connected to clusters boosts the soft X–ray excess. The more diffuse the gas, the higher the soft X-ray excess beyond the virial region. Conclusion. The thermal emission of the WARM gas phase in the form of WCGM clumps and WHIM diffuse filaments reproduces the soft excess emission that was observed up to the virial radius in Coma and in the inner regions of other massive clusters. Moreover, our analysis suggests that soft X–ray excess is a proxy of the dynamical cluster state and that higher excess is observed in the most unrelaxed clusters.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{collaboration2026x,
  author = {Euclid Collaboration and Daniela Galárraga-Espinosa and Massimiliano Bonamente and Stephen G. Walker and M S Mirakhor and Richard Lieu and C. Laigle and E. Bonnassieux and Charlotte Welker and Stefano Gallo and Tony Bonnaire and Jade Paste},
  title = {{X-ray emission in IllustrisTNG circum-cluster environments}},
  booktitle = {Astronomy},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.1051/0004-6361/202556053},
}
Figure