Writing Reusable Digital Geometry Algorithms in a Generic Image Processing Framework

Roland Levillain, Thierry Géraud, Laurent Najman

TL;DR

This paper presents a generic framework for implementing digital topology algorithms using the Generic Programming paradigm in C++. This approach allows algorithms to be written once and reused across various image types and dimensions, significantly improving reusability and reducing development costs for digital topology software.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mathematical Morphology (MM) and Digital Topology (DT) are powerful tools for image analysis, grounded in abstract mathematical principles. However, existing software implementations often fail to leverage this generality. Algorithms are frequently reimplemented for specific image types, neighborhoods, or value types, leading to a lack of reusability and hindering cross-domain experimentation. This paper addresses the challenge of creating reusable and generic digital topology algorithms that can adapt to diverse image data structures and computational contexts.

Methods

The core of this work lies in the application of the Generic Programming (GP) paradigm, particularly within the C++ language. The authors propose a framework that defines essential "concepts" for image processing, such as Image, Site_Set, and Site. These concepts act as contracts, specifying the required interfaces and services that data types must provide to be compatible with generic algorithms.

A key algorithm demonstrated is a generic implementation of homotopic skeletonization by thinning, based on the removal of "simple points." The paper presents a generalized version of this algorithm (Algorithm 1.2) that accepts flexible input functions (functors) for determining point simplicity, detaching points, and applying constraints. This generic algorithm is then implemented in C++ (Algorithm 1.3) using the Milena image processing platform, showcasing how abstract mathematical operations can be translated into reusable code. The framework supports various data structures, including grids, graphs, and complexes, and allows for specialized implementations for performance optimization.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it uses standard image types for demonstration purposes:

  • 2D binary images (regular grid)
  • 3D binary images (cubical grid)
  • Triangle mesh surfaces (simplicial 2-complexes)

These examples are used to illustrate the application of the generic thinning algorithm across different dimensionalities and topological structures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Genericity is Key to Reusability: The paper strongly advocates that software for digital topology should mirror the abstract and general nature of its underlying mathematics. Generic programming provides the tools to achieve this.
  • Concepts as Contracts: Defining clear "concepts" (interfaces) for image processing elements (like images, sites, and neighborhoods) is crucial for enabling generic algorithms to interact with diverse data types.
  • Functors for Flexibility: Using function objects (functors) as parameters for algorithms like simple point detection and detachment allows for easy customization and adaptation to different topological definitions and constraints.
  • Cross-Domain Applicability: The proposed framework is not limited to a single domain. It demonstrates successful application to grid-based images (2D and 3D) and more complex structures like triangle meshes, highlighting its broad utility.
  • Performance vs. Genericity Balance: While genericity is paramount, the paper acknowledges the need for performance. It suggests that specialized implementations of generic algorithms can be developed for specific data types or topologies to achieve significant speedups.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates the successful implementation of a generic breadth-first thinning algorithm within the Milena framework. This algorithm has been applied to:

  • Compute skeletons of 2D binary images, with and without constraints (e.g., preserving end points).
  • Compute skeletons of 3D binary images.
  • Compute thick and thin skeletons of 3D mesh surfaces, showcasing its ability to handle complex topological structures.

Execution times are provided in Table 1, showing that the generic implementation is efficient, with times ranging from 0.08 seconds for simple 2D images to 159.53 seconds for complex mesh processing. The paper also briefly mentions the extension to gray-level images, demonstrating the extensibility of the approach.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Extensibility: The authors suggest future work could involve extending the framework to handle more complex data structures (e.g., combinatorial maps, orders) and developing more sophisticated generic algorithms.
  • Gray-Level Images: While the paper mentions the possibility of extending to gray-level images, the primary focus and illustrations are on binary images. Further development and detailed evaluation for gray-level processing could be explored.
  • Performance Optimization: While the generic approach is efficient, the paper notes that specialized implementations can offer further performance gains. Future work could focus on developing more advanced optimization strategies and tools for users to create highly optimized versions of generic algorithms.
  • New Algorithms: The framework is presented as a foundation for implementing reusable digital topology algorithms. Future work could involve porting and adapting a wider range of existing digital topology algorithms to this generic paradigm.

Summary updated

Abstract

Digital Geometry software should reflect the generality of the underlying mathe- matics: mapping the latter to the former requires genericity. By designing generic solutions, one can effectively reuse digital geometry data structures and algorithms. We propose an image processing framework focused on the Generic Programming paradigm in which an algorithm on the paper can be turned into a single code, written once and usable with various input types. This approach enables users to design and implement new methods at a lower cost, try cross-domain experiments and help generalize results
BibTeX
@inproceedings{levillain2010writing,
  author = {Roland Levillain and Thierry Géraud and Laurent Najman},
  title = {{Writing Reusable Digital Geometry Algorithms in a Generic Image Processing Framework}},
  booktitle = {WADGMM},
  year = {2010},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=6F6k2TL1MI},
}
Figure