Abstract
Conventional wireless techniques are becoming inadequate for beyond fifth-generation (5G) networks due to latency and bandwidth considerations. To improve the error performance and throughput of wireless communication systems, we propose physical layer network coding (PNC) in an intelligent reflecting surface (IRS)-assisted environment. We consider an IRS-aided butterfly network, where we propose an algorithm for obtaining the optimal IRS phases. Also, analytic expressions for the bit error rate (BER) are derived. The numerical results demonstrate that the proposed scheme significantly improves the BER performance. For instance, the BER at the relay in the presence of a 32-element IRS is three orders of magnitudes less than that without an IRS.
Introduction
As we move toward 6G, wireless networks face a "bandwidth-latency" squeeze. While millimeter-wave (mm-Wave) bands offer high speeds, they suffer from severe path loss and blockages. Physical Layer Network Coding (PNC) is a promising technique to boost throughput by allowing a relay to process overlapping signals from multiple sources simultaneously—effectively treating interference as a computation—rather than receiving them sequentially.
However, PNC is highly sensitive to channel conditions. If signals arriving at the relay are poorly aligned or weak, the network-coded message becomes garbled. This research addresses this by introducing an Intelligent Reflecting Surface (IRS)—a programmable surface that can steer and phase-align incoming waves—to create a more favorable propagation environment for network coding.
System Model
The researchers focus on the classic butterfly network topology, which consists of two sources ($S_1, S_2$), one relay, and two destinations ($D_1, D_2$). In this setup, the IRS is deployed to assist the transmission from the sources to the relay.
Methodology
The technical approach involves two main contributions:
- Joint Optimization Algorithm: The goal is to minimize the Mean Squared Error (MSE) of the signal at the relay. Since optimizing both the relay's beamforming matrix and the IRS phase shifts simultaneously is a non-convex problem, the authors propose an iterative two-step algorithm. It first calculates the optimal Minimum Mean Square Error (MMSE) estimator for a fixed IRS state, then updates the IRS phase profile using matrix lifting and Difference-of-Convex (DC) programming.
- Analytical BER Derivation: The authors derived closed-form mathematical expressions for the Bit Error Rate (BER) at both the relay and the final destinations, providing a theoretical foundation for performance under Rayleigh fading.
Key Results
Numerical results obtained via Monte-Carlo simulations demonstrate that the "intelligence" in the surface—the specific optimization of phases—is what drives performance gains. Random IRS phases provide almost no benefit compared to the optimized approach.
As shown in the results, using an IRS with 32 elements reduced the BER at the relay by three orders of magnitude compared to a setup without an IRS. Furthermore, to achieve a target BER of $10^{-2}$ at the relay, the optimized IRS scheme provided an 18 dB gain over using an IRS with random phases. Performance improves rapidly as the number of reflecting elements ($M$) increases, suggesting high scalability for larger surfaces.
Discussion and Future Work
While the IRS massively improves the BER at the relay, the improvement at the final destination is slightly less dramatic. This is because the direct links between sources and destinations, which do not always utilize the IRS, eventually become the performance bottleneck.
Future work may explore the deployment of multiple IRSs to specifically enhance these direct source-to-destination links. Additionally, addressing the overhead of Channel State Information (CSI) estimation for hundreds of elements and adapting the system for high-mobility environments remain critical challenges for real-world 6G implementation.
Summary updated