Wildlife population trends in protected areas predicted by national socio-economic metrics and body size

Megan Barnes, Ian D. Craigie, Luke B. Harrison, Jonas Geldmann, Ben Collen, Sarah Whitmee, Andrew Balmford, Neil Burgess, Thomas M. Brooks, Marc Hockings, Stephen WoodleyNature Communications 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that protected areas (PAs) globally are generally maintaining wildlife populations, with trends being more positive in countries with higher development scores and for larger-bodied species. This highlights the crucial role of socio-economic conditions and targeted management in successful conservation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Globally, protected areas (PAs) are a cornerstone of biodiversity conservation, aiming to safeguard wildlife populations. However, there's a significant knowledge gap regarding their actual effectiveness. While it's often assumed PAs successfully maintain wildlife, documented population declines within some PAs suggest this isn't universally true. Furthermore, the factors influencing these trends are poorly understood. This paper addresses this by investigating what characteristics of PAs and their surrounding environments predict positive wildlife population trends, aiming to inform better conservation strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed linear mixed-effects models to analyze a global dataset of wildlife population trends. This statistical approach is well-suited for hierarchical data structures, allowing them to account for variations at the species, PA, and national levels. They built separate models for global trends, and then for birds and mammals specifically, as well as for the regions of Africa and Europe due to data availability. Model selection was guided by an information-theoretic approach (AICc) and involved forward/backward stepwise selection, testing interactions and polynomials, and careful handling of collinear variables.

Datasets

The study utilized a comprehensive dataset comprising:

  • 1,902 population abundance time series from 447 terrestrial protected areas (PAs) across 72 countries.
  • These time series covered 556 species of birds and mammals, spanning periods from 1970 to 2010.
  • Data for explanatory variables were sourced from various global databases, including those related to socio-economic indicators (e.g., Human Development Index, Gini index), local human impacts (e.g., road density, land-use change), and biophysical contexts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • PAs are generally effective, but not universally: The finding that PAs, on average, maintain wildlife populations is encouraging, but the significant variation suggests that "one size fits all" conservation doesn't work.
  • Development matters: Higher national development scores are strongly linked to better wildlife trends within PAs. This could be due to increased resources for management, reduced reliance on PA resources for livelihoods, or a combination of factors.
  • Big is often better (for trends): Larger-bodied species tend to show more positive population trends. This suggests that active management efforts, often prioritized for charismatic large species, can effectively counteract their inherent disadvantages like lower reproductive rates.
  • Small species need direct attention: The positive trend for larger species implies that conservation efforts focused on iconic taxa might not automatically benefit smaller species, highlighting the need for species-specific management.
  • Socio-economic context trumps PA design: Surprisingly, factors like PA size or shape had no significant explanatory power in the models. This suggests that the socio-economic conditions surrounding PAs are more critical for wildlife maintenance than the physical design of the PA itself.

Key Results

  • Overall trend: The mean annual change in population size within PAs was slightly positive (0.52%), with a median of 0.81%.
  • Species differences: Bird populations showed marginally positive trends (mean 1.72%), while mammal trends were slightly negative (mean -1.00%).
  • Regional differences: Trends in Europe were more positive (mean 2.05%) than in Africa (mean -1.79%).
  • Body mass effect: Larger-bodied species consistently showed more positive population trends across most models, indicating that PAs are more effective at maintaining them.
  • Development effect: Higher Human Development Index (HDI) scores were strongly correlated with more positive population trends.
  • Other factors: Increased road density and land-use change were also associated with positive trends in some models, potentially indicating a "filter effect" where PAs in historically impacted areas are now experiencing recovery.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data bias: The dataset is dominated by large mammalian herbivores and waterfowl, and the data pre-dates the recent surge in poaching of elephants and rhinos, which could skew results.
  • Geographic bias: While global, the analysis is limited by data availability, with insufficient sample sizes for some geographic regions.
  • Scale of analysis: Key socio-economic variables were only consistently available at the national scale, not at finer spatial resolutions relative to PAs.
  • PA design: The lack of significance for PA design variables (size, shape) doesn't mean they are unimportant, but their influence might be overwhelmed by other factors over the study's timescale.

Future work could focus on:

  • Targeting smaller species: Developing management strategies specifically for smaller-bodied species.
  • Addressing developing regions: Implementing extra efforts to retain species in developing countries, where human dependence on PA resources is higher.
  • Understanding complex relationships: Further exploring the nuanced interplay between socio-economic factors, anthropogenic impacts, and wildlife trends.
  • Adaptive management: Emphasizing the need for systematic monitoring and adaptive management to respond to evolving threats and ensure long-term conservation success.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ensuring that protected areas (PAs) maintain the biodiversity within their boundaries is fundamental in achieving global conservation goals. Despite this objective, wildlife abundance changes in PAs are patchily documented and poorly understood. Here, we use linear mixed effect models to explore correlates of population change in 1,902 populations of birds and mammals from 447 PAs globally. On an average, we find PAs are maintaining populations of monitored birds and mammals within their boundaries. Wildlife population trends are more positive in PAs located in countries with higher development scores, and for larger-bodied species. These results suggest that active management can consistently overcome disadvantages of lower reproductive rates and more severe threats experienced by larger species of birds and mammals. The link between wildlife trends and national development shows that the social and economic conditions supporting PAs are critical for the successful maintenance of their wildlife populations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{barnes2016wildlife,
  author = {Megan Barnes and Ian D. Craigie and Luke B. Harrison and Jonas Geldmann and Ben Collen and Sarah Whitmee and Andrew Balmford and Neil Burgess and Thomas M. Brooks and Marc Hockings and Stephen Woodley},
  title = {{Wildlife population trends in protected areas predicted by national socio-economic metrics and body size}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1038/ncomms12747},
}
Figure