WITHDRAWN: Modified Borden Grading System For Cranial And Spinal Dural Arteriovenous Fistulas In Neuroendovsacular Era

Xianli Lv, K. Zhu, Jiangdian WangResearch Square 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Objective: Dural arteriovenous fistulas (DAVFs) represent a complex challenge in neurovascular surgery. This study proposes a practical, unified grading system to streamline clinical assessment. Methods: A retrospective analysis of 143 consecutive DAVF patients was performed. Patients were categorized into modified Borden types I, II, and III. Clinical characteristics and outcomes were compared against traditional Borden and Cognard systems. Results: Type III DAVFs significantly correlated with male sex and non-sinus locations ($p < 0.001$). High-grade lesions (Types II and III) were associated with complex arterial supply ($p = 0.003$) and worse clinical presentations ($p < 0.001$). The modified Borden system showed superior statistical correlation with pre-treatment disability (pre-mRS) compared to the Cognard system. Conclusions: The modified Borden grading system provides an effective, simplified framework for assessing risk and guiding therapy for both cranial and spinal DAVFs.

Introduction

Dural Arteriovenous Fistulas (DAVFs) are abnormal shunts between meningeal arteries and dural venous sinuses or cortical veins. Their clinical presentation varies wildly, from benign tinnitus to life-threatening intracranial hemorrhage. Accurate classification is critical for risk stratification and treatment planning. Historically, the Borden and Cognard systems have been the gold standards. However, the Borden system is often seen as too broad, while the Cognard system, with its five types and multiple subtypes, can be overly complex for rapid clinical decision-making. Furthermore, neither system perfectly unifies cranial and spinal lesions.

The Modified Borden Classification

The researchers propose a "Modified Borden Grading System" that simplifies the vascular architecture into three distinct tiers based on the destination and direction of venous drainage.

Table 1: Comparison of major DAVF classification systems and the proposed Modified Borden types (2021).

The three types are defined as follows:

  • Type I: Drainage directly into dural venous sinuses with antegrade flow. These are generally benign.
  • Type II: Drainage into dural sinuses but with retrograde flow into ophthalmic or bridging veins. These carry a higher risk of venous hypertension.
  • Type III: Drainage directly into pial veins without dural sinus involvement. These carry the highest risk of hemorrhage and neurological deficit.

Clinical Analysis and Results

The study analyzed 143 patients (97 male, 46 female) with a mean age of 46. The statistical analysis revealed that the Modified Borden system more effectively separated patients by clinical severity than the more granular Cognard system.

Table 2: Clinical characteristics, presentation, and treatment modalities stratified by Modified Borden Type.

Key findings include:

  • Symptom Correlation: Type I patients typically presented with benign symptoms like pulsatile tinnitus. In contrast, Type III patients were the only group to present with intracranial hemorrhage (35.3%).
  • Treatment Modalities: The classification system successfully guided treatment choices. Type III lesions were predominantly treated via transarterial embolization (TAE), while Type II lesions often required transvenous embolization (TVE) to address sinus-related issues.
  • Statistical Significance: The correlation between the Modified Borden type and pre-treatment neurological disability (mRS) was highly significant ($p = 4.3 \times 10^{-6}$), outperforming the Cognard system in clearly delineating patient risk groups.

Discussion

The core insight of this research is that anatomical complexity does not always equal clinical utility. While the Cognard system provides minute detail, the 3-tier Modified Borden system provides a clearer "universal language" for neurointerventionalists. By grouping spinal DAVFs and cavernous carotid fistulas (CCFs) under the same rubric, clinicians can apply a consistent logic to diverse vascular pathologies. The study reinforces that the direction of drainage is the primary driver of clinical danger.

Conclusion and Limitations

The Modified Borden grading system offers a precise yet simple tool for the modern neuroendovascular era. It effectively bridges the gap between complex angioarchitecture and clinical risk.

However, readers should note that this paper is currently marked as withdrawn for author corrections. While the underlying logic is compelling, the specific data points should be treated as preliminary until a final version is published. Additionally, as a retrospective single-center study, further multi-center prospective validation is required to confirm these findings globally.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Objective:</bold> Dural arteriovenous fistulas (DAVFs) is a complex condition in neurovascular surgery. Many DAVF classifications have been reported and have changed over time in the literatures. The purposes of this study was to propose a practical and easy-to-follow grading system for DAVFs. <bold>Methods:</bold> From a retrospective analysis of our database, 143 DAVF patients were consecutively collected. Patients were grouped into modified Borden types I, II and III. Patients’ characteristics, treatment and outcomes were analyzed between 3 types. Patients’ pre-treatment status(pre-mRS) were analyzed between Borden, Cognard and modified Borden grading systems. <bold>Results:</bold> Male and non-sinus locations were statistically significantly correlated with the type III DAVF type (p&lt;0.001). More than 3 pedical suppliers and pial arterial suppliers were associated with high grade (type II and III) DAVFs(p=0.003). Worse symptoms were present in most type II and type III patients(p&lt;0.001). Type III DAVF was associated with TAE and type II DAVF was associated with TVE treatment modalities(p&lt;0.001). The results of one-way ANOVA indicated that pre-mRS was significantly different within modified Borden types and Cognard types (p = 4.3×10 <sup>-6</sup> and p = 1×10 <sup>-4</sup> , respectively). In terms of pre-mRS, patients were not separated well using Cognard grading systems. <bold>Conclusions:</bold> A modified grading system of cerebral and spinal DAVFs was promoted according to understanding of angioarchitectures in order to evaluate risk of DAVFs and guide the therapies of these lesions. The modified Borden grading system was informative by providing an effective assessment for the risk of patients with simple but precise results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lv2021withdrawn,
  author = {Xianli Lv and K. Zhu and Jiangdian Wang},
  title = {{WITHDRAWN: Modified Borden Grading System For Cranial And Spinal Dural Arteriovenous Fistulas In Neuroendovsacular Era}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-810322/v1},
}
Figure